The search for the next All Blacks head coach remains a focal point of debate in Modern Zealand, following the unexpected departure of Scott Robertson in mid-January. While several names have been floated, the contest has largely narrowed to a two-way battle between Jamie Joseph and Dave Rennie, each offering a distinct coaching philosophy. The appointment, expected in mid-March, will shape the future direction of the national team.
The contrasting styles of the two frontrunners are at the heart of the discussion. Former international hooker James Parsons believes Rennie’s collaborative approach is what the All Blacks need, particularly after a period of reported cultural issues within the team. However, a recent fan poll indicated support for Joseph, with 55 percent of voters favoring his more direct style, highlighting the divided opinions within the New Zealand rugby community.
Parsons, speaking on The Breakdown, emphasized the importance of a coach who can build a cohesive environment. “The hard-nosed style of Jamie Joseph is quite different to the collaborative style of Dave Rennie. Because they’re poles apart it’s really what you’re looking for,” he said. He pointed to Rennie’s success with the Chiefs as evidence of his ability to foster a winning culture, adding, “Yes, the Wallabies results weren’t great but I do think he was just starting to break through with that side and he was let move. For me, he’s well placed.”
However, not all former players agree. Mils Muliaina, an All Blacks great, expressed a preference for Joseph, citing his directness as a key strength. “It’s a two-horse race. I would love to see them work together because they’re quality coaches. For me it’s Jamie because he’s hard-nosed,” Muliaina said, adding, “I would like to see Jamie given the job.” Despite Muliaina’s desire for a collaborative approach, It’s understood that both Joseph and Rennie are determined to secure the top position.
NZ Rugby Weighs Coaching Styles and Support Staff
New Zealand Rugby’s selection panel, comprised of Dane Coles, Keven Mealamu, David Kirk, Don Tricker, and interim chief executive Steve Lancaster, is currently undertaking due diligence on both candidates. Lancaster and Coles recently visited the Highlanders in Dunedin and are scheduled to travel to Japan to observe Rennie’s current team, the Kobe Steelers, as part of the evaluation process, according to ESPN. Formal interviews with the full panel will follow.
Beyond the head coach position, the panel is as well considering the potential assistant coaches each candidate would bring on board. Jeff Wilson noted that a strong support staff is crucial, stating, “There are some excellent coaches who are around Super Rugby… They shouldn’t be discounted and there are coaches around the world that might develop themselves available if the head coach that they know and like all of a sudden is the man.”
Joseph’s Recent Success and Rennie’s International Experience
Jamie Joseph’s recent success with the Highlanders, including an upset victory over the Crusaders in the opening round of Super Rugby Pacific, has bolstered his candidacy. However, ESPN notes that one win is unlikely to be the deciding factor. Joseph’s extensive coaching experience includes roles with Wellington, the Highlanders (where he led them to a Super Rugby title in 2015), and New Zealand Māori, as well as a stint with Japan.
Dave Rennie, despite a challenging tenure with the Wallabies, is seen as a strong contender due to his previous success with the Chiefs. His ability to build a cohesive and successful team environment is a key attribute that appeals to some within New Zealand Rugby. The appointment process is expected to continue in the coming weeks, with a final decision anticipated by mid-March.
As the selection process nears its conclusion, the debate surrounding the ideal leadership for the All Blacks continues. The contrasting approaches of Joseph and Rennie present New Zealand Rugby with a significant decision, one that will undoubtedly shape the team’s performance and culture in the years to come. The focus now shifts to the final interviews and the careful consideration of each candidate’s vision for the future of All Blacks rugby.
What are your thoughts on the potential appointment of Jamie Joseph or Dave Rennie as the next All Blacks head coach? Share your opinions in the comments below.
