Collingwood Faces Defensive Shuffle: Shaw Advocates for Silvagni Over Mihocek

Melbourne, Australia – Collingwood Football Club is reportedly contemplating a significant shift in its defensive lineup, with key backman Darcy Moore perhaps facing a challenging contract negotiation. Former premiership player and current commentator, Nathan Shaw, has publicly endorsed prioritizing young gun Caleb Silvagni over veteran Jamie Mihocek in future list management decisions.

Shaw, speaking to foxfooty.com.au,acknowledged Mihocek’s valuable contribution to the club,including a premiership,but raised concerns about offering a multi-year deal to a 32-year-old. “Mihocek is a really good player, not a superstar. But if someone wants to give him a two or three-year deal at 32, good luck to you,” Shaw stated.He emphasized the inherent risk of injury at that age, stating, “You’re one injury away at 32 years of age.”

The discussion comes as Collingwood navigates the aging profiles of its defensive core, with Jeremy Howe also nearing the end of his career and Moore approaching 30. Shaw believes Silvagni represents the future. “Silvagni was one of the best one-on-one defenders in the competition until he got hurt again. I’d go there every minute of the day.” He succinctly summarized his preference: “It’s pretty simple really, getting Silvagni in and Mihocek out. If you can keep both, you do it. If not, see you later.”

beyond the immediate: The Evolving Landscape of AFL List Management

This potential move highlights a growing trend in the AFL – the delicate balance between rewarding experienced players and investing in emerging talent. Clubs are increasingly scrutinizing the long-term viability of contracts for players over 30, factoring in injury risk and the need to rebuild for sustained success.

The Collingwood situation is particularly interesting given the club’s recent premiership window. maintaining a competitive edge requires proactive list management, and Shaw’s comments suggest a willingness to prioritize long-term potential over short-term stability. This approach isn’t unique; many successful AFL clubs have demonstrated the courage to make tough decisions regarding beloved veterans to ensure future competitiveness.

Gold Coast suns Secure Fiorini Talks, Rosas attracts Rival Interest

In separate news, the Gold Coast Suns are progressing contract discussions with midfielder brayden Fiorini, whose recent form has been pivotal to the club’s push for a maiden finals berth. Fiorini, averaging 28 disposals over his last three games, is a free agent at the end of 2025.

however, the Suns are also facing potential departures, with small forward Malcolm Rosas attracting interest from Richmond and sydney despite limited senior game time this season.

The Suns, holding a significant draft hand including three first-round picks, are also reportedly keen to bolster their draft capital, with an eye on highly-rated academy prospects Zeke Uwland and dylan Patterson, projected to be top-five selections in the 2025 draft. This strategic positioning underscores the suns’ ambition to build a sustainable premiership contender through a combination of experienced talent and emerging stars.

How might St kilda’s handling of Jack Steele‘s contract negotiations impact their ability to attract and retain other key players?

St Kilda’s Uncertain future: Trade rumours and Key Player Moves Surrounding Jack Steele and Beyond

The Jack Steele Contract Saga: A Focal point for St Kilda

The biggest storyline surrounding the St Kilda Football Club right now undoubtedly revolves around captain Jack Steele. His contract negotiations have become protracted, fueling intense AFL trade rumours and speculation about his future at Moorabbin. While Steele remains a highly valued player, the Saints are reportedly hesitant to meet his demands, creating a potential impasse.

Contract Demands: Reports suggest Steele is seeking a long-term deal with important financial backing, reflecting his importance to the team and his standing within the league.

St Kilda’s Position: The club appears to be adopting a cautious approach, potentially wanting to preserve salary cap space for other key signings and future growth. This is a common strategy in AFL player management.

Potential Suitors: Several clubs, including Collingwood and Geelong, have been linked with a potential move for Steele should he become available. These clubs have demonstrated a history of aggressive recruitment and could offer steele the package he desires.

Potential Trade Value: Nasim’s age and potential make him a highly valuable trade asset. St Kilda could potentially secure multiple draft picks in exchange for his services.

St kilda’s Stance: The Saints are publicly committed to retaining Nasim, but a significant offer from another club could test their resolve.

Clark’s Role: Clark provides valuable experience and leadership, but the Saints may see an prospect to refresh their midfield with younger talent.

Trade Scenarios: A trade involving Clark could allow St Kilda to free up salary cap space and potentially acquire a draft pick or a player who better fits their long-term plans.

Draft Strategy: The Saints are expected to target players who can fill specific roles, such as a key forward, a rebounding defender, or a contested midfielder.

Potential Targets: Several highly rated draft prospects have been linked with St Kilda, including [mention specific draft prospects if available – research current draft rankings].

Trading Draft Picks: St Kilda may also consider trading draft picks to move up the draft order and secure a player they believe has the potential to become a star.