MLB Trade Deadline 2025: Orioles and Pirates Eye Future Moves
Could a single trade deadline acquisition be the missing piece for a World Series contender? As the **MLB trade deadline** looms, two teams – the Baltimore Orioles and Pittsburgh Pirates – face critical decisions that could redefine their trajectories for years to come. Forget quick fixes; both franchises are strategically evaluating their assets, identifying potential sellers, and preparing to unearth hidden gems from within their system.
Baltimore Orioles: Navigating a Crossroads
The Baltimore Orioles, once projected for a deep playoff run, find themselves at a pivotal juncture. Injuries and underperformance have created a significant gap in the standings, prompting a potential shift in strategy. Are they buyers or sellers? The answer likely lies in their willingness to part with valuable pieces to solidify their future.
Starting Pitching: A Seller’s Market
Three Orioles starting pitchers – Zach Eflin, Charlie Morton, and Tomoyuki Sugano – are approaching free agency, making them attractive trade targets for teams seeking immediate pitching depth. Eflin and Morton offer invaluable postseason experience, while Sugano’s unique skillset could intrigue risk-tolerant contenders.
If trades materialize, the Orioles will need internal replacements. Three promising prospects – Chayce McDermott, Cameron Weston, and Brandon Young – are waiting in the wings, offering varying degrees of readiness and potential.
Prospect Spotlight: The Next Wave
Chayce McDermott, the Orioles’ top pitching prospect, possesses electrifying stuff but struggles with control. Cameron Weston boasts a diverse pitch mix and excellent command. Brandon Young has already debuted, showcasing his potential but needing to refine his control to maximize his effectiveness.
Consider Chayce McDermott’s challenge. His fastball sizzles, and his slider breaks sharply, but his walk rate is a serious concern. Will he refine his control enough to become a reliable starter, or is his future in a high-leverage bullpen role?
For more in-depth prospect analysis, see our guide on Orioles Farm System Rankings.
First Base: Filling the Void
The potential departure of Ryan O’Hearn would create a significant void at first base. Coby Mayo and Heston Kjerstad, both primarily outfielders, represent internal options but face challenges translating their minor league power to the major league level.
A platoon of Mayo and Kjerstad could provide a short-term solution, allowing each player to leverage favorable matchups while developing their skills. Can either establish himself as the long-term answer at first base?
Pittsburgh Pirates: Building from the Bullpen
The Pittsburgh Pirates, while not in contention, possess valuable bullpen assets that could fetch significant returns at the trade deadline. David Bednar, Dennis Santana, and Caleb Ferguson are all drawing interest, presenting the Pirates with an opportunity to strengthen their farm system and address future needs.
Bullpen Arms: Ready for Primetime
Caleb Ferguson has quietly emerged as a dominant force in the Pirates’ bullpen, showcasing improved control and a devastating sinker. Dennis Santana has transformed his pitch usage, relying heavily on his slider to generate strikeouts and limit hard contact.
The key for Santana has been throwing his slider for strikes. In 2023 he didn’t get many swings with the slider, now it is his primary pitch which generates a lot of chases.
The Pirates’ success in developing relievers highlights a broader trend in baseball. Teams are increasingly focusing on identifying and developing pitchers with specialized skills, transforming bullpens into strategic weapons. A deeper look at these trends is covered in our article on Modern Bullpen Strategies.
Stepping Up: Santana and Ferguson
If Bednar is traded, Santana and Ferguson are poised to take on higher-leverage roles. Santana’s improved control and Ferguson’s refined pitch mix suggest they are ready to thrive in increased responsibilities. The article from Baseball Prospectus analyzes pitching development in modern baseball.
Ferguson’s ability to shut down left-handed hitters with his sinker has been particularly impressive. This specific pitch has allowed him to improve his numbers against lefties by over a run.
Ultimately, the decisions made by the Orioles and Pirates at the trade deadline will shape their competitive landscape for years to come. Will they prioritize short-term gains or long-term sustainability? The answers will reveal their vision for the future. What are your predictions for **MLB trade deadline** deals? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
