The “Othering” of Humanity: How Apple TV’s *Pluribus* Reflects a Growing Societal Trend
Nearly one in four Americans report feeling lonely or socially isolated, a figure that’s doubled since the early 1980s. This isn’t just a personal crisis; it’s a societal shift that’s increasingly reflected in our entertainment. Apple TV+’s new series, Pluribus, doesn’t shy away from this unsettling reality, presenting a world grappling with a fundamental question: what does it mean to be human when “others” exist among us? The show, and the nuanced performance of Rhea Seehorn as Carol Sturka, taps into a growing anxiety about identity, belonging, and the potential for division in an increasingly complex world.
Beyond Sci-Fi: The Psychology of “Othering”
The premise of Pluribus – a sudden transformation of a portion of the population into beings who appear human but lack emotional mirroring – is a compelling sci-fi setup. However, the show’s power lies in its exploration of the psychological phenomenon of “othering.” This isn’t a new concept; history is rife with examples of groups being dehumanized to justify discrimination and conflict. But what happens when the “other” isn’t defined by race, religion, or ideology, but by a subtle, yet profound, difference in emotional response?
Seehorn’s portrayal of Carol Sturka, a fantasy author struggling to navigate this new reality, is particularly insightful. As she reveals in interviews, Carol’s initial reaction isn’t necessarily fear, but frustration and a desperate need for understanding. Her struggle to even *name* the transformed individuals – ultimately settling on “others” – highlights the difficulty of grappling with something that challenges our fundamental assumptions about humanity. This echoes real-world anxieties surrounding artificial intelligence and rapidly evolving technologies, where the line between human and non-human is becoming increasingly blurred.
The Rise of Tribalism and the Search for Connection
The show’s depiction of a fractured society, where trust is eroded and individuals cling to their own groups, resonates with current political and social trends. The rise of tribalism, fueled by social media echo chambers and increasing polarization, is creating a world where empathy is in short supply. Carol’s initial connection to her fellow authors, those she believed would lead the charge in understanding the transformation, is shattered when they retreat into inaction. This mirrors the disillusionment many feel with traditional institutions and leaders in the face of complex global challenges.
Interestingly, Seehorn’s comments on the potential “shipping” of Carol and Zosia (Karolina Wydra) – a relationship built on a strange, almost comedic dynamic – speaks to our innate desire for connection, even in the most unlikely of circumstances. The show subtly suggests that even across profound differences, the need for human (or something akin to human) connection persists. This is a powerful message in a world that often feels increasingly fragmented.
The Future of Empathy in a Post-Human World
Pluribus isn’t just a cautionary tale; it’s an invitation to examine our own biases and assumptions. The series raises critical questions about the nature of empathy, the importance of emotional intelligence, and the potential consequences of a society that prioritizes uniformity over diversity. As AI continues to advance and our interactions with technology become more sophisticated, the ability to recognize and respond to emotional cues – even those that differ from our own – will become increasingly crucial.
The show’s creators deliberately avoid portraying Zosia’s kind as monstrous or alien, emphasizing their sentience and capacity for thought. This is a key distinction. They aren’t enemies to be defeated, but beings to be understood. This approach suggests a future where coexistence, rather than conflict, is the only viable path forward. A recent report by the World Economic Forum highlights the growing demand for “soft skills” like empathy and emotional intelligence in the workplace, suggesting that these qualities will be essential for navigating the challenges of the 21st century.
Ultimately, Pluribus serves as a compelling reminder that our shared humanity – however defined – is worth preserving. The show’s exploration of “othering” isn’t just a fictional narrative; it’s a reflection of the anxieties and challenges facing our world today. And as we grapple with increasingly complex questions about identity, belonging, and the future of our species, the lessons of Pluribus may prove to be more relevant than ever.
What are your thoughts on the themes explored in Pluribus? Share your predictions for how the series will unfold in the comments below!
