Digital Interfaces as Inheritance: Dice’s Construction of Enlightenment Narratives

:

Enlightenment Interfaces: A Conference Recap

paris, France – October 9-10, 2025 – A conference focusing on “Enlightenment Interfaces. Digital Constructions of an Inheritance” was held at the Sorbonne University,Convent of the Cordeliers,Amphi Pasquier.The event explored the intersection of digital humanities and the Enlightenment era.

The first day opened with an introduction from Flora Amann, Servanne Monjour, and Christophe Schuwey. The initial session, “Editing the Lights for the Screen,” featured presentations by Alexandre Guilbaud and Alain Sandrier on the Encyclopedia of Diderot, Alembert and Jaucourt, and Enrico Natale discussing a digital edition of Jean-Jacques Rousseau’s complete works. Nicolas Rieucau and Josselin Morvan presented on the electronic inventory of Condorcet’s correspondence.

Following a break, a roundtable discussion moderated by Flora Amann addressed the editorialization of Enlightenment studies and its historiographical implications. Participants included stéphanie Géhanne-Gavoty, Benoît Melançon, Olivier Ritz, and Christophe Schuwey. The afternoon featured a session on utilizing BNF APIs to study Enlightenment literature with speakers Flora Amann,Marie Carlin,and Ioana galleron.

The day concluded with presentations exploring database-driven scholarship: Dorothée Rusque and Nathalie Vuillemin’s work on a virtual encyclopedia of the Enlightenment, and Christoph Schöch’s exploration of modeling the 18th-century French novel in a database. The final presentations focused on utilizing Wikidata for prosopography and analyzing the digital presence of the Comédie-Française,given by Melanie Conroy and Sara Harvey respectively.

The second day featured presentations on further developments within the same theme.

Further information about the conference, including access to the Zoom link and contact information, is available at https://frenchlibrary.zoom.us/j/84354746199.

How does Dice’s architecture attempt to address Enlightenment concerns regarding intellectual property and attribution?

The algorithmic Legacy of Reason

The Enlightenment, with it’s emphasis on reason, empirical observation, and universal principles, might seem a distant ancestor to the world of digital interfaces. However, a closer examination reveals a profound inheritance. Specifically, the work of Ted Nelson, especially his concept of “Xanadu” and the subsequent implementation of Project Xanadu, and its influence on the development of hypertext systems like the World Wide Web, can be understood as a deliberate attempt to reconstruct Enlightenment ideals within a digital framework. This reconstruction isn’t merely aesthetic; it’s embedded in the very architecture of how we interact with facts online. we’ll explore how these digital structures, often manifested in seemingly simple choices like link design and version control, echo core Enlightenment philosophies. Key terms to consider include hypertext, digital humanities, information architecture, and Enlightenment philosophy.

Xanadu: A Hypertextual Republic of Letters

Ted Nelson’s Xanadu project, conceived in the 1960s, wasn’t simply about creating a better way to link documents. It was a radical vision for a digital “library of all books,” a global hypertext system built on principles of intellectual property and attribution. This vision directly mirrored the Enlightenment’s “Republic of Letters” – a transnational network of scholars and intellectuals who shared ideas through correspondence and publication.

* Two-Way Links: Xanadu’s core innovation was the two-way link. Unlike the unidirectional links of the Web, Xanadu links automatically created a reciprocal connection, acknowledging the source and allowing for easy tracing of intellectual lineage. This directly addresses the Enlightenment concern with intellectual honesty and the proper attribution of ideas.

* Micropayments & Royalties: Nelson envisioned a system of micropayments for every quote or use of copyrighted material,ensuring authors were compensated for their work. This was a response to the Enlightenment’s burgeoning debates around copyright and intellectual property rights.

* Transclusion: The concept of transclusion – embedding portions of documents within other documents without copying – allowed for dynamic, interconnected knowledge creation, mirroring the enlightenment’s emphasis on building upon existing knowledge.

These features weren’t accidental; they were deliberate attempts to encode Enlightenment values into the digital realm.The project, though never fully realized in its original form, laid the groundwork for many of the technologies we use today. Understanding Xanadu’s principles is crucial to understanding the philosophical underpinnings of the web.

The Web’s Divergence: From Ideal to Reality

While the World Wide Web owes a technical debt to Xanadu,it represents a significant divergence from nelson’s original vision. Tim Berners-Lee’s creation, while democratizing access to information, largely abandoned the principles of attribution and compensation that were central to Xanadu.

* Unidirectional Links & Citation Crisis: The Web’s unidirectional links contribute to a “citation crisis,” were tracing the origins of ideas becomes increasingly difficult. This undermines the Enlightenment ideal of intellectual accountability.

* Copyright & Piracy: The ease of copying and distributing content on the Web has led to widespread copyright infringement, challenging the Enlightenment’s emphasis on protecting intellectual property.

* Filter Bubbles & Echo Chambers: Algorithmic curation,while intended to personalize the user experience,can create filter bubbles and echo chambers,limiting exposure to diverse perspectives – a direct contradiction of the Enlightenment’s call for open inquiry and rational debate. Consider the impact of algorithmic bias on information access.

This divergence isn’t necessarily a failure,but it highlights the challenges of translating philosophical ideals into technological realities. The Web, in many ways, reflects a more pragmatic, commercially-driven approach to information management. The study of digital culture helps us understand these shifts.

Dice: reclaiming Enlightenment Values in Interface Design

Dice, a research project led by Brendan Cox at Parsons School of Design, represents a conscious effort to reclaim some of the lost Enlightenment values within digital interfaces. Dice is a protocol and set of tools designed to create “provable” web pages – pages that explicitly document their sources and allow users to verify the information presented.

* Provenance Tracking: Dice uses cryptographic signatures to track the provenance of content, ensuring that users can trace information back to its original source. This directly addresses the Web’s citation crisis.

* Version Control: Dice incorporates version control, allowing users to see how content has changed over time and identify potential manipulations.This aligns with the Enlightenment’s emphasis on empirical observation and the importance of verifiable evidence.

* Attribution & Compensation (Potential): While not fully implemented, Dice’s architecture allows for the possibility of micropayments and royalties, potentially addressing the issue of author compensation.

Dice isn’t about recreating Xanadu; it’s about building a more trustworthy and accountable web, one that reflects the core values of the Enlightenment. The project’s focus on data provenance and digital trust is particularly relevant in an era of misinformation and disinformation.

Case Study: The Impact of Dice on Scholarly Publishing

A pilot project using Dice within the digital humanities demonstrated the potential of the protocol to improve the rigor and transparency of scholarly publishing. Researchers were able to create “provable” versions of their articles, allowing readers to verify the sources and methods used in their research. This increased trust in the scholarship and facilitated more informed debate. This example showcases the practical application of scholarly communication principles.

Practical tips for Building Enlightenment-inspired Interfaces

While