Peter Schiff Speculates on Bitcoin’s Performance: A Look at Supporters’ Responses and Comparisons to Stocks, Gold, and ETFs

News">

Schiff raises Concerns as Bitcoin Lags Behind Surging Stocks And Gold

New York, NY – september 17, 2025 – Prominent Economist Peter Schiff Has Expressed Skepticism Regarding The Recent Performance Of Bitcoin, Contrasting Its Stagnation With The Record-breaking Gains Seen In Traditional Markets Like Equities And Precious Metals. The Observation Fuels Ongoing Debate About The Cryptocurrency’s Role As A Store Of Value And Its Potential For Future Growth.

Nasdaq And Gold Reach New Heights, Bitcoin Trails

Schiff Pointed Out That While the Nasdaq Composite And Gold Prices Have Consistently Reached New Peaks, Bitcoin Has Failed To Do So For Over A Month. The Nasdaq Composite Closed At A Record High Of 22,348.75 On Monday, While Gold Surpassed $3,700 Per Ounce, And Silver Exceeded $42 Per Ounce – Demonstrating Robust Investor Appetite For Traditional Assets. The VanEck Gold Miners ETF Also Showed Critically important Gains, breaching The $70 Mark Earlier This Week.

Though,Market Volatility Remained Present. The Nasdaq Experienced A Slight Dip From Its Record Highs On Tuesday, And Gold Experienced A Modest Decrease Of 0.24%, Settling At $3,680.

Weekly Gains: Bitcoin Outperforms, But Monthly Trend Raises Questions

Despite The Lack of New All-Time highs, Bitcoin Has Demonstrated Strong Weekly Performance, Outpacing Other Assets. Though, Its Monthly Gains Have Been More Modest.Here’s A Detailed Look At The Recent Performance Of Key Assets:

Asset	Weekly Gain (+/-)	Monthly gain (+/-)	Price (As of 11:55 PM)
Nasdaq Composite	+1.73%	+3.26%	22,333.96
Gold	+1.14%	+10.39%	$3,682.10
Silver	+2.05%	+10.52%	$42.0185
Bitcoin	+4.43%	+0.99%	$116,471
VanEck Gold Miners ETF (GDX)	+2.24%	+18.80%	$69.02

Analysts Weigh In On Bitcoin’s Trajectory

Bitcoin enthusiasts have Countered Schiff’s Concerns, Highlighting The cryptocurrency’s Near-doubling In Value Over The Past Year, Substantially Outperforming Gold’s 43% Gain. A Social Media User, @bearcatden, Noted This Disparity, Suggesting That Bitcoin might potentially be Awaiting Increased participation From New Investors.

last year, the BTC was worth 55,000 dollars, today it is 110,000.

So maybe he is waiting for the latecomers to catch up.

– denwoll (@bearcatden)

Killa, A Widely Followed Cryptocurrency Analyst, Recently Indicated That Bitcoin Often Anticipates Decisions Made By The Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC). He Suggested That The Recent Pullback Could Indicate A Potential Rebound. Furthermore, Arthur Hayes, Investment Director At Maelstrom And Co-Founder of BitMEX, Advocated For A Long-Term Perspective On Bitcoin Investing, Encouraging Investors To Look Beyond Short-Term Fluctuations.

Understanding Bitcoin’s Volatility

Bitcoin,As A Relatively New Asset Class,Is Inherently More Volatile Than Established Investments Like Stocks And Gold. Several Factors Contribute To This Volatility,Including Regulatory Uncertainty,Market Sentiment,And Technological Developments. Investors Considering Bitcoin Should Be Aware Of These Risks And Conduct Thorough Research Before Investing.

did You Know? Bitcoin’s Price Has Historically Experienced Significant Swings, Frequently enough Characterized By Periods Of Rapid Growth followed By Sharp Corrections.

pro Tip: Diversification Is Key. Do Not Invest More Than You Can Afford To Lose In Any Single Asset, Including Bitcoin.

Frequently Asked Questions About Bitcoin

• What is Bitcoin? Bitcoin is a decentralized digital currency, meaning it is not controlled by a single entity like a central bank.
• Why is Bitcoin volatile? Bitcoin’s price is influenced by supply and demand, news events, and regulatory changes, leading to price fluctuations.
• Is Bitcoin a good investment? Bitcoin can offer high potential returns, but it also carries significant risks. Investors should do thier own research.
• What factors influence Bitcoin’s price? Demand,regulatory news,technological advancements,and macroeconomic conditions all impact Bitcoin’s price.
• How does Bitcoin compare to gold? While both are seen as potential hedges against inflation, Bitcoin is considerably more volatile than gold.

What are your thoughts on the future of Bitcoin in relation to traditional assets? Do you think it’s poised for a significant rebound, or will its growth remain subdued?

Share your thoughts and engage in the discussion below!

What specific macroeconomic factors does Peter Schiff believe will trigger a Bitcoin price correction?

Schiff’s Latest Bitcoin Prediction & Historical Context

Peter Schiff, a well-known economist and vocal Bitcoin critic, recently reiterated his bearish stance on the cryptocurrency, predicting a important price correction. This isn’t new territory; Schiff has consistently warned against Bitcoin’s volatility and lack of intrinsic value since its inception. His arguments typically center around Bitcoin being a speculative bubble, lacking the fundamental backing of assets like gold or the cash flows generated by stocks.

Specifically, in late September 2025, Schiff pointed to macroeconomic factors – rising interest rates and potential recessionary pressures – as catalysts for a Bitcoin downturn. He suggests investors will flock to safer assets during economic uncertainty, abandoning riskier holdings like cryptocurrency investments. he frequently frames Bitcoin as a “risk-on” asset, similar to tech stocks, and therefore susceptible to sharp declines when market sentiment shifts.

Bitcoin Supporters’ Rebuttals: A Community Divided

The crypto community responded swiftly and predictably to Schiff’s latest pronouncements. Bitcoin proponents argue that Schiff fundamentally misunderstands the technology and its potential. Common rebuttals include:

* Decentralization as a Key Feature: Supporters emphasize Bitcoin’s decentralized nature as a hedge against government manipulation and inflation, a direct contrast to fiat currencies.

* Limited Supply & Scarcity: The capped supply of 21 million Bitcoins is frequently cited as a key driver of long-term value, comparing it favorably to the inflationary nature of traditional currencies.

* Growing institutional Adoption: Increased investment from institutional investors, like MicroStrategy and tesla (despite Tesla’s previous partial divestment), is presented as evidence of growing legitimacy.

* Bitcoin as Digital Gold: Many Bitcoin advocates position it as “digital gold,” a store of value that is resistant to censorship and seizure. This narrative gains traction during geopolitical instability.

These arguments are often amplified on platforms like X (formerly Twitter), Reddit’s r/Bitcoin, and various crypto-focused forums. The debate highlights a fundamental ideological divide between those who believe in the traditional financial system and those who see Bitcoin as a revolutionary choice.

Bitcoin vs. Stocks: A Risk Assessment

comparing Bitcoin to stocks reveals significant differences in risk profiles.

* Volatility: Bitcoin is demonstrably more volatile than even the most volatile stocks. Historical data shows bitcoin experiencing far larger percentage swings in price over short periods.

* Regulation: The regulatory landscape for stocks is well-established, offering investors a degree of protection. Bitcoin regulation remains fragmented and evolving,creating uncertainty.

* Intrinsic Value: Stocks represent ownership in a company with underlying assets and earnings potential. Bitcoin’s value is largely based on supply and demand,and perceived future utility.

* Correlation: While historically low, Bitcoin’s correlation with tech stocks has increased in recent years, particularly during periods of market stress. This suggests it may not always act as a true diversification tool.

For investors, understanding these differences is crucial. Bitcoin investing should be considered a high-risk, high-reward proposition, while stocks offer a potentially more stable, albeit lower-growth, investment option.

Bitcoin vs. Gold: The Store of Value Debate

The comparison between Bitcoin and gold is central to the ongoing debate. Schiff consistently champions gold as a superior store of value. Here’s a breakdown:

* Historical Performance: Gold has a centuries-long track record as a safe haven asset, particularly during times of economic turmoil.Bitcoin’s history is comparatively short.

* Tangibility: Gold is a physical asset, offering a sense of security that Bitcoin, a digital asset, lacks for some investors.

* Acceptance: Gold is universally recognized and accepted as a form of value. Bitcoin’s acceptance is growing but remains limited.

* Divisibility & Portability: Bitcoin excels in divisibility (easily broken down into smaller units) and portability (easily transferred across borders). Gold is less convenient in these respects.

* Scarcity: Both assets are scarce, but Bitcoin’s scarcity is mathematically enforced, while gold’s supply is subject to discovery and mining.

Recent analysis suggests that both gold and Bitcoin have seen increased demand as inflation concerns rise, but gold continues to be favored by more conservative investors.

Bitcoin vs. ETFs: Accessibility and Liquidity

Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) offer a convenient and liquid way to invest in various asset classes. The emergence of Bitcoin etfs in 2024 substantially altered the investment landscape.

* Accessibility: ETFs make Bitcoin accessible to a wider range of investors who may not be cozy directly purchasing and storing cryptocurrency.

* Liquidity: ETFs are highly liquid,allowing investors to easily buy and sell shares during market hours.

* Regulation & Security: ETFs are subject to regulatory oversight, providing a level of investor protection.

* Fees: ETFs charge management fees, which can eat into returns.

* Tracking Error: Bitcoin ETFs may not perfectly track the price of Bitcoin due to factors like