The Shift in MLB Strategy: Why Small Ball is Making a Big Comeback
Over the past decade, Major League Baseball has been dominated by the home run. Teams built rosters prioritizing power hitters, and analytics largely reinforced this approach. But a quiet revolution is underway. Through July 2024, stolen base attempts are up 35% compared to 2023, and teams are increasingly focused on manufacturing runs – a strategy known as “small ball.” This isn’t just a cyclical trend; it’s a fundamental shift driven by rule changes, evolving player development, and a growing realization that consistent, versatile offense is more valuable than relying solely on the long ball.
The Rule Changes Fueling the Fire
The 2023 MLB rule changes – larger bases, pitch clock, and limits on defensive shifts – were designed to increase action and improve pace of play. They’ve done exactly that, and a significant byproduct has been the resurgence of the stolen base. Larger bases mean shorter distances for runners, and the pitch clock reduces opportunities for pitchers to slow down runners. The ban on extreme shifts opens up more holes in the infield, rewarding contact hitters who can place the ball strategically. These changes haven’t just allowed small ball to work; they’ve actively incentivized it.
Beyond the Rules: A New Breed of Player
While rule changes created the opportunity, player development is capitalizing on it. Teams are now actively scouting and developing players with a different skillset than the traditional power-first prospect. Speed, contact hitting, and on-base percentage are becoming increasingly valued. We’re seeing more athletes who can consistently get on base, steal bases, and move runners over – players like Jose Ramirez and Marcus Semien, who aren’t necessarily known for their home run totals but are consistently among the league’s most valuable offensive contributors. This shift in focus is a direct response to the data showing the long-term benefits of a more balanced offensive approach.
The Data Doesn’t Lie: Run Creation Beyond the Home Run
For years, the focus was on isolating power – measuring slugging percentage and home run rates. However, advanced metrics like Weighted Runs Created Plus (wRC+) and Base Running Runs (BsR) are providing a more nuanced understanding of offensive value. wRC+ measures a player’s total offensive contribution relative to the league average, accounting for all aspects of hitting, not just power. BsR quantifies a player’s impact on run scoring through stolen bases, extra bases taken, and avoiding double plays. Teams are now using these metrics to identify and value players who excel in these areas, even if their home run numbers are modest. A recent study by FanGraphs demonstrated a correlation between teams prioritizing BsR and sustained offensive success.
The Implications for Team Building and Strategy
The rise of small ball has significant implications for how MLB teams are built. The days of solely chasing power hitters are numbered. Teams will need to prioritize versatility, speed, and contact hitting. This means a greater emphasis on scouting international markets, where players with these skills are often more prevalent. It also means a shift in how teams utilize their lineups. We’re likely to see more emphasis on batting order construction, with players who can get on base consistently placed ahead of those with more power. Managers will also need to be more aggressive on the basepaths, taking advantage of the new rules and the increased value of stolen bases.
Will Pitching Adapt? The Next Phase of the Evolution
As teams become more proficient at small ball, pitchers will need to adapt. Holding runners on base will become even more critical, and pitchers may need to shorten their deliveries or incorporate more pickoff moves. We could also see a resurgence in the use of sinkerball pitchers, who induce ground balls and limit hard contact. The cat-and-mouse game between hitters and pitchers is constantly evolving, and the rise of small ball is the latest chapter in that ongoing story.
The return to a more multifaceted offensive approach isn’t about abandoning power altogether. It’s about recognizing that consistent run creation requires a blend of skills. The teams that embrace this shift – prioritizing speed, contact, and strategic base running – will be the ones who thrive in the years to come. The era of the exclusively power-hitting team is fading, and a new, more dynamic style of baseball is taking its place. What strategies will teams employ to counter this trend? Only time will tell, but one thing is certain: the game is evolving, and the future of MLB is looking faster, smarter, and more exciting.
Explore more insights on MLB strategy and player development in our MLB Analytics section.
