The “Boring Dresser” Effect: How Authenticity is Rewriting the Rules of Personal Style
Nearly 60% of consumers say authenticity is a major factor when deciding which brands they support, according to a recent Stackline report. This demand for ‘real’ isn’t just impacting marketing; it’s fundamentally reshaping how we approach personal style, and even how characters are designed for on-screen impact. The recent buzz around the costuming for the show The Curse, specifically the character of Shane, perfectly illustrates this shift.
Beyond Fashion: The Power of “Real” Character Design
A viral tweet perfectly captured the sentiment: “I love that he needed a personal stylist for this look when he could have walked into any random European Zara and grabbed the same outfit off the mannequin.” The show’s costume designer, Stacey Puley, intentionally leaned into the mundane. She wasn’t aiming for high fashion, but for a grounded, relatable aesthetic. As Puley explained, her goal was to create characters who felt “real,” especially given the inherently fantastical premise of the show – peering into the private lives of hockey players. This echoes a point made last year by fashion critic Cathy Horyn regarding Taylor Swift’s evolving style: sometimes, the most powerful statement is a deliberate lack of statement.
Masking and the Psychology of Style
Puley’s approach wasn’t simply about finding affordable clothes. It was deeply connected to Shane’s character arc. The stylist, and even his attempts at presenting a polished exterior, were portrayed as part of his “masking” – concealing his true self, particularly as he navigated coming out. This highlights a fascinating psychological aspect of style: clothing can be a tool for both self-expression and self-protection. For many, particularly those grappling with identity, a deliberately understated or conventional style can be a way to blend in and avoid unwanted attention. This is a far cry from the aspirational, often unattainable, looks promoted by traditional fashion media.
The Rise of “Anti-Style” and the Normalization of the Everyday
The fascination with Shane’s “boring dresser” persona signals a broader trend: the rise of “anti-style.” This isn’t about eschewing fashion altogether, but about rejecting the pressure to constantly curate a perfect, Instagrammable image. It’s about embracing comfort, practicality, and personal authenticity, even if that means wearing clothes from Banana Republic (as playfully pointed out in a TikTok parody). This trend is fueled by several factors, including a growing awareness of the environmental impact of fast fashion and a rejection of the superficiality often associated with influencer culture.
From Steve Jobs to Shane: The Power of a Uniform
The comparison to Steve Jobs’ iconic black turtleneck and jeans is apt. Jobs didn’t care about fashion; he cared about efficiency and minimizing distractions. His uniform became a symbol of his focus and unconventional thinking. Similarly, Shane’s deliberately unremarkable style serves to underscore his internal struggles and his attempts to navigate a complex world. This demonstrates how a lack of stylistic flourish can be just as powerful – and intentional – as a bold fashion statement. It’s a subtle form of storytelling that resonates with audiences seeking authenticity.
Looking Ahead: The Future of Personal Style
What does this mean for the future of personal style? We’re likely to see a continued blurring of the lines between high fashion and everyday wear. The demand for sustainable and ethically produced clothing will continue to grow, driving a shift towards more mindful consumption. But perhaps the most significant change will be a greater emphasis on individuality and self-expression, even if that expression takes the form of deliberately understated style. Puley’s vision for Shane – “leaning into color and showing body more publicly” – suggests a future where authenticity ultimately leads to greater confidence and a willingness to embrace one’s true self, sartorially and otherwise.
What are your predictions for the future of personal style? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
:format(webp)/nginx/o/2025/12/23/17356686t1hb07e.jpg)
