Trump says Russia will accept security guarantees for Ukraine, but adds ‘possible exchanges of territory’ to be discussed
Table of Contents
- 1. Trump says Russia will accept security guarantees for Ukraine, but adds ‘possible exchanges of territory’ to be discussed
- 2. Macron stresses leaders want peace and echoes need to push for a ceasefire
- 3. Merz breaks with Trump to push for ceasefire ‘from the next meeting’
- 4. Trump says he would prefer ceasefire, but ‘as of this moment, it’s not happening’
- 5. Trump says Russia will accept security guarantees for Ukraine, but adds ‘possible exchanges of territory’ to be discussed
- 6. Trump kicks off multilateral meeting with European leaders
- 7. Zelenskyy in the Oval Office, round two – snap analysis
- 8. ‘We will give them very good protection,’ Trump says of Ukraine
- 9. Trump to call Putin later today
- 10. What are teh historical precedents for territorial concessions made during peace negotiations, and how might they inform the current discussion regarding Ukraine?
- 11. Trump Discusses Russia’s Security Guarantees for Ukraine but Mentions Potential Territorial Exchanges
- 12. Trump’s Recent Statements on Ukraine and Russia
- 13. The Core of the Proposed deal: Security Guarantees
- 14. Potential Territorial Exchanges: A Controversial Aspect
- 15. Reactions and Analysis: International Response
- 16. historical Precedents: Territorial Adjustments in Post-Conflict Settlements
- 17. Implications for US Foreign Policy
- 18. Key Search Terms & Related Queries
Trump says after his summit with Putin he believes that peace is “within reach”.
In a “significant step”, Putin agreed Russia would accept security guarantees for Ukrainehe says.
He says the leaders at this meeting will be considering “who will do whatessentially” regarding Ukraine’s future security.
Trump says he’s optimistic that the group can reach an agreement that will deter future aggression against Ukraine, adding:
I actually think there won’t be. I even think that’s largely overrated.
“I think the European nations are going to take a lot of the burden,” he says, reiterating that the US will be involved. “We’re going to help them.”
The meeting will also discuss the “possible exchanges of territory”, he adds, ominously for Ukraine.
Key events
-
Macron stresses leaders want peace and echoes need to push for a ceasefire
-
Merz breaks with Trump to push for ceasefire ‘from the next meeting’
-
Trump says he would prefer ceasefire, but ‘as of this moment, it’s not happening’
-
Trump says Russia will accept security guarantees for Ukraine, but adds ‘possible exchanges of territory’ to be discussed
-
Trump kicks off multilateral meeting with European leaders
-
Zelenskyy in the Oval Office, round two – snap analysis
-
‘We will give them very good protection,’ Trump says of Ukraine
-
Trump to call Putin later today
-
Ukraine needs ‘everything’ in support from US, says Zelenskyy
-
Trump says ceasefire not necessary to negotiate an end to war
-
Trump says he believes Putin wants Ukraine war to end
-
US to ‘be involved’ in Ukraine’s security, says Trump
-
Zelenskyy doesn’t say if he’s prepared to cede territory to Russia
-
Zelenskyy thanks Trump for efforts to stop war
-
Trump touts ‘very substantial progress’ in Putin talks
-
Zelenskyy returns to White House for crucial talks with Trump alongside European allies
-
We need ‘joint pressure’ on Russia to end war, Zelenskyy says, after ‘coordinating positions’ with allies ahead of White House talks
-
First European leaders arrive at White House — in pictures
-
European leaders expected at White House soon
-
14 dead in overnight Russian attacks, authorities say
-
Russia’s Putin calls leaders of Brazil, India, South Africa ahead of Zelenskyy’s DC visit
-
EU27 to get debrief on Trump-Zelenskyy talks tomorrow
-
First leaders seen in Washington ahead of crunch talks
-
Poland set to miss summit amid conflict between president, government on foreign policy
-
‘Russia can only be forced into peace through strength’, Zelenskyy says as he bids for Trump’s backing
-
‘I’ll get it done, Trump says, as he insists ‘I know exactly what I’m doing’
-
Trump rages against ‘fake news’ saying they wouldn’t credit him even if he got Russia to ‘surrender’ and hand over Moscow, St. Petersburg, and 1000 miles around them
-
European leaders want to ‘flesh out details’ of security guarantees for Ukraine
-
Ten dead in attacks ahead of Trump-Zelenskyy meeting
-
Meloni sees ‘glimmer of hope’ from Trump-Putin talks, focuses on security guarantees
-
‘We’ve got to get it right,’ Starmer says, as he pushes for ‘lasting, fair, just’ peace in Ukraine
-
UK’s Starmer ready to back Ukraine peace deal without ceasefire as precondition
-
Germany’s Merz finds silver lining in Trump’s Alaska summit, but commiting troops continues to divide politicians
-
‘Moscow must hear: stop,’ Zelenskyy says, as he warns against rewarding Russia for war
-
Hungary, Ukraine clash over criticism for attack on Russian oil pipeline
-
Seven dead, 20 injured in Russian attack on Kharkiv
-
17 injured in overnight Russian attack on Zaporizhzhia
-
Trump’s tone on ending war likely to alarm Europeans ahead of talks — snap analysis
-
Ceasefire, security guarantees to be discussed at White House, Finnish PM says
-
Opening summary
Joanna Walters
What has Vladimir Putin been up to today during the great international assembly at the White House?
It appears to have been a drab day in Moscow all around, damp and grey and the Russian president hosting a meeting at the Kremlin with the acting governor of the Rostov region, Yury Slyusar.
One gripping regional media headline is: “Putin noted a decrease in the pace of agricultural production in the Rostov region.”
Meanwhile the attacks and the killing in Ukraine go on.
That’s the end of the public remarks from the meeting between Trump and the European leaders. As they continue talks through the afternoon, we’ll bring you more as we get it.
The UK’s prime minister Keir Starmer echoes Macron’s sentiments that “we all want peace” and guaranteeing Ukraine’s security guarantees the security of Europe as a whole.
He adds that a trilateral meeting is “the sensible next step”.
Macron stresses leaders want peace and echoes need to push for a ceasefire
French president Emmanuel Macronnotably, opens his remarks by saying: “Everybody around this table is in favour of peace”.
Discussions of security guarantees are “about the whole security of the European continent”, he tells Trump.
He reiterates Merz’s comments about asking for a ceasefire “at least to stop the kiilling”, adding “we all support this idea”.
Security guarantees would involve a strong Ukrainian army for “years and decades to come”, and a commitment from all those around the table to build security, he says.
Merz breaks with Trump to push for ceasefire ‘from the next meeting’
German chancellor Friedrich Merz emphasises that they would like to see a ceasefire. “To be honest, we all would like to see a ceasefire, the latest from the next meeting on,” he tells Trump.
He adds that he “can’t imagine” the trilateral meeting will take place without one, urging the US president to put pressure on Russia to get one.
Trump says “we’ll see … if we can do that” but, as he did earlier, highlights the “six wars|” he claims to have ended without a ceasefire.
Invited to address the media, Zelenksyy says he and Trump had a “constructive” meeting, a “very good conversation”.
He reiterates that Ukraine’s security depends on the European countries present and the United States. “This is very important the the US gives such strong signal and is ready for security guarantees,” he says.
Trump says he would prefer ceasefire, but ‘as of this moment, it’s not happening’
Trump says he would prefer an immediate to ceasefire in Ukraine while they work on a peace deal, but “as of this moment, it’s not happening”.
Trump reiterates that he wants a trilateral meeting soon.
Trump says Russia will accept security guarantees for Ukraine, but adds ‘possible exchanges of territory’ to be discussed
Trump says after his summit with Putin he believes that peace is “within reach”.
In a “significant step”, Putin agreed Russia would accept security guarantees for Ukrainehe says.
He says the leaders at this meeting will be considering “who will do whatessentially” regarding Ukraine’s future security.
Trump says he’s optimistic that the group can reach an agreement that will deter future aggression against Ukraine, adding:
I actually think there won’t be. I even think that’s largely overrated.
“I think the European nations are going to take a lot of the burden,” he says, reiterating that the US will be involved. “We’re going to help them.”
The meeting will also discuss the “possible exchanges of territory”, he adds, ominously for Ukraine.
There is a feed at the top of the blog if you’d like to follow the meeting live.
Trump kicks off multilateral meeting with European leaders
That multilateral meeting has just started between Donald Trump, Volodymyr Zelenskyy and the European leaders at the White House.
Volodymyr Zelenskyy and Donald Trump have just posed for a “family photo” with European leaders. Here it is, featuring UK prime minister Keir StarmerFrench president Emmanuel MacronItalian prime minister Giorgia MeloniFinnish president Alexander Stubband the president of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen.
Zelenskyy in the Oval Office, round two – snap analysis
Well, the optics of this initial meeting were far friendlier than the last time these people were all in the Oval Office together, and Zelenskyy and the other European leaders will no doubt be very pleased with how suit-gate was handledfor example – heck, there was even laughing at times.
But despite this lightheartedness, there were some worrying developments for Kyiv. Perhaps most key was Trump’s assertion that he’s decided he doesn’t need a ceasefire after all in order to negotiate a peace deal, after spending months demanding one from Russia and threatening sanctions and “severe consequences” if it didn’t comply. Things have clearly changed after his Alaska summit with Putinwho knows the US president wants peace more than anything and has played this up to his advantage by blaming others for being obstacles to ending the war.
But there were glimmers of hope for Kyiv, notably Trump saying the US would help with Ukraine’s security in a peace deal, giving Ukraine “very good protection”. But he remained uncommitted on what level of specific security guarantees the US is willing to support, for instance whether its involvement would include an Article 5-style defence commitment and/or American boots on the ground.
Whether Trump can now be convinced once again by Zelenskyy and the Europeans that the onus is on Russia to end its war, and not on Ukraine to give up territory, in order to achieve peace remains to be seen.
‘We will give them very good protection,’ Trump says of Ukraine
Earlier Trump was asked if he would offer Ukraine [Nato] Article 5-style security guarantees. He said this hasn’t been discussed yet but says of Kyiv:
We will give them very good protection, very good security. That’s part of it.
Trump to call Putin later today
Trump says he just spoke to Putin indirectly, and will speak to him again after these meetings today “and we may or may not have a [trilateral meeting].”
“He’s expecting my call when we’re finished with this meeting,” Trump says.
What are teh historical precedents for territorial concessions made during peace negotiations, and how might they inform the current discussion regarding Ukraine?<
Trump Discusses Russia’s Security Guarantees for Ukraine but Mentions Potential Territorial Exchanges
Trump’s Recent Statements on Ukraine and Russia
Former President Donald Trump recently discussed potential pathways to resolving the conflict in Ukraine, outlining a scenario where russia might accept security guarantees in exchange for adjustments to Ukrainian territory. These statements,made during a public appearance,have sparked notable debate and analysis within geopolitical circles and among international policy experts. The core of the discussion revolves around a potential negotiation framework involving Russia, Ukraine, and key international actors.
The Core of the Proposed deal: Security Guarantees
Trump indicated that Russia has expressed a willingness to consider security assurances for Ukraine, potentially alleviating concerns about future NATO expansion towards its borders. This willingness, however, is reportedly contingent upon certain concessions from Ukraine. Key elements of these potential security guarantees could include:
Neutrality: Ukraine agreeing to a neutral status, foregoing membership in NATO.
Demilitarization: Limitations on Ukraine’s military capabilities to address Russian security concerns.
International Oversight: A framework for international monitoring and verification of compliance with the agreed-upon terms.
Economic Assistance: A commitment of economic aid to support Ukraine’s reconstruction and development.
Potential Territorial Exchanges: A Controversial Aspect
The most contentious part of Trump’s discussion centered on the possibility of territorial exchanges between Russia and Ukraine. He suggested that Russia might be open to a resolution involving Ukraine ceding control of certain territories, specifically referencing Crimea and parts of the Donbas region.
Crimea: Annexed by Russia in 2014, Crimea remains a major point of contention. trump’s comments suggest a potential acceptance of Russia’s control over the peninsula as part of a broader agreement.
Donbas Region: The conflict in the Donbas region, encompassing the self-proclaimed donetsk and Luhansk Peopel’s Republics, has been ongoing as 2014. Trump indicated that russia might be willing to discuss the future status of these territories, potentially involving some form of autonomy or Russian control.
Historical Context: Understanding the historical claims and demographics of these regions is crucial to grasping the complexity of any potential territorial negotiations.
Reactions and Analysis: International Response
The former President’s statements have elicited a range of reactions from international leaders and analysts.
Ukrainian Goverment: Ukrainian officials have expressed strong opposition to any territorial concessions, emphasizing the importance of maintaining Ukraine’s sovereignty and territorial integrity.
NATO Allies: Reactions from NATO allies have been mixed, with some expressing concerns about the implications of potentially legitimizing Russian territorial gains. Others have acknowledged the need for exploring all possible avenues for a peaceful resolution.
Russian Government: While official comments have been limited, Russian state media has portrayed Trump’s statements as a sign of a more pragmatic approach to resolving the conflict.
Policy experts: Geopolitical analysts have debated the feasibility and potential consequences of Trump’s proposed framework, highlighting the challenges of balancing security concerns with principles of international law and sovereignty.
historical Precedents: Territorial Adjustments in Post-Conflict Settlements
Throughout history, territorial adjustments have been a common feature of post-conflict settlements. Examining past examples can provide insights into the potential dynamics and challenges of such negotiations.
Post-World war I Treaties: The Treaty of Versailles, such as, involved significant territorial changes in Europe.
Post-World War II Settlements: The Potsdam and Yalta Conferences resulted in territorial adjustments in Eastern Europe.
Balkan Conflicts: The Dayton Agreement, which ended the Bosnian War, involved complex territorial divisions and power-sharing arrangements.
Case Study: The Åland Islands: The Åland Islands, a Swedish-speaking autonomous region of Finland, offer a unique exmaple of a territorial dispute resolved through negotiation and international guarantees.
Implications for US Foreign Policy
Trump’s comments raise significant questions about the future direction of US foreign policy towards Ukraine and Russia.
shift in Approach: A potential shift towards a more transactional approach, prioritizing a rapid resolution over strict adherence to principles of sovereignty and territorial integrity.
Impact on Alliances: The implications for US alliances with NATO and other partners in Europe.
Long-Term Security Landscape: The potential impact on the long-term security landscape in Eastern europe.
US-Russia Relations: The potential for improved US-Russia relations, albeit at the expense of Ukrainian territorial integrity.
Ukraine Russia negotiations
Trump Ukraine policy
Russia
