News 12 Long Island’s Shifting Landscape: What the Exodus of Local Anchors Signals for the Future of Regional Media
The familiar faces that once defined local television news on Long Island are increasingly becoming memories. Since 2017, News 12 Long Island has seen a significant departure of on-air talent, including anchors and reporters who were instrumental in shaping the station’s identity and connecting with viewers for generations. This trend, highlighted by the recent departures of 25-year veteran Elizabeth Hashagen and meteorologist Samantha Augeri, prompts a deeper look into what this mass exodus signifies for the future of regional media, viewer engagement, and the careers of broadcast professionals.
The reasons behind these departures are varied, ranging from buyouts and cutbacks to retirements and the pursuit of new opportunities. What remains consistent is the impact on the local news ecosystem, leaving a void that loyal viewers will undoubtedly notice. As these seasoned professionals move on to roles in communications, other media outlets like NewsdayTV, or even entirely different industries, the landscape of Long Island’s broadcast journalism is undergoing a profound transformation.
The Evolving Careers of Local News Personalities
Examining the pathways of departing News 12 personalities reveals a complex interplay of industry shifts and individual career aspirations. Many have transitioned to roles that leverage their communication skills in different capacities. For instance, Danielle Campbell, a fixture for years, is now heading communications for Catholic Charities of Long Island, while Elisa DiStefano has found a new home as a senior lifestyle host for NewsdayTV. This pattern suggests a growing trend of media professionals repurposing their expertise in less traditional, yet often equally impactful, roles.
The list of departures is extensive and includes many who were foundational to News 12’s success:
- Danielle Campbell (1992-2023): Specialized in history and environment stories, now Director of Communications and Development for Catholic Charities of Long Island.
- Elisa DiStefano (2005-22): A prolific reporter and anchor, now Senior Lifestyle Host for NewsdayTV.
- Norm Dvoskin (1986-2016): A beloved personality who retired in 2016 and passed away in 2024.
- Macy Egeland (2017-23): Moved from weekend mornings to 10 p.m. anchor, now reporting for NewsdayTV.
- Andrew Ehinger (1999-2023): Consumer and tech reporter, also hosted “The Download,” now at NewsdayTV and a broadcast media consultant.
- Shari Einhorn (1993-2022): Started as an intern, a 27-year veteran, now reporting for NewsdayTV.
- Meredith Garofalo (2021-23): Meteorologist who moved to WBNS/10 in Columbus, Ohio.
- Doug Geed (1986-2023): A launch member and host of “The East End,” now covering politics for NewsdayTV.
- Stone Grissom (2011-20): Former prosecutor and well-known anchor, now News Director for WRGB/6 in Albany.
- Virginia Huie (2000-23): A 17-Emmy award-winning reporter, now at NewsdayTV.
- Christine Wehll (2002-22): General assignment reporter, now a real estate broker.
- Bill Korbel (1994-2019): Longtime meteorologist, now retired but doing occasional reporting for NewsdayTV.
- Eileen Lehpams (2003-22): Criminal justice reporter and Murrow Award winner, now at WPIX/11.
- Jackie Lukas (2008-22): Anchor/reporter for the Catholic Faith Network and media consultant.
- Mackenzie Maynard (2021-22): A brief but prominent stint as 10 p.m. co-anchor, now weekend anchor at WNTH/8 in New Haven.
- Colleen McVey (1986-2019): An original morning show anchor, now at Catholic Faith Network.
- Ty Milburn (2009-2023): Veteran reporter and anchor across tristate affiliates, now Director of Productions for the Food Bank For New York City.
- Drew Scott (1997-2017): A seasoned veteran of New York TV, now Director of Communications for the Town of Brookhaven.
- Carol Silva (1986-2019): Beloved morning presence, now retired and active in her church.
- Lea Tyrrell (1986-2017): A charter member and anchor, retired to spend more time with her daughter.
The Shifting Sands of Local News Consumption
This exodus isn’t occurring in a vacuum. It reflects broader shifts in how audiences consume news and the economic realities facing local broadcast stations. The rise of digital-native news organizations, the fragmentation of audiences across social media platforms, and the increasing cost of maintaining large newsroom operations all contribute to this dynamic. For stations like News 12, which are intrinsically tied to a specific geographic region, the challenge is to adapt to changing viewer habits while retaining the community connection that has long been their strength.
The strategy of poaching talent by competitors, particularly digital platforms like NewsdayTV, indicates a recognition of the value these experienced journalists bring. Their established reputations and deep understanding of local issues are assets that can be difficult and time-consuming to cultivate from scratch. This creates a competitive environment where established local news brands must not only attract talent but also find ways to retain it.
What This Means for the Future of Regional Media
The phenomenon at News 12 Long Island serves as a microcosm for the challenges and opportunities facing regional media outlets across the country. The future of local news will likely involve a more agile and diversified approach. This could mean:
- Increased focus on digital-first strategies: Local news organizations will need to excel in delivering content across multiple platforms, catering to on-demand viewing habits.
- Leveraging multimedia storytelling: Reporters will need to be adept at producing video, audio, and written content, engaging audiences through various mediums.
- Emphasis on unique, hyper-local content: As national and global news becomes ubiquitous, regional outlets that can offer deeply localized stories, investigative journalism, and community-focused content will stand out.
- New career paths for journalists: The skills honed in local newsrooms are highly transferable. We may see more journalists moving into roles in public relations, corporate communications, content marketing, and non-profit advocacy, as exemplified by many of the former News 12 personalities.
Consider the evolving role of meteorologists. Meredith Garofalo, for example, not only continues her meteorological duties but also takes on space and science correspondent roles. This demonstrates a demand for versatility and specialized expertise within broadcast news.
Actionable Insights for Media Professionals and Consumers
For broadcast journalists, the current landscape demands adaptability and a proactive approach to career development. Embracing new technologies, seeking out diverse training opportunities, and understanding the broader media ecosystem can open doors to a wider array of fulfilling roles. Building a strong personal brand across social media and professional networks is also becoming increasingly crucial.
For viewers, the departures highlight the importance of supporting local journalism. Engaging with local news content, subscribing to local news outlets, and providing feedback can help ensure the continued viability of these vital community resources. The depth of institutional knowledge and local connection that long-serving anchors and reporters bring is invaluable, and their absence leaves a gap that is difficult to fill entirely.
The industry is also seeing a rise in specialized news delivery. Platforms like the Catholic Faith Network, where former News 12 anchors Jackie Lukas and Colleen McVey have found new roles, showcase the growing niche for highly targeted content. This move towards specialization is a significant trend to watch in the media landscape.
Furthermore, the experience of veterans like Doug Geed, who helped launch News 12 in 1986 and now contributes to NewsdayTV, illustrates the enduring relevance of seasoned journalists. Their deep roots and understanding of the region continue to be a valuable asset, even as the delivery methods evolve.
Ultimately, the story of News 12 Long Island’s departing talent is a testament to the resilience and adaptability of the media industry. While the familiar faces may change, the need for credible, local news remains. The challenge, and the opportunity, lies in reimagining how that news is produced, delivered, and consumed in an ever-evolving digital age. The transition may be marked by the departure of beloved figures, but it also signals a potential for innovation and new avenues for journalistic careers.
What are your thoughts on the future of local news? Share your predictions and experiences in the comments below!
