Lloyds’ Finance Chief Undecided on Entering the Motor Finance Market

Lloyds Banking Group Considers Legal Action Over Motor Finance Redress

Thursday, October 23, 2025, 10:11 AM

Updated: Thursday, October 23, 2025, 10:29 AM

Lloyds has allocated £2 billion to cover potential payouts related to the motor finance scandal.

London, United Kingdom – Lloyds Banking Group is not dismissing the possibility of launching a legal challenge against the Financial Conduct Authority’s proposed motor finance redress scheme. The move comes after the bank earmarked critically important provisions, totaling £2 billion, to cover anticipated payouts, a figure that impacted its recent financial performance.

Financial Concerns Drive Potential Legal Action

William Chalmers, the Chief Financial Officer of Lloyds, articulated the bank’s apprehension regarding the FCA’s proposed scheme. He emphasized that the lender believes the scheme could unfairly disadvantage some customers, creating an inconsistent application of redress. Chalmers stated that Lloyds intends to actively participate in the FCA’s consultation process, hoping to achieve a more balanced outcome.

When questioned about a potential court battle, Chalmers declined to comment on specific actions beyond the ongoing consultation. This guarded response suggests that all options – including legal recourse – remain on the table.

the FCA’s Redress Scheme Overview

The Financial Conduct Authority’s consultation, currently open until November 18, proposes a threshold of 35 percent commission for assessing unfairness in motor finance agreements. Approximately 14.2 million agreements are potentially eligible for review. The FCA estimates this scheme will provide compensation to a significant number of consumers who may have been adversely affected by high commission rates on car loans.

Impact on the Financial Sector

Charlie Nunn, Chief executive of Lloyds, previously cautioned that the redress scheme could erode two decades of profitability within the broader motor finance industry. The financial implications are substantial, prompting concerns from other lenders about the scheme’s sweeping scope and potential cost.

Understanding the Historical Context

The current situation stems from a Supreme Court ruling earlier this year that found certain commission practices in motor finance to be unfair.while the court sided with lenders in several cases, it upheld a claim based on a 55 percent commission rate being deemed unreasonable. This ruling prompted the FCA to review past practices and implement a redress scheme.

Key Stakeholder	Position
Lloyds Banking group	Concerned about fairness; Considering legal challenge.
Financial Conduct Authority (FCA)	Implementing a redress scheme for potentially mis-sold motor finance.
Consumers	Potential recipients of compensation for unfair commission rates.

The FCA maintains that the scheme represents the most effective and cost-efficient method for addressing the issue. It stresses the need to establish a definitive resolution to restore confidence in the motor finance market.

Did You Know? The average car loan commission rate in the UK has historically been around 10-12%, but some lenders previously offered rates as high as 80-90%.

Long-Term Implications of the Redress Scheme

This situation highlights the importance of openness and fair practices within the financial services industry. Increased regulatory scrutiny and consumer awareness are likely to lead to more responsible lending practices in the future. The outcome of this dispute will set a precedent for similar cases and will likely influence the direction of consumer finance regulation for years to come.

pro Tip: If you suspect you were unfairly charged commission on a car loan, gather all relevant documentation and contact the Financial Ombudsman Service for guidance.

Frequently Asked Questions About Motor Finance Redress

What are your thoughts on the potential legal action? Share your opinion in the comments below!

What potential financial implications for Lloyds Banking Group arise from possible retrospective redress payments related to the FCA investigation?

Current Market Landscape: A Complex Picture

the UK’s motor finance sector is currently navigating a period of significant scrutiny and change. Recent investigations by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) into potential commission arrangements have created uncertainty, impacting profitability for lenders and dealerships alike. Lloyds Banking Group’s Finance Chief, William Chalmers, has publicly stated the bank is carefully evaluating the risks and rewards before committing to a larger presence in this market. This hesitation stems from the FCA’s review, which focuses on discretionary commission models that may have incentivized car dealers to inflate loan amounts, leading to higher costs for consumers.

The FCA’s findings, expected to be finalized in early 2026, will likely dictate the future regulatory framework for auto loans and car financing. chalmers has indicated Lloyds is awaiting clarity on these regulations before making a definitive decision. The potential for retrospective redress payments to customers affected by unfair practices is a major concern for all players, including Lloyds.

Lloyds’ Existing Footprint in Automotive Lending

Lloyds already has a presence in the vehicle finance market through its Black Horse division. However, its market share is smaller compared to competitors like Santander Consumer Finance and MoneySuperMarket. Black Horse primarily focuses on prime borrowers,offering hire purchase (HP) and personal contract purchase (PCP) agreements.

* Current Strategy: Lloyds has been strategically scaling back its riskier lending activities in recent years, focusing on more secure and profitable areas.

* Black Horse Performance: While Black Horse remains profitable, its growth has been constrained by the broader market uncertainty and the FCA investigation.

* Potential Expansion Areas: Should Lloyds decide to expand, potential areas include:

* Electric vehicle (EV) Finance: Capitalizing on the growing demand for EVs with specialized financing products.

* Used Car Finance: A larger and more accessible market segment than new car finance.

* Subprime Lending: A higher-risk, higher-reward segment, requiring careful risk management.

the impact of the FCA Investigation on Motor Finance

The FCA’s investigation centers around weather discretionary commission schemes used by dealerships led to consumers paying more for their car loans. These schemes allowed dealers to vary the commission they received from lenders based on the interest rate offered to the customer. the FCA argues this created an incentive for dealers to prioritize their own profits over securing the best deal for the borrower.

here’s a breakdown of the key concerns:

1. Discretionary Commission: The core issue revolves around the lack of clarity and potential conflicts of interest inherent in these schemes.
2. Inflated interest Rates: The FCA believes some consumers were offered higher interest rates than they should have been, resulting in increased borrowing costs.
3. Redress Payments: Lenders may be required to compensate customers who were unfairly disadvantaged by these practices. The estimated cost of redress could run into billions of pounds.
4. Regulatory Changes: The FCA is expected to introduce new rules governing commission arrangements in the motor finance sector,perhaps banning discretionary schemes altogether.

Risks and Opportunities for Lloyds

Entering the motor finance market, or expanding its existing presence, presents both significant risks and potential opportunities for lloyds.

Risks:

* Regulatory Uncertainty: The FCA’s final findings and subsequent regulations could significantly impact the profitability of motor finance.

* Reputational Damage: Involvement in potential redress schemes could damage Lloyds’ reputation.

* Competition: The market is highly competitive, with established players already holding significant market share.

* Economic Downturn: A slowdown in the UK economy could lead to increased defaults on car loans.

Opportunities:

* Market Growth: Despite the current challenges, the motor finance market is expected to grow in the long term, driven by demand for new and used vehicles.

* EV Transition: The shift towards electric vehicles presents a significant opportunity for lenders to offer specialized financing products.

* Digital Innovation: Leveraging technology to streamline the loan submission process and improve customer experience.

* Strategic Partnerships: Collaborating with car manufacturers and dealerships to offer integrated financing solutions.

The Role of Technology in Future Motor Finance

Fintech companies are increasingly disrupting the auto loan market, offering innovative solutions such as:

* Online Loan Applications: Streamlined and convenient application processes.

* Automated Credit Scoring: Faster and more accurate credit assessments.

* Personalized Financing Offers: Tailored loan products based on individual borrower profiles.

* Data Analytics: Utilizing data to identify and mitigate risk.

Lloyds will need to invest in technology to remain competitive in this evolving landscape. Embracing digital lending platforms and leveraging artificial intelligence (AI) will be crucial for attracting and retaining customers.The integration of Open Banking also presents opportunities to access more comprehensive borrower data and improve risk assessment.

Impact on Consumers: What to Expect

irrespective of Lloyds’ decision, consumers can expect changes in the car finance market.

* Increased Transparency: New regulations are likely to require lenders and dealerships to be more clear about commission arrangements and interest rates.

*