Gym owners accuse Quebec of ignoring them

QUEBEC CITY — An association representing gym owners accuses the government of ignoring them as it tries to establish a dialogue to find a way to open fitness centers safely.

© Provided by The Canadian Press

“It’s not just answers that are not satisfactory, denounces Gabriel Hardy, spokesperson for Quebec for the Canadian Council of the Fitness Industry (CCICP). It’s really: no answer, no listening, no exchange.

Mr. Hardy says he had meetings with the government in November 2020 and discussed the future of the industry in times of the pandemic and possible solutions. “We could see that we would not get out of it easily [de la pandémie]. We had made proposals that went in that direction. We had plenty of avenues to help the industry get through. None of these proposals has been recognized.”

The CCICP spokesperson, who is also the owner of Le Chalet gym in Quebec, says the government has been turning a deaf ear ever since. “Despite the fact that we sent letters, that we communicated regularly, not only with public health, but the Ministry of Economy, the Ministry of Labor, the Deputy Ministry of Sport.”

The lack of openness is such that the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) decided to intervene by sending a letter to the Minister of Health, Christian Dubé, to draw the attention of the government. The communication sent Tuesday by e-mail would still not have obtained a response, says Francis Bérubé, senior policy analyst at the CFIB.

The questions from the fitness industry are “legitimate,” says Bérubé. He points out that industry representatives have put forward “innovative” proposals that would not have received responses. “Considering the little feedback we are currently receiving, we thought it appropriate to write a joint letter.”

Mr. Bérubé notes that fitness centers arrive between “two chairs”. The tourism sector, also shaken by the pandemic, can exchange with the Ministry of Tourism, gives the analyst as an example. “Fitness centers affect a bit of everything. It affects health, it affects the economy, it affects sport.

It was not possible to obtain a reaction from the Ministry of Health, which we contacted in the morning.

Video: Around the world restrictions for non-vaccinated (Le Devoir)

Around the world of restrictions for the unvaccinated

  • Who are the vaccinated in intensive care?
    Who are the vaccinated in intensive care?
    Who are the vaccinated in intensive care? Half of the people who end up in intensive care units due to a severe form of COVID-19 are not vaccinated, said Prime Minister François Legault last week. The other half, on the other hand, is vaccinated, hence the skepticism of some with regard to the effectiveness of the vaccine, whose protective virtues are nevertheless constantly being praised. However, these people, although adequately vaccinated, are all immunocompromised due to an organ transplant, chemotherapy, hemodialysis or an autoimmune disease, which prevented them from developing good immune defenses. following the vaccination, supports Dr. Madeleine Durand, specialist in internal medicine at the Hospital Center of the University of Montreal (CHUM). No one adequately vaccinated and with a healthy immune system has yet been admitted to a CHUM intensive care unit. Of those vaccinated in intensive care, about half had been transferred to that unit because their condition had seriously worsened due to COVID-19. The other half were staying there for another medical reason, but since they were tested positive on admission to the hospital, these patients who often have mild COVID-19 are still included in the statistics counting patients with COVID-19 who are in an intensive care unit. “So we cannot say that the vaccine has not worked for these kinds of patients, because they are not in intensive care for their COVID-19, but to treat something else. […]“says Dr. Madeleine Durand. These patients who are adequately vaccinated, but vulnerable due to their pre-existing medical condition, “are very dependent on herd immunity. They are not safe if the others are not vaccinated,” she explains. “All of our organ transplant recipients, all of the individuals on hemodialysis, all of the very elderly depend on the vaccination of everyone else!”, she recalls.

    Logo of Le Devoir: Le Devoir smallFavicon
    The duty

  • French actor Gaspard Ulliel is dead
    French actor Gaspard Ulliel is dead
    French actor Gaspard Ulliel is dead Caesarized actor Gaspard Ulliel, known for his portrayal of Yves Saint Laurent, died Wednesday at the age of 37, after a skiing accident in Savoie, his family announced in a press release. “Victim of a ski accident” on Tuesday, the actor “died”, indicates this brief press release. “Gaspard Ulliel grew up with cinema and cinema grew with him. They loved each other madly. It is with a heavy heart that we will now see his most beautiful interpretations and meet this certain look. We are losing a French actor,” immediately reacted Prime Minister Jean Castex on Twitter. He was known to the general public for films such as A Long Engagement Sunday (2004) by Jean-Pierre Jeunet, Saint Laurent (2014) by Bertrand Bonello and Just the End of the World (2016) by Xavier Dolan, which earned him the César for best actor in 2017. He played a writer reuniting with his family after twelve years of absence, to whom he came to announce his impending death. During an eclectic career, he had toured alongside big names in French cinema, such as Isabelle Huppert and Gérard Depardieu. Angel’s face and slight gash linked to a dog scratch in childhood, i Leading a career in France but also internationally, he was soon to be featured in the Marvel series Moon Knight broadcast on Disney +.

    Logo of Le Devoir: Le Devoir smallFavicon
    The duty

  • Should the N95 mask replace the blue mask?
    Should the N95 mask replace the blue mask?
    Should the N95 mask replace the blue mask? Faced with the Omicron wave, the United States Centers for Disease Prevention and Control (CDC) have just changed their tune and now judge the N95 mask to be the most effective, resetting the cloth masks to the last rank. What about Quebec, when community transmission is in full swing and congested hospitals are ready, if necessary, to reduce the minimum quality of care? Some experts say that an increase in protection is needed as soon as possible, others that the simple surgical mask still does the trick. “The surgical mask is effective if it meets strict standards. In practice, we see that it stems infections as well as the N95 mask, ”says Dr. Stéphane Perron, medical advisor at the National Institute of Public Health of Quebec (INSPQ). Even if Omicron proves to be more transmissible, the INSPQ does not consider it necessary, unlike the CDC, to widen the wearing of the N95 mask in the population, including in certain more at-risk situations. The Commission for Standards, Equity and Occupational Health and Safety (CNESST) last December extended its recommendation on the wearing of the N95 mask to healthcare workers in hot and warm areas, or in close contact with patients. “The take home message is that the current measures are still working. The N95 mask fits the face better, but if it is not tested or poorly adjusted, it is no more effective than the surgical mask,” insists Dr. Perron. But other experts oppose this view in the current context of high community transmission of Omicron and increasingly precarious access to care in hospitals. “It is high time to review this position. All scientists recognize the superiority of N95 […]. We are in a wave where people must protect themselves as much as possible, ”says immunologist André Veillette, of the Montreal Clinical Research Institute (IRCM). Professor Maximilien Debia, specialist in occupational hygiene at the School of Public Health at the University of Montreal, also considers that it is time to “change the paradigm” for N95. The INSPQ still does not advocate the use of N95 or KN95 masks in the community, reserving it for employees of the health network exposed to increased risks of exposure, in particular during medical procedures generating aerosols.

    Logo of Le Devoir: Le Devoir smallFavicon
    The duty



Prime Minister François Legault said Tuesday that the reopening of gyms would happen during a “third stage”, after the reopening of restaurants and performance halls. No date has been advanced.

Until then, gym owners are stretched thin after having been closed for 14 of the past 22 months, Mr Hardy worries. The owners would have accumulated between $75,000 and $80,000 in debt on average, according to an internal survey.

Ways to open

By working with the fitness industry, Mr. Hardy believes it is possible to find a satisfactory compromise to limit the spread of the virus and allow reopening.

He cites British Columbia as an example, where fitness centers have been open since January 20. Working with industry, the government has established strict conditions to allow them to reopen. The vaccination passport is required there, wearing a mask is compulsory when traveling and for coaches. A distance of seven meters between athletes is also required.

British Columbia’s Chief Medical Officer of Health, Bonnie Henry, thanked the provincial chapter of the CCICP when she announced the reopening of the gyms. These steps have made it possible to reopen with measures that “public health knows and accepts”, judges Mr. Hardy.

Not that easy

However, the reopening of fitness centers is not so simple for the government, believes Roxane Borgès Da Silva, professor at the School of Public Health at the University of Montreal (ESPUM). “With a more contagious variant, you would expect there to be a much higher risk of having outbreaks in a gym.”

While it may seem contradictory to reopen restaurants before fitness centers, the decision can be justified, according to her. “Contamination is by aerosol. When we play sports, we are out of breath and we expel a lot more aerosol than when we are in a seated restaurant.

Mr. Hardy believes that public health experts would be able to see that fitness centers are healthy environments if they visited the facilities. “Have you come to visit our circles to look at what you see as dangerous? Where are the massive outbreak statistics in gyms compared to movie theaters or performance halls? There is no exchange, we do not know what they are based on, but, for that, it takes a dialogue.

Stephane Rolland, The Canadian Press

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.