Technology "Society does not have to follow you like a...

“Society does not have to follow you like a prophet, even if your intuition is correct”


“Scientists, like all citizens, also participate in the collegial decision-making process. I offer you an attitude of collaboration. I think we would all come out of it growing up. »GERARD JULIEN / AFP

Grandstand. In his column “The doctor can and must think like a doctor, and not like a methodologist” published on March 25, 2020 on, Professor Didier Raoult urges to get rid of “Methodologists and mathematicians”. The rostrum is clearly provocative. As a medical methodologist, she shocked me. It may be a process of intention, but I extract from this text a common catchphrase: scientists would be preventing them from going straight, opposing the march of progress.

In medicine, “common sense” is that caregivers have endless wisdom about evaluating the effectiveness of new things, based on their practical experience, and the method would only hinder its spread. Finally, the expert authority should prevail over the scientific consensus based on the collection of high-level experimental evidence, because after thirty years of experience, we know everything better than everyone.

Read also The resuscitators: “Help us by agreeing to participate in our clinical research studies”

Scientists and caregivers can work together to provide society with robust responses. Scientists are also human beings. “Mathematicians” are not unethical monsters. Ethics transcends and we cannot escape it. If each decision made by Professor Didier Raoult in the context of his practice is judged according to his ethics, scientists do the same.

Attempts at mathematical prediction

To believe you, “The modellers of the future” would not be better than “Astrologers”. Yes, no human being can predict the future. Yes, statistics are a tool to help decision-making in situations of uncertainty (not irreducible). Yes, the most sophisticated mathematical predictions are wrong. However, admitting the need to anticipate, what do you offer instead as a tool?

I’m not sure if it works with a wet finger, even if it’s connected to a very well-cortexed expert brain, will lead to a better result. It’s possible. Perhaps you have a gift of foreknowledge? However, I have the right not to be immediately overwhelmed and to consider attempts at mathematical prediction.

Article reserved for our subscribers Read also Coronavirus: Didier Raoult, the Marseille infectiologist behind the planetary madness around hydroxychloroquine

You claim that “The doctor can and must act like a doctor, not like a methodologist”. Thank you for the obvious. Yes, a doctor, in his care activity, must act as such. Of course, the experience gained in the field is of value. This is why there are devices allowing therapeutic decisions to be made outside of recommendations (the possibilities of prescribing off MA).


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Latest news

The director incarcerated in Fatal Crash has made a new film. Did he violate his parole?

Click here to read the full article. Randall Miller, the director who spent a year in prison on the...

the wave of criticism of Youtubers who got rid of the child they had adopted and who were the protagonist of their channel

The internet can get really bad when you get angry. And the Stauffer knows it perfectly, a couple who...

Alcoa wants to fire 85% of the workforce the last primary aluminum factory in Spain

It was an announced death and it was confirmed yesterday. In a meeting with representatives of the works council...

More than 200,000 heavy vehicles will have to go through the workshop in the de-escalation

The progressive return of economic activity will have its effects not only on private mobility, but also on professional...

Must read

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you