Medicare Advantage Growth Doesn’t Lead to Reduced Hospital Profits: MedPAC Report Highlights Discrepancy

Medicare Advantage Growth Doesn’t Impact Hospital Finances, New Study Finds

washington D.C. – A newly released analysis challenges long-held concerns within teh healthcare industry, indicating that the substantial growth of Medicare Advantage (MA) plans hasn’t considerably altered hospital profit margins. The report, issued by the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC) on Friday, September 6, 2025, offers a counterpoint to hospital assertions that the rise of these privatized plans is contributing to financial strain, especially for rural hospitals.

Medicare Advantage: A Rapidly Expanding Landscape

Currently, over half of the 66.5 million Americans eligible for Medicare – approximately 35 million individuals – are enrolled in Medicare advantage plans, a significant increase over the past decade. Beneficiaries are drawn to these plans due to their frequently enough more comprehensive benefits, predictable out-of-pocket costs, and inclusion of prescription drug coverage, coupled with extensive marketing efforts by insurance providers. As of February 2025, Medicare enrollment totaled 66.5 million people according to data from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS).

Hospital Concerns and Prior Authorization Issues

The expanding role of MA plans has sparked debate, with lawmakers, patient advocates, and policy analysts raising concerns. Research indicates that Medicare Advantage plans can be more expensive for the government than customary Medicare. Moreover, there are reports of potential profiteering by some participating health plans and heightened barriers to care for seniors. Hospitals, particularly those in rural areas, have voiced concerns about lower reimbursement rates, cumbersome prior authorization requirements, and other administrative burdens imposed by these plans.

the medpac Findings: A Closer Look

The american Hospital Association reports that average MA payments to rural hospitals were recently around 90% of what traditional Medicare provided. This led many facilities to curtail contracts with MA plans, with becker’s Hospital Review documenting 27 health systems dropping MA insurers in the first half of 2025. Despite these alarms, MedPAC’s study – analyzing hospital cost data from 2013 to 2023 alongside MA market penetration rates – revealed a surprising disconnect.

Researchers discovered a modest correlation: a 10 percentage point increase in MA penetration corresponded to a 1.3% decrease in hospital revenue, offset by a 1.2% decrease in costs. Critically, the study found no statistically significant impact on overall hospital profitability. The analysis held true for critical access hospitals and integrated health systems that both operate a hospital and an MA plan.

Metric	Impact of 10% increase in MA Penetration
Hospital Revenue	-1.3%
Hospital Costs	-1.2%
Hospital Profit Margin	No Statistically Significant Impact

Industry Reaction and Ongoing Debate

Susan Reilly,Vice President of Communications for the Better medicare Alliance,stated the analysis clarifies that concerns about Medicare Advantage harming hospital finances are unsupported by data. She emphasized that Medicare Advantage delivers value for both seniors and taxpayers. However, MedPAC researchers cautioned that their analysis reveals associations, not direct cause-and-effect relationships, and that other influencing factors weren’t fully incorporated into the study. Future research will need to assess unintended consequences on payment rates.

Understanding Medicare Advantage & Traditional Medicare

Medicare Advantage plans offer an option to Original Medicare,allowing private insurance companies to administer benefits approved by Medicare. These plans often include extra benefits,such as vision,dental,and hearing coverage,which are typically not covered by Original Medicare. however, beneficiaries usually need to use a network of providers and may require pre-authorization for certain procedures. traditional Medicare,conversely,allows beneficiaries to see any doctor who accepts Medicare and doesn’t require a primary care physician referral for specialist visits.The choice between these options depends on individual health needs and preferences.

Did you Know? Medicare Advantage enrollment has been steadily increasing for over two decades,driven primarily by the appeal of extra benefits and lower out-of-pocket costs.

Frequently Asked Questions About Medicare Advantage & Hospital Finances

What are your thoughts on the findings of this report? Do you believe Medicare Advantage plans are adequately reimbursing hospitals for their services? Share your comments below!

How do risk adjustment mechanisms within Medicare Advantage impact hospital payments, according to teh MedPAC report?

The MedPAC findings: challenging Conventional Wisdom

The Medicare Payment advisory commission (MedPAC) recently released a report challenging the widely held belief that the increasing enrollment in Medicare Advantage plans directly translates to decreased profitability for hospitals. This finding is significant, particularly as Medicare Advantage enrollment continues its upward trajectory, now covering over 50% of Medicare beneficiaries. The report suggests a more nuanced relationship between MA plan growth and hospital financial performance than previously understood.

Traditionally, the argument posited that as more beneficiaries shift from Original Medicare to Medicare Advantage, hospitals would face increased pressure on reimbursement rates, ultimately impacting their bottom line.This expectation stemmed from the fact that MA plans frequently enough negotiate lower rates with providers than those under fee-for-service Medicare. However, MedPAC’s analysis indicates this isn’t consistently happening.

dissecting the Discrepancy: Why Hospital Profits Remain Stable

Several factors contribute to this unexpected outcome. The report highlights the following key reasons:

Risk Adjustment: Medicare advantage risk adjustment mechanisms are designed to compensate plans for enrolling sicker beneficiaries. This, in turn, can lead to higher payments to hospitals treating those patients, offsetting potential losses from lower negotiated rates.

provider Contracting Dynamics: Hospitals haven’t been as aggressive in pushing back against MA plan rates as anticipated. Many hospitals prioritize maintaining network access for MA beneficiaries,fearing loss of market share. this is especially true in markets with high MA penetration.

Shifting Patient Mix: While MA enrollment is growing, the types of patients choosing these plans aren’t necessarily the ones who would have generated the highest profits under Original Medicare. This subtle shift in patient demographics impacts overall hospital revenue.

Supplemental Benefits & Value-Based Care: The increasing focus on Medicare Advantage supplemental benefits and value-based care models within MA plans can lead to improved care coordination and possibly reduced hospital readmissions, indirectly benefiting hospital finances.

Impact of medicare Advantage on Hospital revenue Cycle

The growth of Medicare Advantage plans is undeniably altering the hospital revenue cycle. Hospitals are now navigating a more complex landscape of prior authorizations, utilization management, and claim denials.

Here’s a breakdown of the key changes:

1. Increased Prior Authorizations: MA plans often require prior authorization for a wider range of services than Original Medicare, creating administrative burdens for hospitals.
2. Utilization Management: MA plans actively manage healthcare utilization, potentially leading to denials for services deemed needless or not medically appropriate.
3. Claim Denials & Appeals: Hospitals are experiencing higher rates of claim denials from MA plans, requiring significant resources for appeals.
4. Contract Negotiation Complexity: Negotiating contracts with numerous MA plans, each with its own specific requirements and reimbursement rates, is a time-consuming and challenging process.

Regional Variations in Medicare Advantage Impact

The impact of Medicare Advantage on hospital profits isn’t uniform across the country. Regional variations play a significant role.

High-Penetration Markets: In areas with high Medicare Advantage market share (e.g.,florida,Arizona),hospitals have generally experienced more pressure on reimbursement rates,but have often adapted through strategic contracting and focusing on high-value services.

Low-Penetration Markets: In regions with lower MA enrollment, the impact on hospital finances has been less pronounced. Hospitals in these areas have more leverage in negotiations with MA plans.

Rural Hospitals: Rural hospitals face unique challenges, as they often have limited negotiating power and rely heavily on Medicare reimbursement. The growth of Medicare Advantage could exacerbate existing financial vulnerabilities.

The Role of Star Ratings and Quality Bonuses

Medicare Advantage star ratings are increasingly significant. plans with higher star ratings receive quality bonus payments from CMS,which can then be used to offer more competitive reimbursement rates to providers. This creates an incentive for MA plans to invest in quality betterment initiatives and attract high-performing hospitals. Hospitals actively participating in Medicare Advantage quality programs can benefit from these incentives.

Future Implications and Considerations

The MedPAC report suggests that the relationship between Medicare Advantage growth and hospital profits is likely to remain complex.Several factors will shape this dynamic in the coming years:

Continued enrollment Growth: Medicare Advantage enrollment projections indicate continued growth, potentially reaching 60% or higher in the next decade.

CMS Policy Changes: Future CMS policies regarding risk adjustment, reimbursement rates, and quality measurement will considerably impact the financial landscape for both MA plans and hospitals.

Consolidation in Healthcare: Ongoing consolidation among hospitals and MA plans could alter bargaining power and influence reimbursement rates.

Focus on Value-Based Care: The continued shift towards value-based care within Medicare Advantage will likely drive innovation and incentivize hospitals to improve quality and efficiency.

Practical Tips for Hospitals Navigating the MA Landscape

**Data