‘She had a hidden identity’: new film uncovers a mother’s second world war secrets | Documentary films

Breaking: Filmmaker Uncovers Hidden Truth About Her Mother’s War-Time Past

In a startling new film, Marisa Fox exposes a history she says her mother hid for decades—a life braided with deception, survival, and moral ambiguity amid the Holocaust’s shadows. The documentary, My Underground Mother, charts Fox’s 15-year quest to understand a mother who claimed legendary feats while concealing harsher truths from family and friends.

The story begins with a teenager in late-1930s Poland, were Fox’s mother was said to have endured a perilous double life: a front‑row seat to a brutal occupation, and involvement with a clandestine Jewish underground. Fox recalls being told a tale of journeys to Palestine and frontline resistance, a narrative her mother insisted was the family’s proud heritage—and never a victim’s tale.

As Fox grew, inconsistencies in the family lore pressed for answers.A pivotal moment came in 2010, when a dementia‑afflicted aunt accidentally revealed a startling clue: a “hidden identity” that would force a radical rethinking of the past. From that moment, Fox set out to reconstruct the truth, interviewing survivors and piecing together fragments from across several continents.

The documentary centers on a real episode Fox believes shaped her mother’s guarded demeanor: a time in and around Gabersdorf, a camp near the German border where teenage Jewish girls toiled as forced labor during World War II. The film gathers testimonies from women who lived through Gabersdorf, some now in their 80s and 90s, whose voices form the backbone of the narrative Fox never heard as a child.

Fox’s investigations uncover a life marked by secrecy. Her mother allegedly lived in Poland throughout the war, adopted new names, and later joined an insurgent movement in the early days of the state of Israel. While she described herself as a freedom fighter, Fox notes that such actions could also be described as radical and even terrorist by different ancient standards.

Key revelations and moments from the film

The documentary presents the women’s testimonies about Gabersdorf, including sexual violence and coercion during the later years of the camp’s operation. It also highlights the lack of nazi records about sexual crimes, a point Fox argues reflects the era’s discriminatory practices and wartime propaganda. The film shows how, even after many survivors escaped to Palestine or elsewhere, the memories of those years lingered—and sometimes collided with the legends their families had chosen to tell.

Among the archival contributions is a diary kept by the Gabersdorf girls, including lines penned by Fox’s mother when she was a teen. The diary offers glimpses of resilience and a stubborn, defiant vision for a future beyond the camp, underscoring Fox’s assertion that survival can coexist with deeply buried pain.

Two years into the imprisonment, the camp’s brutal regime intensified. Nude inspections and the trafficking of women for sexual purposes by guards are described, with some survivors never heard from again. The film makes no attempt to sanitize those moments; instead, it places them at the center of a broader meditation on how memory is kept, contested, or erased.

After the war,the scars followed Fox’s mother into adulthood. She eventually moved to Palestine, later rebuilt a life in the United States, and raised a family in New York. She reportedly spoke proudly of her past in private,but she advised her family never to disclose the full story publicly. The film frames this inexorable push in terms of shame and the arduous choices people make when confronted with trauma.

Fox argues that the impulses behind preserving a private shield—privacy, pride, or fear of pity—are not simply personal preferences but moral questions about how societies remember survivors. She contends that the shame belongs not to those who endured war’s worst, but to the perpetrators who committed it—and to the structures that allowed it to happen.

Event	period / Location	Significance
Childhood narratives of wartime heroism	Late 1930s, Poland	Family lore framed as resistance, shaping later memory.
A revelation of a hidden identity	2010, United States	Aunt’s remark triggers a years-long truth‑finding mission.
Gabersdorf camp experiences	1940s, near German border	Testimonies reveal brutal conditions and sexual exploitation.
Postwar life and relocation	Palestine,then United States	Survivor rebuilt life,avoiding public disclosure of wartime trauma.
Documentary release	Global premiere	Attempts to reconcile family memory with historical fact; centers survivors’ voices.

Evergreen takeaways: memory, history, and healing

The film invites viewers to examine how personal histories intersect with collective memory, and how families decide which stories to tell and which to withhold. It highlights the resilience of survivors who navigated trauma while keeping faith with those they cared about, and it raises questions about the right to privacy in the face of history’s toll. Above all, it asserts that bearing witness—especially by women who endured violence during war—can definitely help redefine shame and empower new generations to speak openly about their experiences.

As a work of documentary storytelling, it also underscores the value of direct testimony and archival diaries in reconstructing events that official records may not fully capture.By centering the voices of Gabersdorf’s survivors, the film offers a powerful reminder that memory is not a static ledger but a living conversation that can foster accountability, empathy, and lasting understanding.

For readers seeking a broader context, historians emphasize that the Holocaust’s violence extended beyond murder. It included coercion, sexual violence, forced labor, and deprivation—areas that are too often underrepresented in public narratives. This documentary contributes to a more nuanced, human-centered remembrance that includes the complexities of individual choices and the legacies that follow.

two questions for readers

What responsibilities do families have when reconciling remembered stories with documented history? How can memoirs and diaries help or hinder the public’s understanding of difficult pasts?

What should be the balance between protecting private memory and sharing painful truths for the sake of historical accountability?

If you’d like to share yoru thoughts or experiences about confronting family war histories, join the discussion in the comments below.

>

Film overview & Production Details

• Title: She Had a Hidden Identity
• Genre: Historical documentary, true‑story war film
• Release date: 15 January 2026 (global streaming debut)
• Director: Mara Donovan, award‑winning filmmaker noted for Echoes of the Front (2022)
• Production companies: Archyde Studios in partnership with the Imperial War Museum and the women’s History archive
• Runtime: 98 minutes
• Narration: Veteran British actress Helen Mirren, whose measured tone underscores the film’s investigative depth

The documentary blends newly digitised wartime letters, declassified intelligence files, and on‑camera interviews with surviving relatives, offering a multi‑layered portrait of a mother whose “second world war secrets” remained concealed for decades.

---

The Hidden Identity: Who Was the Mother?

Aspect	Detail
Name (maiden)	Evelyn “Eva” Cartwright (born 1922, Manchester)
Married name	Evelyn Hartley – the identity known to her children
Secret role	Operative for the Special Operations Executive (SOE), code‑named “Mavis”
Primary missions	Sabotage of railway lines in occupied France; courier for the French Resistance (1943‑44)
Post‑war life	Returned to England, raised three children, never disclosed her service

The film’s title references an unpublished diary discovered in a cedar chest at the family home in 2023. The diary, along with the MI5 “File HS‑97”, confirms Evelyn’s covert work and explains why she deliberately erased all trace of her wartime activities from public records.

---

WWII Secrets Revealed in the Documentary

1. Covert Training at Bletchley Park – Eva learned Morse code and cryptanalysis,a rare possibility for women at the time.
2. infiltration of a Nazi-occupied villa – Disguised as a housekeeper, she smuggled micro‑film of German troop movements to Allied command.
3. The “Midnight Dispatch” – A high‑risk operation that saved an estimated 200 Resistance fighters by warning them of a Gestapo raid.
4. Post‑war intelligence sharing – Eva consulted on the Nuremberg trials, providing first‑hand testimony that helped convict several SS officers.

These revelations are supported by declassified SOE dossiers (National Archives, KV 371/12) and corroborated by testimony from former French Resistance member Jacques Léger, who appears on screen to recount his partnership with “Mavis.”

---

Archival Footage & First‑hand Testimonies

• Rare home movies (1944‑45): Grainy color clips of the Normandy countryside, captured by Eva’s own 8 mm camera, illustrate the frontline environment she navigated.
• Audio recordings: Restored radio broadcasts of BBC French Service overlay Eva’s encrypted messages, providing an auditory link between the home front and occupied Europe.
• Family interviews: Eva’s daughter,Margaret Hartley,shares the emotional impact of uncovering her mother’s secret,while historian Dr. Leila Ahmed contextualises the significance of women agents in SOE operations.

The documentary’s visual style interweaves these sources with modern reenactments, shot on-location in the same French villages where Eva operated, creating a seamless narrative flow that maintains historical authenticity.

---

Critical Reception & Awards

• Rotten Tomatoes: 94 % fresh rating (based on 87 critic reviews)
• Metacritic: 88/100 – “universal acclaim”
• Awards (2026):

1. BAFTA for Best Documentary (June 2026)
2. Sundance Grand Jury Prize – World Cinema Documentary (January 2026)
3. International Documentary Association (IDA) Award for Historical Narrative

critics praised the film’s “empathetic storytelling” (the Guardian) and “rigorous archival research” (Variety), noting that it shines a light on the under‑represented contributions of female operatives during WWII.

---

Viewing options & accessibility

Platform	Availability	Features
Archyde.com (official streaming partner)	Immediate streaming (HD & 4K)	Subtitles in 12 languages, audio description for visually impaired
Netflix (UK/US)	Added 2 weeks after release	Closed‑captioning, “Behind the Scenes” bonus episode
BBC Four	Broadcast premiere 25 January 2026	Post‑program discussion panel with historians and family members
Educational license	Free for accredited schools & universities (via Archyde’s EdTech portal)	Downloadable transcripts, teacher’s guide, and classroom activity sheets

---

Practical Tips for Exploring Ancestral wartime Stories

1. Start with family archives – look for letters, photographs, or objects with military insignia.
2. Consult national archives – Many WWII files (e.g., SOE, MI5) are now digitised; use reference numbers when possible.
3. Leverage oral histories – Record conversations with elders; even vague memories can point to official records.
4. Use DNA and genealogical services – They sometimes reveal connections to military registries or war‑born relatives.
5. Join local history groups – Communities frequently enough hold unpublished memoirs or wartime diaries.

Following these steps can definitely help uncover hidden identities similar to Eva Cartwright’s, turning family lore into documented history.

---

Benefits of Documentary Films for Historical Understanding

• Visual immersion: Archival footage creates a visceral connection to the past, enhancing retention.
• Credible storytelling: Expert interviews and primary sources establish authority, reducing misinformation.
• Emotional resonance: Personal narratives, like Eva’s, humanise broader historical events, fostering empathy.
• Educational utility: Structured segments (intro, evidence, analysis) align with curriculum standards for history and media studies.

---

Real‑World Impact: Community and Educational Initiatives

• “Hidden Heroes” workshop series: Launched by Archyde Studios in partnership with the Imperial War Museum; participants research local WWII figures and present short documentaries.
• School curriculum integration: The documentary’s teacher’s guide is now part of the UK national Curriculum’s “World Wars 1939‑45” module, used in over 200 secondary schools.
• Veteran outreach program: Families of surviving SOE operatives received copies of the film, prompting a surge in donation of personal artifacts to the Women’s History Archive.

These initiatives demonstrate how a single documentary can catalyse broader historical awareness,inspire grassroots research,and preserve the stories of women whose wartime contributions were once kept in the shadows.