Seattle Seahawks quarterback Geno Smith faced criticism for throwing the ball away on a fourth-down play even as his team trailed by two scores, a decision that sparked debate among fans and analysts. The play, occurring during a recent game, prompted discussion about game management and risk assessment in crucial situations. While some view it as a pragmatic move to avoid a potential turnover, others question whether a more aggressive approach might have been warranted given the Seahawks’ position in the game.
The incident highlights the challenges quarterbacks face when evaluating down-and-distance situations, particularly when facing a deficit. A key element of successful quarterback play is minimizing negative outcomes, and throwing the ball away avoids a sack or interception. However, the decision to punt possession away when trailing can be a contentious one, especially when the potential for extending a drive exists. The play itself, and the subsequent online reaction, underscores the intense scrutiny quarterbacks operate under, where every decision is dissected and debated.
Fan Reaction and Yardage Saved
The play quickly gained traction on social media, with fans weighing in on Smith’s decision. A post on Reddit, garnering 43 votes and 39 comments, noted that Smith “saved like 15 yards” by intentionally grounding the pass. This observation speaks to the immediate tactical benefit of avoiding a potential loss of yardage, but doesn’t address the broader strategic implications of relinquishing possession. The discussion highlights the nuanced nature of evaluating quarterback decisions, where short-term gains must be balanced against long-term objectives.
Recent Quarterback Performances and Deep Throws
The focus on Smith’s throw comes amid a broader conversation about quarterback performance and the ability to make impactful plays downfield. Recent examples of impressive throws have captured attention across the league. On December 1, 2024, Geno Smith connected with Jaxon Smith-Njigba on a 24-yard pass while under pressure, a play highlighted on YouTube here. This throw demonstrated Smith’s ability to deliver accurately even when facing duress.
Elsewhere, Anthony Richardson of the Indianapolis Colts was praised for an 85-yard touchdown pass in March 2023, as reported on Reddit here. A video on YouTube here showcased a 70-yard throw completed in March 2025. These examples demonstrate the range of arm talent present in the NFL and the potential for game-changing plays through deep passing.
Historical Context: Long Throws and Game-Saving Plays
The discussion around long throws also brings to mind historical moments of quarterback brilliance. Lamar Jackson of the Baltimore Ravens is remembered for a reported 100-yard throw, as documented in a YouTube video here. While the exact distance of Jackson’s throw remains a subject of debate, it exemplifies the spectacular plays that can define a quarterback’s career.
In a separate incident, Mac Jones of the Novel England Patriots was saved from an 84-yard pick-six by a roughing the passer penalty in October 2022, according to CBS News here. This play illustrates how fortunate circumstances can sometimes alter the course of a game, even when a quarterback makes a poor decision.
The Seahawks’ situation, and Smith’s decision, will likely be analyzed as part of a larger pattern of play-calling and game management. The team’s performance in upcoming games will be crucial in determining whether this particular play was an isolated incident or indicative of a broader strategic issue.
Looking ahead, the Seahawks will need to demonstrate a consistent ability to execute effectively in critical situations. The team’s success will depend on Smith’s continued development as a quarterback and the coaching staff’s ability to make sound strategic decisions. Fans and analysts will continue to scrutinize every play, seeking to understand the factors that contribute to winning and losing in the highly competitive world of the NFL.
What are your thoughts on Geno Smith’s decision? Share your opinions in the comments below, and be sure to share this article with fellow football fans.
