Jury Awards $21 Million in Ski Lift Fall Paralysis Case, Challenging Resort Waivers
Table of Contents
- 1. Jury Awards $21 Million in Ski Lift Fall Paralysis Case, Challenging Resort Waivers
- 2. the Incident and the Lawsuit
- 3. The Verdict Breakdown
- 4. Implications for Ski Resort Liability
- 5. Understanding Ski Resort Liability Waivers
- 6. What specific evidence presented by the plaintiff’s legal team moast strongly supported the claim of negligent maintenance by Crested Butte Mountain Resort?
- 7. Jury Awards $21 Million to Woman Injured in Crested butte Ski Lift Accident
- 8. The Crested Butte Ski Lift Injury: A detailed Breakdown
- 9. What Happened: The Accident at Crested Butte
- 10. The Legal Battle: Negligence and liability
- 11. The $21 Million Verdict: Breakdown of Damages
- 12. Ski Lift Safety: Regulations and Best Practices
- 13. Similar Cases & Legal Precedents
- 14. Protecting yourself on the Slopes: Practical Tips
- 15. The Future of Ski Lift Safety and Resort Liability
Crested Butte, Colorado – A Colorado jury reached a significant decision on friday, awarding $21 million to a woman who sustained life-altering injuries after a fall from a ski lift at Crested butte Mountain Resort three years ago. The verdict represents a potentially pivotal moment in legal battles against ski resorts, notably concerning the enforceability of liability waivers.
the Incident and the Lawsuit
The incident occurred on March 16,2022,when the claimant,then 16 years old,fell approximately 30 feet from the Paradise Express chairlift. The claimant attempted to grasp the chair to avoid falling as the lift continued to operate. Her father frantically signaled for the lift to be stopped, but his pleas went unheeded, and she ultimately fell, suffering severe injuries that resulted in paralysis. The claimant’s father was later forced to ski down the mountain to reach his daughter.
The lawsuit, filed by Michael Miller, argued that Crested Butte Mountain Resort staff were negligent in failing to halt the lift’s operation before the fall occurred. This case gained renewed momentum following a ruling by the Colorado Supreme Court in May 2024. The Supreme Court steadfast that liability waivers may not shield ski resorts from legal responsibility when they breach state laws or regulations.
The Verdict Breakdown
After deliberations, the jury allocated 25% of the fault to the claimant and 75% to Vail Resorts, the owner of Crested Butte Mountain Resort. The $21 million award is divided as follows:
- Non-economic damages: $5.3 million
- Economic damages: $10.5 million
- Damages for physical impairment and disfigurement: $5.3 million
Vail Resorts,citing statutory caps on non-economic damages,anticipates paying a total of $12.4 million. The company maintains it disagrees with the verdict, labeling it inconsistent with existing Colorado law. Though, it expressed sympathy for the claimant and her family and reaffirmed its commitment to upholding the highest safety standards.
Implications for Ski Resort Liability
Legal experts suggest this verdict could considerably alter the legal landscape for ski resorts. Brian Aleinikoff, the claimant’s attorney, believes the ruling will empower skiers to pursue legal action against ski operators, especially in instances involving chairlift malfunctions or negligent operation.
“For a long time, ski areas have enjoyed a great degree of protection from lawsuits,” Aleinikoff stated. “While the inherent risks of skiing remain the responsibility of the skier, the operation of ski lifts must adhere to strict safety protocols.”
Did You Know? According to the National Ski Areas Association, there are roughly 470 ski areas in the United States, serving approximately 60 million visitors annually.[National Ski Areas Association]
| Aspect | Details |
|---|---|
| Claimant’s Age at Time of Incident | 16 years old |
| Total Verdict Amount | $21 million |
| Vail Resorts’ Expected Payment | $12.4 million |
| Fault Assigned to claimant | 25% |
| Fault Assigned to Vail Resorts | 75% |
The claimant, now a 20-year-old junior at the University of Tulsa studying music and psychology, is focusing on her recovery and education.Aleinikoff emphasized the importance of holding ski areas accountable for safety compliance to protect all skiers.
Pro Tip: Always be aware of yoru surroundings and follow the instructions of ski lift operators.If you feel unsafe or have difficulty securing your seat, immediately alert the lift operator.
Understanding Ski Resort Liability Waivers
Ski resorts routinely require skiers to sign liability waivers before using their facilities. These waivers typically seek to release the resort from responsibility for injuries resulting from the inherent risks of skiing. However, these waivers are not absolute. Courts have consistently held that waivers are unenforceable when a resort acts negligently or violates applicable laws or regulations.
The recent Colorado Supreme Court ruling reinforces this principle. Resorts cannot simply rely on waivers to shield themselves from the consequences of their own negligence. This case underscores that resorts have a duty to operate their facilities safely and to prioritize the well-being of their patrons.
What are your thoughts on ski resort liability? Do you believe waivers adequately protect both skiers and resorts? Share your perspective in the comments below!
What specific evidence presented by the plaintiff’s legal team moast strongly supported the claim of negligent maintenance by Crested Butte Mountain Resort?
Jury Awards $21 Million to Woman Injured in Crested butte Ski Lift Accident
The Crested Butte Ski Lift Injury: A detailed Breakdown
On September 3rd, 2025, a Colorado jury delivered a notable verdict, awarding $21 million to a woman severely injured in a 2023 ski lift accident at Crested Butte Mountain Resort. The case, which garnered considerable attention within the ski accident and personal injury law communities, highlights the potential liabilities of ski resort operators and the importance of ski lift safety. This article delves into the details of the accident, the legal proceedings, and the implications for skiers and snowboarders.
What Happened: The Accident at Crested Butte
The incident occurred on January 14, 2023, when the plaintiff, identified as Sarah Miller, was riding the Red Lady Express lift. According to court documents and reports from the Crested Butte News, a mechanical failure caused the lift to abruptly stop and then lurch forward. Miller, who was seated on the chair, was thrown from the lift, sustaining severe injuries upon impact with the snow below.
Injuries sustained included:
Multiple fractures, including a broken femur and pelvis.
Traumatic brain injury (TBI) resulting in ongoing cognitive difficulties.
Spinal injuries requiring extensive rehabilitation.
Severe emotional distress and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
Initial investigations pointed to a faulty drive mechanism as the primary cause of the malfunction. The lawsuit alleged negligence on the part of Crested Butte Mountain resort in its ski lift maintenance and inspection procedures.
The Legal Battle: Negligence and liability
The lawsuit filed by Miller’s legal team, led by attorneys at[LawFirmName-[LawFirmName-replace with actual firm], argued that the resort failed to adequately maintain the red Lady Express lift, despite prior reports of mechanical issues. Key arguments centered around:
Negligent Maintenance: Failure to adhere to industry standards for regular inspection and repair of ski lift components.
Lack of Warning: Insufficient warnings to skiers and snowboarders about potential hazards associated with the lift.
Operator Error: Potential errors in the operation of the lift that contributed to the accident.
The defense, representing Crested Butte Mountain Resort, argued that the accident was an unforeseen mechanical failure and that the resort had taken reasonable steps to ensure the safety of its patrons. They presented evidence of routine inspections and maintenance records. Though, the jury ultimately sided with the plaintiff, finding the resort liable for negligence.
The $21 Million Verdict: Breakdown of Damages
The $21 million awarded to Miller is comprised of several categories of damages:
Medical Expenses: $8.5 million to cover past and future medical costs,including surgeries,rehabilitation,and ongoing care for her TBI and spinal injuries.
Lost Wages: $6 million to compensate for lost income and diminished earning capacity due to her injuries. Miller was a[Plaintiff’sProfession-[Plaintiff’sProfession-replace with actual profession]prior to the accident.
Pain and Suffering: $5 million for the physical pain, emotional distress, and mental anguish caused by the accident and her ongoing disabilities.
Punitive Damages: $1.5 million, intended to punish the resort for its alleged negligence and deter similar conduct in the future.
Ski Lift Safety: Regulations and Best Practices
Ski lift accidents, while relatively rare, can result in catastrophic injuries. Several regulations and best practices are in place to minimize these risks:
American National Standards Institute (ANSI): ANSI/CEMA standards provide guidelines for the design, construction, maintenance, and operation of ski lifts.
State Inspections: Most states require annual inspections of ski lifts by qualified inspectors.
Regular Maintenance: Ski resorts are responsible for conducting regular maintenance and repairs on their lifts, following manufacturer recommendations and industry standards.
Operator Training: Lift operators must undergo thorough training to ensure they can safely operate the lifts and respond to emergencies.
Similar Cases & Legal Precedents
This case echoes several previous ski resort liability cases. In 2018, a jury awarded $7.5 million to a skier injured in a fall at Vail Resorts due to allegedly unmarked terrain. The legal principle of respondeat superior* often applies in these cases,holding ski resorts liable for the negligence of their employees. Understanding Colorado ski law is crucial for both skiers and resort operators.
Protecting yourself on the Slopes: Practical Tips
While ski resorts have a responsibility to ensure the safety of their patrons, skiers and snowboarders can also take steps to protect themselves:
- Pay Attention to Lift Instructions: Listen carefully to lift operators and follow all posted instructions.
- Secure Your Belongings: Ensure all loose items are securely fastened to prevent them from falling onto the lift track.
- Be Aware of Your Surroundings: Pay attention to other skiers and snowboarders, and be mindful of potential hazards.
- Report Any Concerns: If you notice any mechanical issues or safety concerns with a ski lift, report them to resort personnel immediately.
- Consider Ski Insurance: Ski injury insurance can definitely help cover medical expenses and other costs associated with an accident.
The Future of Ski Lift Safety and Resort Liability
The $21 million verdict in the Crested Butte case is likely to have a significant impact on the ski