Technology

The weight of criticism often falls heavier when it comes from the creator of the very saga being scrutinized. David Jaffe, director of the original God of War and creative director of God of War 2, has publicly voiced his strong disapproval of God of War: Sons of Sparta, the recently released 2D spin-off that surprised players during PlayStation’s State of Play. Jaffe’s assessment is blunt: he believes the game is a misstep for the franchise and, in some respects, an insult to both fans and the developers who worked on it.

Jaffe detailed his disappointment in a recent YouTube video, stating he found little to enjoy in Sons of Sparta. He specifically criticized the portrayal of a younger Kratos, calling the character a “generic kid” lacking the emotional weight and identity of the Kratos players have come to know. His concerns extend to the game’s production values, voice acting, and overall price point. The unexpected release of Sons of Sparta, alongside announcements of remakes of the original trilogy, has sparked debate among fans, but Jaffe’s perspective carries particular significance given his foundational role in the series.

Jaffe’s Scathing Critique of ‘Sons of Sparta’

“What were they thinking? Seriously, what were they thinking? Why does this exist? I don’t understand, I just don’t understand,” Jaffe exclaimed in his video (via Push Square). He stated he only played approximately one hour of the game and has no intention of returning to it. Jaffe also expressed frustration with the game’s frequent interruptions for dialogue and perceived shortcomings in the voice acting. He suggested, based on conversations with former Santa Monica Studio employees, that the studio is increasingly prioritizing narrative complexity, citing the storyline involving Atreus and Angrboda in God of War Ragnarok as an example.

The creator of Twisted Metal went on to compare Sons of Sparta unfavorably to other games in the 2.5D action-platformer genre, including Blasphemous, Neon Inferno, Ninja Gaiden Ragebound, and Shinobi: Art of Vengeance. He argued that these titles offer superior visuals, gameplay, and value for money, with many available for under $30. “This really pisses me off. Not just because I have a personal connection to the brand and the franchise, but because it shows a collapse of the great creative work that Sony has done in the past,” Jaffe stated.

A Departure from the Core ‘God of War’ Identity?

Jaffe didn’t hold back in his overall assessment, labeling the game “garbage,” “absurd,” and “stupid,” and advising viewers to “avoid this shit.” He acknowledged that Sons of Sparta is “well-made, but generic and boring,” and described it as “one of the worst decisions the God of War team has ever made,” calling its very existence “confusing, and offensive.” Interestingly, Jaffe initially expressed interest in a 2D God of War game, having long advocated for the idea, but ultimately concluded that Sons of Sparta fails to capture the essence of the franchise. He questioned whether the younger Kratos possesses the emotional depth and established identity of the character fans have grown to love.

Jaffe’s criticism stems from a broader dissatisfaction with the direction God of War has taken since 2018, when Sony Santa Monica opted to humanize Kratos through his relationship with his son, Atreus. He believes this shift diminished the core elements that defined the original games, and Sons of Sparta represents a further departure. Despite Jaffe’s harsh critique, player reception on the PlayStation Store has been largely positive, with the game currently holding a 4.8/5 rating based on over 3,000 user reviews. Many players describe it as an enjoyable and worthwhile experience while larger projects in the franchise are in development.

What’s Next for the ‘God of War’ Franchise?

Beyond Sons of Sparta, Santa Monica Studio is actively working on remakes of the original God of War trilogy, a project that is still in its early stages and expected to grab years to complete. There is also speculation that the studio is developing at least two additional projects: a sequel to God of War Ragnarok and a fresh intellectual property led by Cory Barlog. More information is expected in the coming months, alongside updates on the in-development God of War television series, which is currently in the casting phase and is tentatively slated for release in mid-to-late 2027.

The release of God of War: Sons of Sparta, despite the creator’s disapproval, highlights the ongoing evolution of the franchise and the challenges of balancing fan expectations with creative experimentation. Whether this spin-off will be remembered as a bold step or a miscalculation remains to be seen, but it has undoubtedly sparked a conversation about the future of God of War.

What are your thoughts on God of War: Sons of Sparta? Share your opinions in the comments below!