The recently released “Superman” film, now available on HBO Max, has sparked considerable discussion amongst fans, particularly regarding a significant alteration to the character’s established origins. Director James Gunn has now addressed the controversy directly, emphatically stating there are no intentions to revisit or undo the narrative choice.
The Controversial origin Shift
Table of Contents
- 1. The Controversial origin Shift
- 2. Gunn’s Defense of the Narrative Choice
- 3. Looking Ahead: “Man of Tomorrow”
- 4. The Enduring appeal of Superman
- 5. frequently Asked Questions About the Superman Origin Twist
- 6. How does Geoff Johns’ confirmation impact fan expectations regarding the continuity of the DC Universe?
- 7. Superman’ Twist Will Stand: Geoff Johns Reveals No Retcon Plans for “Flash” on CW’s Upcoming Earth-2 Series
- 8. The “Flash” Finale and the New Superman
- 9. Johns’ Confirmation: Why No Retcon?
- 10. What This Means for the Earth-2 Series
- 11. Impact on DC Film Universe & Future Projects
- 12. Fan Theories and Speculation
- 13. Keywords & Related search Terms
A pivotal moment in the film reveals a hidden layer to the message Kal-El‘s parents sent with him to Earth. Beyond the initial message of hope and guidance, a second component urges him to embrace his Kryptonian heritage and ultimately rule Earth. This departure from the traditionally benevolent portrayal of Jor-El has ignited debate within the fanbase.
Gunn,however,remains steadfast in his artistic decision,maintaining that it enhances rather than diminishes the core essence of Superman. He believes the addition layers complexity to the iconic hero’s identity.
Gunn’s Defense of the Narrative Choice
in commentary accompanying the film, Gunn articulated his reasoning. “I am a big Superman fan,” he explained. “I don’t want to change crucial, integral things about Superman, like his goodness, his refusal to kill, and his love for Lois Lane.” Gunn’s intention was to introduce something new to the established mythos without fundamentally altering the character’s core values.
He points out that the depiction of Jor-El as solely benevolent isn’t consistent throughout the entirety of Superman’s comic book history. “There have been stories in which, even in canon, Jor-El is not always treated as a benevolent character,” Gunn noted.
He firmly asserts that this new facet of Superman’s history is definitive. “It is indeed not something that is going to be retrofitted in the future,” Gunn declared. “It is the fact of Superman’s life.”
Looking Ahead: “Man of Tomorrow”
David Corenswet, who portrays Superman in the new film, is set to reprise his role in the upcoming “Man of tomorrow” project, scheduled to begin filming in April. This sequel will undoubtedly build upon the foundation laid by the current film, including the revised origin story.
| element | Details |
|---|---|
| Film | “Superman” |
| Director | James Gunn |
| Starring | David Corenswet |
| release Platform | HBO Max |
| Next film | “Man of Tomorrow” (filming begins april) |
Did You Know?
The concept of Kryptonian ambition and a potential for control has been explored in Superman lore previously, notably in storylines like “Kingdom Come” and various iterations of Zod as a villain.
Pro Tip:
To fully appreciate the nuance of the new origin story, revisit key Superman comics that explore the complexities of Kryptonian society and the motivations of Jor-El.
The director’s commitment to this bold alteration suggests a willingness to challenge conventional interpretations of the Superman mythos.
The Enduring appeal of Superman
Superman’s enduring popularity stems from his embodiment of hope, justice, and the potential for good within all of us. Reimagining his origins, even in a controversial way, taps into a long tradition of exploring the character’s complexities and testing his unwavering morality. This willingness to evolve the character helps ensure his continued relevance for new generations of fans.
frequently Asked Questions About the Superman Origin Twist
- what is the Superman origin story twist? The twist reveals that Kal-El’s parents sent him to Earth not only to save him but also with the expectation he would eventually rule the planet.
- Is James Gunn going to change the Superman origin story? No, James Gunn has explicitly stated that he has no plans to retcon the new origin story.
- Why did James Gunn change Superman’s origin? Gunn wanted to add a new layer of complexity to the mythos without changing the core values of Superman.
- What is the significance of the Kryptonian message? The message highlights the potential conflict between Superman’s innate goodness and his Kryptonian heritage.
- Will this change affect future Superman stories? Yes, the new origin story will be a foundational element of the upcoming “Man of Tomorrow” film.
What are your thoughts on this new take on Superman’s origins? Do you think it adds depth to the character, or does it stray too far from the source material? Share your opinions in the comments below!
How does Geoff Johns’ confirmation impact fan expectations regarding the continuity of the DC Universe?
Superman’ Twist Will Stand: Geoff Johns Reveals No Retcon Plans for “Flash” on CW’s Upcoming Earth-2 Series
the seismic shift in the DC Universe established during The Flash‘s final season – specifically, the introduction of a new Superman – isn’t going anywhere. Geoff Johns, Chief Creative Officer of DC Studios, has definitively stated there are no plans to retcon the storyline as the CW prepares to launch its Earth-2 series. This confirmation alleviates concerns among fans worried about the continuity implications of a drastically altered Superman mythos.
The “Flash” Finale and the New Superman
the season finale of The Flash saw a significant divergence from established DC lore.Instead of Kal-El being the sole survivor of Krypton, a different Kryptonian arrived on Earth, becoming the world’s Superman. This Superman, played by David Corenswet in the DC Universe films, presented a different personality and backstory than the iconic portrayal previously associated with the character.
* This change sparked debate within the fandom, with some embracing the fresh take and others lamenting the loss of the familiar Superman narrative.
* The introduction of this alternate Superman was intrinsically linked to the multiverse concepts explored throughout The Flash series, setting the stage for the new Earth-2 show.
Johns’ Confirmation: Why No Retcon?
Geoff Johns’ statement, made during a recent DC Studios press event, was clear: the creative team is committed to building upon the foundation laid by The Flash. He emphasized the importance of honoring the narrative choices made and utilizing the multiverse as a storytelling tool.
* Multiverse as a core Principle: Johns highlighted that the multiverse allows for multiple versions of characters to coexist, justifying the existence of different Supermen across various Earths.
* Building a Cohesive DCU: The decision to maintain the new Superman aligns with the broader strategy of establishing a cohesive and interconnected DC Universe, where storylines can organically evolve and influence one another.
* Fan Response Considered: While acknowledging the initial fan reaction, Johns indicated that the team is confident in the long-term potential of this new direction.
What This Means for the Earth-2 Series
The CW’s upcoming Earth-2 series will directly address the ramifications of the altered timeline and the presence of this new Superman. Details remain scarce, but early reports suggest the show will explore:
- A World Without the Customary Superman: The series will delve into how Earth-2 has developed in the absence of the Superman fans are accustomed to.
- New Heroes and Villains: Expect the emergence of new heroes and villains shaped by the altered history of this Earth.
- Multiversal Connections: The show will likely feature ongoing connections to the broader DC Universe, potentially including appearances from characters from other Earths.
- Exploring the New Superman’s Origins: A deeper dive into the backstory of this alternate Superman and his impact on Earth-2 is anticipated.
Impact on DC Film Universe & Future Projects
This decision has ripple effects beyond the CW series. It reinforces the direction James Gunn and Peter Safran are taking with the DC Universe (DCU), signaling a willingness to embrace bold changes and explore alternate interpretations of beloved characters.
* corenswet’s Superman: The continuity established in The Flash directly supports David Corenswet’s portrayal of Superman in the DCU films, solidifying his place as the primary Superman of this new era.
* Potential for Multiversal Storytelling: The commitment to the multiverse opens up exciting possibilities for future DC projects, allowing for crossovers and explorations of alternate realities.
* “Superman: Legacy” Implications: The Earth-2 series could potentially provide context and backstory for elements explored in Gunn’s Superman: Legacy film.
Fan Theories and Speculation
The confirmation from Johns has fueled further speculation among fans. Popular theories include:
* The Council of supermen: Some believe the multiverse will eventually lead to the formation of a “Council of Supermen,” bringing together different versions of the character from various Earths.
* Earth-2 as a Testing Ground: Others speculate that Earth-2 will serve as a testing ground for new ideas and concepts that could eventually be integrated into the main DCU timeline.
* The Role of Legacy Characters: The fate of legacy characters like Lois lane and Lex Luthor on Earth-2 remains a key point of interest for fans.
* Superman
* The Flash (CW)
* Earth-2
* Geoff Johns
*
