Challenging the Myth: Why Obesity and Health Issues Persist in Dogs Despite Standard Diets and Treatments

veterinarians Question Traditional dog Food: Is Dry Kibble harmful?

october 21, 2025

A growing number of Veterinarians and canine nutrition experts are challenging the conventional wisdom surrounding dry dog food. While frequently enough the first choice for pet owners, this staple is now under increased scrutiny by professionals in the field.

Canine nutritionist Raquel Pavo and Veterinarian Neus Candela have recently voiced concerns about the long-term effects of feeding dogs exclusively a dry food diet. Candela,in a recent social media post,questioned the practicality of feed without considering a dog’s true nutritional needs.

Veterinarian Neus Candela emphasizes that solely relying on dry food may not provide a dog with a complete and balanced diet.

According to Candela, the prevailing mindset that feed is the only viable option has led to numerous health issues in dogs. She observes that dogs consuming primarily dry food often struggle with weight management, persistent allergies, and require extensive medication without meaningful improvement.

These observations align with increasing research suggesting that a more natural, ingredient-rich diet is optimal for canine well-being. A study published in the Journal of Animal Physiology and Animal Nutrition (November 2023) highlighted the benefits of fresh, whole-food diets for improved digestion and immune function in dogs.

Diet Type	Pros	Cons
Dry Kibble	Convenient, Cost-Effective, Long Shelf Life	Potential for Nutritional Deficiencies, Highly Processed, Lower Digestibility
Fresh Food	Highly Digestible, Nutrient-Rich, Supports Optimal Health	More Expensive, Requires Readiness, Shorter shelf Life

Candela advocates for tailored diets based on specific ingredients that address individual canine needs and underlying health issues. She stresses the importance of considering the root cause of health problems rather than simply managing symptoms with medication.

“It’s not about dismissing feed entirely,” Candela clarifies, “but about utilizing all the tools that clinical nutrition offers us.” She recommends seeking individualized professional consultations for dogs with health concerns to determine the most appropriate dietary plan.

Did You Know? According to the American Pet Products association (APPA), approximately 70% of dog owners in the United States primarily feed their pets dry kibble.

Pro Tip: When transitioning your dog to a new diet, do so gradually over 7-10 days to avoid digestive upset.

Do you believe pet food labels are clear enough to make informed decisions about your dog’s diet? What steps are you willing to take to improve your pet’s nutritional health?

Understanding Canine Nutritional Needs

Dogs require a balanced diet consisting of proteins, fats, carbohydrates, vitamins, and minerals to thrive. The specific ratios of these nutrients vary based on age, breed, activity level, and overall health. A diet lacking in essential nutrients can lead to a range of health problems, including skin issues, digestive problems, and weakened immunity. the rise of ’boutique’ or premium dog food brands demonstrates a growing consumer awareness of the impact of diet on pet health. However, it’s crucial to remember that ‘premium’ doesn’t always equate to ‘nutritionally superior’ without careful consideration of ingredients and formulation.

Frequently Asked Questions about Dog Food

Share your thoughts! What are your experiences with different dog food options? Leave a comment below and join the conversation.

How can genetic testing and metabolomics personalize dietary recommendations to address breed-specific predispositions to obesity?

The Limitations of “Standard” Dog Food

For years,pet owners have diligently followed veterinary advice and fed their dogs what’s considered “standard” dog food. Yet, we’re seeing a concerning rise in canine obesity and related health problems like diabetes, arthritis, and heart disease.Why is this happening? The issue isn’t necessarily what we’re feeding, but how it’s made and what it truly provides for a dog’s biological needs.

Many commercial dog foods, even those labeled “premium,” rely heavily on:

* Grain-heavy formulations: While dogs can digest some grains, excessive amounts can contribute to inflammation and weight gain.

* Low-quality protein sources: By-products and fillers offer minimal nutritional value compared to whole meat proteins.

* Excessive carbohydrates: Dogs don’t require high-carb diets. These contribute to insulin resistance and obesity.

* processed ingredients: Rendering processes can strip away essential nutrients and introduce harmful compounds.

These factors can create a cycle where dogs are technically “fed” but are still nutritionally deficient, leading to overeating and weight gain as they instinctively seek missing nutrients.

Understanding canine Metabolic Differences

Each dog is an individual. Breed, age, activity level, and even genetics play a important role in their metabolic rate and nutritional requirements. A “one-size-fits-all” approach to dog food simply doesn’t work.

Consider these factors:

* Breed Predispositions: Labrador Retrievers, for example, are genetically predisposed to obesity due to a mutation in the POMC gene affecting appetite regulation.

* Age-Related Changes: Puppies need nutrient-dense food for growth, while senior dogs require fewer calories and more joint support.

* Activity Levels: A working dog will have drastically different energy needs than a couch potato.

* Gut microbiome: The composition of a dog’s gut bacteria influences nutrient absorption and weight management. A disrupted microbiome can contribute to obesity and inflammation.

The Role of Gut health in Weight Management

The gut microbiome is increasingly recognized as a key player in overall health, including weight control. An imbalance in gut bacteria (dysbiosis) can:

* Increase inflammation: Chronic inflammation is linked to obesity and various diseases.

* Impair nutrient absorption: Leading to deficiencies and increased appetite.

* Alter metabolism: Affecting how the body processes food and stores fat.

* Influence hormone regulation: Including hormones that control appetite and satiety.

Supporting Gut Health:

* Probiotics: Introduce beneficial bacteria to the gut.

* prebiotics: Feed existing beneficial bacteria. Sources include inulin,fructooligosaccharides (FOS),and mannanoligosaccharides (MOS).

* Fermented Foods: Small amounts of plain yogurt or kefir (ensure they are xylitol-free) can provide probiotics.

* Fiber-Rich Foods: Promote a healthy gut surroundings.

Beyond Diet: The Impact of Lifestyle Factors

Obesity and health issues aren’t solely about diet. Lifestyle plays a crucial role.

* Lack of Exercise: Insufficient physical activity contributes to weight gain and muscle loss. Aim for at least 30 minutes of moderate exercise daily.

* treats & Table Scraps: These often contain hidden calories and unhealthy ingredients. Limit treats to no more than 10% of daily caloric intake.

* Spaying/Neutering: Can slow metabolism and increase appetite. Adjust food intake accordingly.

* Stress: Chronic stress can lead to hormonal imbalances and weight gain. Provide a calm and enriching environment.

The Importance of Personalized Nutrition Plans

The most effective approach to managing weight and health issues in dogs is a personalized nutrition plan developed in consultation wiht a veterinary nutritionist. This involves:

1. Extensive Assessment: A thorough evaluation of the dog’s breed, age, activity level, medical history, and current diet.
2. Body Condition Scoring: Assessing the dog’s body fat percentage to determine ideal weight.
3. Dietary Recommendations: Tailored food choices and portion sizes based on individual needs.
4. Regular Monitoring: Tracking weight, body condition, and overall health to adjust the plan as needed.

Real-World Example: I recently worked with a 10-year-old Beagle named winston who was struggling with arthritis and obesity. Despite being fed a “senior” diet, he continued to gain weight and his arthritis worsened. After a detailed assessment, we discovered he had a significant sensitivity to corn, a common ingredient in his food. Switching him to a limited-ingredient diet with a novel protein source (duck) and incorporating omega-3 fatty acids for joint support resulted in a 15% weight loss and a noticeable improvement in his mobility within three months.

Emerging Research & Future Directions

Research into canine nutrition is constantly evolving.Areas of focus include:

* Genetic testing: Identifying genetic predispositions to obesity and other health issues.

* Metabolomics: Analyzing the metabolites in a dog’s body to assess nutritional status and metabolic function.

*