February 2026

As the Penn State Nittany Lions continue their impressive streak of success in collegiate wrestling, a question arises that fans and analysts alike are eager to explore: Could Penn State’s wrestling team defeat a national all-star team in a dual meet? After a dominant performance against No. 2 Ohio State, where they clinched their sixth consecutive Big Ten title, the Lions have now achieved 85 consecutive dual meet victories. They are set to face Princeton next, aiming for an undefeated season.

It has been 2,210 days since Penn State last tasted defeat in a dual meet, a loss to Iowa on January 31, 2020. During this remarkable run, they have also secured three consecutive Big Ten championships and four national titles. With no signs of slowing down, speculation arises about what it would take to challenge this wrestling dynasty. Could a team composed of the best wrestlers from across the country stand a chance?

With six wrestlers currently ranked No. 1 nationally and nine in the top six, the answer isn’t as straightforward as one might think. Let’s break down how Penn State’s wrestlers measure up against potential all-star competitors across various weight classes.

Weight Class Breakdown

125 Pounds

Luke Lilledahl, currently ranked No. 1, solidified his status with a recent victory over Ohio State’s Nic Bouzakis. Lilledahl boasts an impressive record of 16-0 this season, featuring one pin, eight tech falls, and two major decisions. His closest competitors include reigning national champion Vincent Robinson from NC State and Virginia Tech’s Eddie Ventresca, who could pose a challenge. However, Sheldon Seymour from Lehigh, who previously defeated Lilledahl at the NCAA Championships, also warrants consideration as a formidable opponent.

133 Pounds

Marcus Blaze remains undefeated as well, currently holding an 18-0 record after a thrilling match against Ohio State’s Ben Davino. Blaze’s performance has earned him the No. 2 spot in the Intermat rankings. The College All-Stars would likely counter with Lucas Byrd, the reigning national champion from Illinois, who has yet to face a signature opponent this season. Alternatively, freshman Jax Forrest from Oklahoma State has emerged as a dark horse, showcasing his skills against top competitors.

141 Pounds

At 141 pounds, the College All-Stars could uncover an opportunity for bonus points. Penn State’s Braeden Davis faced reigning two-time national champion Jesse Mendez from Ohio State, who decisively won their match, demonstrating the challenge that lies ahead. The potential inclusion of injured wrestlers like Aaron Nagao could impact the outcome, but Mendez’s recent form suggests a strong advantage for the All-Stars.

149 Pounds

Shayne Van Ness is currently the top-ranked wrestler at 149, with a flawless 17-0 record this season, including four pins and eight tech falls. While he hasn’t faced the toughest competition recently, Jaxon Joy from Cornell could serve as the All-Stars’ representative, having excelled against a more rigorous schedule.

157 Pounds

PJ Duke’s freshman season has been remarkable, with a record of 15-1, his only loss coming in a close match against Antrell Taylor. Taylor remains a strong choice for the All-Stars, but other contenders, including Meyer Shapiro from Cornell, could also be considered due to their offensive prowess.

165 Pounds

Mitchell Mesenbrink, the reigning national champion, has been consistent, winning all his matches with bonus points. His chief competitor, Mikey Caliendo from Iowa, has struggled this season, leaving Mesenbrink as a heavy favorite should they meet.

174 Pounds

Levi Haines is another undefeated wrestler for Penn State, showcasing his skills with a record of 17-0. His performance has set him apart, but he could face challenges from competitors like Simon Ruiz from Cornell, who has been performing well this season.

184 Pounds

Rocco Welsh remains undefeated, with a record of 16-0. The weight class is unpredictable, featuring potential opponents like Max McEnelly from Minnesota and Angelo Ferrari from Iowa, both of whom could pose a threat to Welsh’s streak.

197 Pounds

Josh Barr has quietly established himself as a dominant force, returning strong after an injury. He is currently 15-0 and would likely face Rocky Elam from Iowa State, who has also been impressive this season.

Heavyweight

At heavyweight, Cole Mirasola’s recent victory over Nick Feldman highlights his capabilities, but he faces stiff competition from Yonger Bastida of Iowa State, who boasts an undefeated record of 20-0.

Conclusion: What Would Happen in a Dual Meet?

If a dual meet were to occur between Penn State and a national all-star team, the matchup could easily tilt either way. Penn State excels in several weight classes, particularly at 165, 174, and 197, where they have clear advantages. However, the All-Stars would likely dominate at 141 and heavyweight, creating a competitive balance.

The dual could highly well come down to a close score, potentially a nail-biting 17-16 in favor of either side. Given Cael Sanderson’s impressive track record, it’s essential to remember not to underestimate his team’s capabilities.

Fans and analysts are left excited about what the future holds for the Nittany Lions as they prepare for the postseason and continue their quest for another undefeated season. As they gear up for their next match against Princeton, the wrestling world will be watching closely.