Leichardt Oval witnessed a dominant performance by the Wests Tigers on Saturday, leaving North Queensland Cowboys coach Todd Payten and captain Tom Dearden searching for answers after a 44-16 defeat. Beyond the scoreboard, a growing frustration with the NRL’s evolving six-again rule permeated the post-match discussion, adding another layer of complexity to the Cowboys’ start to the 2026 season.
The Cowboys’ struggles were evident early, conceding five set restarts within the opening ten minutes, which allowed the Tigers to build a commanding 28-2 lead at halftime. Dearden expressed confusion over the penalties, stating his team was often unsure of the infringements that led to the stoppages. Payten, meanwhile, indicated the team would use the week to refocus and prepare for upcoming challenges, acknowledging the demand to address fundamental issues after a second consecutive loss following a 28-18 defeat against Newcastle in Las Vegas.
Confusion Over Six-Again Rule Intensifies
“The most frustrating bit is you don’t understand what it’s for,” Dearden said after the match. “I know to start the game we had three or four back-to-back, but we had no idea why. It’s not like they’re calling six again and telling us what it’s for.” He explained that players were left reacting to the referee’s arm signal without a clear understanding of the underlying infraction, leading to a sense of helplessness during crucial moments of the game. The NRL implemented changes to the six-again rule in the off-season, aiming to encourage more time with the ball in play by altering the threshold for infringements beyond the 20-metre line and introducing tackle count restarts. Though, these changes have drawn criticism from players and officials alike.
According to data from the opening round of the season, there was an average of eight restarts and 11.5 penalties per game, representing a 35 per cent increase in six-agains compared to 2025. This increase has contributed to the highest average winning margin in 25 years, raising concerns about the impact of the rule changes on game flow and competitive balance.
Payten Calls for Clarity, Focuses on Fundamentals
Payten echoed Dearden’s frustration, suggesting a preference for clear-cut penalties rather than the current interpretation of ruck infringements. “I like the way the game was refereed in Vegas, it was a bit different to this game today,” Payten stated. “But it’s bringing fatigue into the game and the game is fast enough. The referees are just more willing to blow those ruck infringements. You’re not really sure what they’re for. I would prefer that if it’s not a full-blown penalty, don’t give it a ruck infringement.”
The Cowboys coach also addressed a sin bin issued to lock Kai O’Donnell for repeated infringements, stating he would seek clarification on the decision. Beyond the refereeing concerns, Payten emphasized the need for the team to address fundamental errors that plagued their performance against the Tigers. North Queensland committed 46 missed tackles, six penalties, and 13 errors, allowing Benji Marshall’s side to capitalize with 21 offloads and eight line breaks. Jarome Luai played a key role in the Tigers’ attack, contributing three try assists.
Looking Ahead: A Week to Reset
Payten conceded the team would return to North Queensland to regroup and focus on preparation for the weeks ahead. “It’s really important,” Payten said of turning the season around. “It will be good to get around our families and focus on our prep. We’ve got a couple of big weeks. It’s important that we train to win this week and then get our physical state right and mentally, be ready to go.” He acknowledged the need for individual accountability, stating, “Everyone has got to look at their own performance here, there is some fundamental stuff which really hurts.”
The Cowboys will need to quickly address their issues if they hope to regain momentum. Their start to the season has been hampered by errors and a lack of clarity regarding officiating, but Payten remains confident in the team’s ability to bounce back. The focus now shifts to preparation and a renewed commitment to fundamental execution as they look to improve their performance in the coming weeks.
What are your thoughts on the new six-again rules? Share your opinions in the comments below!
