The Shifting Sands of AEW’s “Four Pillars”: What It Means for Wrestling’s Future
The wrestling world is built on narratives, and few have been as intriguing as the rise and potential fall of AEW’s self-proclaimed “Four Pillars.” While initial hype suggested a future dominated by MJF, Darby Allin, Sammy Guevara, and “Jungle Boy” Jack Perry, recent comments from MJF himself reveal a starkly different reality: fan investment, he believes, has largely narrowed to just two. This isn’t simply a matter of bruised egos; it’s a crucial case study in how quickly wrestling’s landscape can change, and what it signals about the evolving demands of modern fans.
The Erosion of the “Pillar” Concept
The “Four Pillars” moniker, coined early in AEW’s existence, represented a promise of generational talent. Each wrestler brought a unique skillset and charisma to the table. However, as MJF bluntly stated in a recent interview with Vice, “The only two pillars that people genuinely thought were pillars were me and Darby [Allin].” This assessment, while characteristically boastful, highlights a critical point: sustained momentum in professional wrestling is exceptionally difficult to achieve.
Several factors contribute to this. The relentless pace of the wrestling calendar demands constant reinvention. Shifting storylines, injuries, and the emergence of new talent all play a role. “Jungle Boy” Jack Perry, for example, has seen his momentum stall amidst creative inconsistencies, while Sammy Guevara, despite undeniable talent, has struggled to consistently connect with the audience on a deeper level. MJF’s own evolution, transforming into a compelling villain, has arguably eclipsed the initial promise of the group as a whole.
The Rise of the Anti-Hero and the Protagonist/Antagonist Dynamic
MJF’s current feud with Hangman Page is central to understanding this shift. He explicitly frames Page as the “main protagonist” of AEW, positioning himself as the necessary “main antagonist.” This dynamic is a classic wrestling trope, but its effectiveness in the modern era is noteworthy. Fans increasingly gravitate towards complex characters, even those they love to hate. The willingness to embrace morally grey figures, like MJF, demonstrates a growing sophistication in the wrestling audience.
This trend isn’t unique to AEW. Across the industry, we’re seeing a move away from purely heroic figures towards characters with flaws and relatable vulnerabilities. The success of stars like Seth Rollins in WWE, who expertly blend arrogance and athleticism, underscores this point. The key is authenticity – fans can spot a manufactured persona a mile away. MJF’s ability to deliver scathing promos and genuinely connect with his character’s motivations is a major reason for his current popularity.
The Impact of Social Media and Direct Fan Interaction
Social media has fundamentally altered the relationship between wrestlers and fans. Direct interaction allows performers to cultivate a personal brand and bypass traditional media gatekeepers. MJF, in particular, is a master of this, using platforms like Twitter to amplify his character and engage in provocative exchanges with fans. This direct connection fosters a sense of investment and allows wrestlers to control their own narratives to a greater extent.
However, this also creates increased pressure to consistently deliver. The 24/7 news cycle and the immediacy of social media mean that any misstep can be quickly amplified and scrutinized. Maintaining momentum requires constant effort and a keen understanding of what resonates with the audience. This is where the “pillars” concept falters – sustaining that level of engagement over the long term is incredibly challenging.
Looking Ahead: The Future of AEW’s Top Stars
The evolution of the “Four Pillars” narrative offers valuable lessons for AEW and the wider wrestling industry. Focusing on compelling storylines, authentic character development, and leveraging the power of social media are crucial for building lasting stars. The emphasis should be on creating genuine connections with the audience, rather than relying on pre-defined labels or expectations.
The upcoming match between MJF and Hangman Page at Forbidden Door on August 24th is a pivotal moment. A victory for MJF would solidify his position as AEW’s top heel and further cement the protagonist/antagonist dynamic. However, regardless of the outcome, the story arc surrounding these wrestlers will continue to shape the future of AEW. The wrestling landscape is constantly evolving, and only those who can adapt and connect with the audience will truly thrive. The concept of “pillars” may be fading, but the need for compelling, authentic stars remains stronger than ever.
What are your predictions for the future of AEW’s top stars? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
