‘All’s Fair’ Faces Brutal Reviews: Kim Kardashian’s New Series Deemed a “failure”
The highly anticipated legal drama All’s Fair, starring Kim Kardashian and an ensemble cast of acclaimed actresses, has premiered to a storm of negative criticism. The series, created by Ryan Murphy, began streaming on Hulu November 4, 2025, immediatly attracting attention – and overwhelmingly unfavorable reviews.
A Star-Studded Cast Cannot Salvage a flawed Series
Alongside Kim kardashian, All’s Fair features Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash, glenn Close, sarah Paulson, and Teyana Taylor, all portraying formidable divorce attorneys. Despite this remarkable lineup, critics have labeled the show a resounding failure, with a current 0% critics score on Rotten Tomatoes. Industry publications are united in their condemnation of the series’s weak script,shallow characters,and ultimately,its lack of resonance.
What Are the Critics Saying?
Angie Han of The Hollywood Reporter described the show as failing to effectively portray female empowerment, and criticized the writing as “stiff and affectless.” She further pointed out that Kardashian’s performance suffers when contrasted with her more experienced co-stars, highlighting her weaknesses as an actor. Han noted the show relies heavily on “fierce looks” and “bitchy one-liners” but these elements do not compensate for the lack of substance.
Any actual emotional resonance or narrative coherence that All’s Fair manages along the way is purely incidental. really, the show is here to serve fierce looks, bitchy one-liners and big juicy moments, with severely mixed results.
lucy Mangan of The Guardian went even further, awarding the series zero stars and calling it “fascinatingly, incomprehensibly, existentially terrible.” Mangan specifically took issue with the show’s misguided concept of empowerment and described the “kissing scenes” as “the worst ever on screen.”
Beyond the embarrassment of the script, there is the embarrassment of the performances; even though I take the point that when someone – in this case, Murphy stalwart Sarah Paulson as psychopathic rival ‘lady’ lawyer Carrington – is required to scream ‘Are you calling me an ugly duckling? So what if I give myself home perms? It’s economical!’, while smashing up her mentor’s office, they are probably not going to be able to give their best.
Alison Herman of Variety observed a concerning lack of female creative involvement, noting that only one of the first two episodes credited a female producer alongside Ryan Murphy. she characterized the show as a “clumsy, condescending take on rah-rah girlboss feminism.”
Ben Dowell of The Times UK similarly dismissed the show’s feminist aspirations, labeling it a “tacky and revolting monument to greed, vanity and avarice.” He called it “may well be the worst television drama ever made.” emily Maddick of Glamour echoed this sentiment, describing the series as lacking emotion and charm, and feeling overly “Kardashian-ified”.
Audience Response Differs From Critics
While critics have universally condemned All’s Fair,the general audience appears to have a more lenient view. as of today, November 5, 2025, the show holds a 54% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, indicating some viewers are finding enjoyment in its over-the-top nature.
The Evolution of Celebrity-Driven Television
The trend of casting celebrities in dramatic television roles is not new.In recent years, stars from diverse backgrounds-music, reality television, and social media-have increasingly sought to establish themselves as actors. This phenomenon reflects a changing media landscape and a blurring of customary entertainment boundaries. While some ventures have been successful, the reception of All’s Fair highlights the challenges of transitioning from celebrity status to convincing dramatic performance.
| Celebrity | Previous Profession | Notable Dramatic Role | Critical Reception |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jennifer Lopez | Musician/Actress | Hustlers (2019) | Generally Positive |
| Lady Gaga | Musician | American Horror Story: Hotel (2015) | Positive |
| Kim Kardashian | Reality Television | All’s Fair (2025) | Overwhelmingly Negative |
frequently Asked Questions About ‘All’s Fair’
- What is ‘All’s Fair’ about? ‘All’s Fair’ is a legal drama centered around the lives of powerful divorce attorneys.
- Who stars in ‘All’s Fair’? The series stars kim Kardashian, Naomi Watts, Glenn Close, Sarah Paulson, Niecy Nash, and Teyana Taylor.
- Where can I watch ‘All’s Fair’? All’s Fair is available to stream on Hulu.
- What is the critical reception of ‘All’s Fair’? Critics have overwhelmingly panned the series, giving it a 0% rating on rotten Tomatoes.
- Is ‘all’s Fair’ written by a predominantly female team? No, only one episode so far has a major female creative credit – shared with Ryan Murphy.
- Will ‘All’s Fair’ have a second season? Given the universally negative reviews, a second season is highly unlikely.
- What is Ryan murphy known for? Ryan Murphy is known for creating successful television series such as American Horror Story, Glee, and Pose.
Do you think a stellar cast can overcome a poorly written script? what role do you see celebrity presence playing in the future of television?
The first three episodes of All’s Fair are available for streaming now on Hulu, with new episodes dropping each tuesday as part of its 10-episode run.
