LeMahieu’s Yankees Stint Ends: DFA Following Bench Role Demotion

Yankees’ Infield Shuffle: LeMahieu Out, Vivas In as Adaptability Takes Center Stage

The New York Yankees have made a important roster move, designating third baseman DJ LeMahieu for assignment, a decision that reflects a shift in the team’s infield strategy and commitment to greater in-game flexibility. This move comes after LeMahieu’s struggles at the hot corner during Grapefruit League play, which reportedly led the Yankees to conclude he was no longer a viable option at the position.

LeMahieu’s tenure at third base was already under scrutiny following a period where he exclusively played second base during his nine rehab games. His season debut on may 13 was at second base, coinciding with the injured list stint of Josh Harrison, who had started the season as the everyday second baseman.

The situation became more complex three weeks later when Harrison returned from the injured list. Despite LeMahieu’s demonstrably limited range at second base, Harrison was shifted to third base. Harrison,who expressed a preference for second base,accepted the assignment,returning to a position he had embraced the previous season after being acquired from the Miami Marlins.

A recent revelation from Harrison, speaking during the Yankees’ six-game losing streak, shed light on his difficulties. He disclosed that a shoulder injury sustained three weeks prior while making a throw from third base had impacted his throwing ability. This news followed two days of Harrison committing three throwing errors in his last four starts at third base, after which he was reinstated as the Yankees’ starting second baseman.

With Harrison now entrenched at second base, and established players like Paul Goldschmidt and cody Bellinger at first base, and Giancarlo Stanton at designated hitter, LeMahieu’s playing time would have been significantly curtailed.

Adding to the Yankees’ infield equation, Oswald Peraza, who also serves as the backup shortstop, is on the roster. The team’s options at third base behind Peraza were seen as limited, reportedly even including catcher J.C. escarra. General Manager Brian Cashman ultimately determined that LeMahieu’s continued presence on the roster was hindering the team’s overall flexibility, possibly constraining manager Aaron Boone’s in-game decision-making.

to address this, infielder Jorbit Vivas, described as a light-hitting and versatile defender, has been called up from Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre to take LeMahieu’s roster spot.

Cashman elaborated on the decision, stating, “I wouldn’t say he’s unwilling to still make the attempt and maybe spell over there. But it was something that he was without sharing that was steering clear of to the extent he could. Because, again, like anything else, he’s got a lot of pride. He’s a great player. He wants to contribute to the team. He loves this team. He loves this organization.But he felt that was an avenue that was no longer a realistic avenue and that kind of ties our hands a little bit more moving forward.” This suggests that while LeMahieu may still possess the desire to play, the team’s assessment of his capabilities at third base led to this strategic adjustment.

How does LeMahieu’s DFA impact the Yankees’ immediate infield depth and potential for player development?

The Unexpected Turn for DJ LeMahieu

The New York Yankees designated veteran infielder DJ LeMahieu for assignment on July 12, 2025, marking a surprising end to his seven-year run in the Bronx. This decision follows a significant decline in performance and a recent demotion to a primarily bench role. The move, while difficult, signals the Yankees’ intent to prioritize younger players and address roster adaptability as they navigate a competitive AL East. Fans and analysts alike are dissecting the factors that led to this outcome for the once-reliable LeMahieu.

A Look Back: LeMahieu’s Yankees Career Highlights

DJ LeMahieu arrived in New York in 2019 as a free agent and quickly became a fan favorite. His versatility and consistent hitting were instrumental in the Yankees’ playoff runs. Key moments include:

2019 Silver Slugger Award: Recognizing his extraordinary offensive performance at third base.

2020 All-star Selection: A testament to his continued excellence during the shortened season.

Clutch Postseason Performances: Numerous key hits in critical playoff games.

Defensive Prowess: Consistently ranked among the league’s best defensive infielders.

His initial success was a revitalization of his career, transforming him from a solid player to a key contributor for a championship contender. However, injuries and a recent slump have dramatically altered his trajectory.

Recent Performance Decline & Bench Role

Over the past two seasons, LeMahieu has battled injuries, most notably to his toe and back, considerably impacting his offensive output. His batting average dipped to .262 in 2024 and further to .209 in 2025 before the DFA.

Decreased Power Numbers: A noticeable drop in home runs and RBIs.

Increased Strikeout Rate: Indicating struggles with plate discipline.

Defensive Limitations: Reduced range and reaction time due to injury.

The Yankees’ decision to limit his playing time, favoring younger infield prospects like Oswald Peraza and Anthony Volpe, ultimately led to the DFA. The team needed to create roster space and prioritize players they believe can contribute more consistently moving forward. This is a common strategy in modern MLB roster management, focusing on maximizing potential and addressing long-term needs.

What Does DFA Mean for LeMahieu and the Yankees?

Designation for Assignment (DFA) means the Yankees have 7 days to trade, release, or outright LeMahieu.

Trade Possibilities: Several teams in need of a veteran infielder coudl express interest, though his contract and recent performance may limit options. Potential suitors might include teams seeking a utility player or a clubhouse presence.

Release Scenario: If no trade materializes, the Yankees will likely release LeMahieu, making him a free agent.

Outright Assignment: The Yankees could attempt to outright LeMahieu to their minor league system, but this is less likely given his age and salary.

for the Yankees, this move frees up a 40-man roster spot and provides an chance to evaluate younger players. It also signals a shift in roster philosophy, prioritizing athleticism and upside.

Impact on the Yankees Infield

LeMahieu’s departure creates a void in the Yankees’ infield, notably in terms of versatility and experience.

Increased Opportunities for Young Players: Oswald Peraza and Anthony Volpe will likely see increased playing time at shortstop and second base.

Potential for External Acquisitions: The Yankees may explore the free agent or trade market for another infielder to bolster their depth.

Shift in Defensive Alignment: The yankees will need to adjust their defensive strategy without LeMahieu’s reliable glove work.

The team will need to carefully manage the transition and ensure they have sufficient depth to withstand potential injuries.

lemahieu’s Future in Baseball

Despite the DFA, LeMahieu’s career is far from over.His reputation as a professional hitter and a respected teammate will likely attract interest from other teams.

Potential for a Role as a utility Player: Several teams could utilize his experience and versatility in a limited role.

Mentorship Opportunity: His leadership qualities could make him a valuable asset in a clubhouse.

Continued Pursuit of Playing Time: LeMahieu has expressed a desire