The Supreme Court of the United States dealt a significant blow to former President Donald Trump’s trade policies on Thursday, striking down a substantial portion of his tariffs as unconstitutional. However, the ruling offers limited immediate relief to Canada, as key tariffs impacting Canadian industries remain in place.
While the court’s decision invalidates some of the tariffs imposed by Trump, it does not address the duties on steel, aluminum, lumber and automobiles – sectors critical to the Canadian economy. “The U.S. Tariffs on steel, aluminum, lumber, and other key sectors [like the automotive industry] remain in place and continue to weaken our industries, jobs, and regions,” stated Quebec’s Minister of Economy, Jean Boulet.
Canada currently benefits from exemptions from U.S. Tariffs on many goods due to the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement (CUSMA), formerly known as NAFTA. However, this agreement is scheduled for review this year, setting the stage for potentially contentious negotiations with Washington. Canada’s Finance Minister, François-Philippe Champagne, indicated that the Supreme Court ruling validates Canada’s long-held position against the tariffs, calling them “justified,” but the government has remained cautious in its public response.
The Supreme Court’s 6-3 decision, which included dissenting votes from conservative justices, reportedly left Trump visibly angered. According to reports, he labeled the judges who ruled against him as “garbage.” The ruling overturned tariffs imposed on imports from various countries, but the core tariffs affecting Canadian trade were not among those invalidated. The decision is particularly notable given the court’s conservative majority, with three justices appointed by Trump himself – John Roberts, Amy Coney Barrett, and Neil Gorsuch – joining the majority in striking down the tariffs.
“I am ashamed of some members of the Court, totally ashamed, because they did not have the courage to do what was right for our country,” Trump said, visibly agitated at a press conference at the White House.
The ruling comes as Trump faces a series of setbacks, including challenges to his immigration policies following incidents involving the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency. Earlier this week, the House of Representatives, with support from six Republicans, passed a resolution calling for the repeal of tariffs imposed on Canada, though the resolution lacks the force of law. This vote signals growing dissent within the Republican party regarding Trump’s trade policies.
Despite this setback, Trump has vowed to implement alternative measures, including a potential 10% global tariff, utilizing what he described as “even more powerful” mechanisms. However, the Supreme Court ruling has similarly opened the door for U.S. Companies to seek reimbursement for the approximately $180 billion in tariffs they have paid since the duties were first implemented.
Ottawa has been actively working to reduce its reliance on the U.S. Market, and these efforts are expected to continue. With Trump showing no signs of backing down, and potentially becoming more aggressive ahead of the November midterm elections, the trade relationship between Canada and the United States remains uncertain.