The New Roughnecks: How “Landman” Signals a Shift in Our Relationship with Energy, Masculinity, and Decline

The Permian Basin, a 75,000-square-mile expanse of West Texas and New Mexico, produces more oil than most countries. But it’s not the oil itself that’s capturing attention right now; it’s the cultural fascination with the world surrounding it, fueled by Taylor Sheridan’s latest series, “Landman.” More than just a neo-Western, the show’s unexpected success – despite, or perhaps because of, its unflinching portrayal of a morally ambiguous industry – suggests a growing appetite for narratives that grapple with the complexities of American decline, the enduring power of traditional masculinity, and the uncomfortable realities of our energy dependence. And it’s a signal that these narratives are likely to dominate entertainment and, increasingly, shape public discourse in the years to come.

Beyond the Boomtown: Why We’re Drawn to the Grit

“Landman,” based on the “Boomtown” podcast, doesn’t glamorize the oil industry. It shows the messy, often brutal, work of securing leases, managing crews, and navigating the legal and ethical gray areas of extraction. This isn’t the world of “Dallas” or “Dynasty”; it’s a world of dust, debt, and desperation. Yet, audiences are tuning in, and the show’s popularity isn’t limited to those with ties to the energy sector. Part of the appeal lies in its voyeuristic glimpse into a high-stakes, high-reward industry, similar to the fascination with the financial world depicted in “Succession.” But it’s more than just spectacle. The show taps into a deeper cultural anxiety about economic insecurity and the fading promise of the American Dream.

The Toxic Blend: Oil, Masculinity, and the American Psyche

The series’ central premise – the intertwined nature of oil and a particular brand of rugged masculinity – resonates deeply. As the show illustrates, the oil field has historically been a space where traditional masculine ideals are not only valued but *required*. The long hours, physical demands, and inherent risks create a culture of stoicism, self-reliance, and often, aggression. However, “Landman” doesn’t simply celebrate this masculinity; it deconstructs it, revealing its inherent contradictions and destructive tendencies. The characters grapple with the consequences of their choices, the toll the industry takes on their families, and the emptiness that often lies beneath the surface of wealth and power. This exploration of **masculinity** in the context of a declining industry is particularly poignant, reflecting a broader societal reckoning with traditional gender roles.

The Shifting Sands of Energy and Identity

The show’s controversial stance on environmental issues – particularly Tommy Norris’s dismissal of wind energy – is a deliberate provocation. It forces viewers to confront the uncomfortable truth that our energy needs are often at odds with our environmental concerns. But it also highlights the economic realities of communities dependent on fossil fuels. As the world transitions towards renewable energy sources, these communities face an uncertain future, and the loss of identity tied to the oil industry is a significant concern. This transition isn’t just about energy; it’s about livelihoods, communities, and a way of life. The International Energy Agency’s Net Zero by 2050 report underscores the scale of this challenge and the need for a just transition that addresses the social and economic impacts on affected communities.

The Future of “Roughneck” Narratives

“Landman” isn’t an anomaly. It’s part of a growing trend of narratives that explore the complexities of American decline, the anxieties of the working class, and the search for meaning in a rapidly changing world. We’re likely to see more stories that delve into the lives of those left behind by globalization, automation, and the energy transition. These narratives will likely be characterized by a gritty realism, a willingness to confront uncomfortable truths, and a focus on the human cost of progress. Expect to see more exploration of the psychological impact of economic insecurity, the rise of populism, and the search for new forms of identity and community.

Beyond Oil: The Broader Implications

The themes explored in “Landman” extend far beyond the oil industry. The show’s depiction of power dynamics, corruption, and the struggle for survival resonates with broader concerns about economic inequality, political polarization, and the erosion of trust in institutions. The show’s success suggests that audiences are hungry for stories that grapple with these issues in a nuanced and unflinching way. This demand will likely drive a surge in demand for similar content across various media platforms, from television and film to podcasts and literature. The rise of “rural noir” as a genre, for example, reflects this growing interest in stories that explore the dark underbelly of small-town America and the challenges faced by those living outside of urban centers.

Ultimately, “Landman” is a reflection of our times – a time of uncertainty, anxiety, and a growing sense of disillusionment. It’s a show that doesn’t offer easy answers, but it does offer a compelling and thought-provoking glimpse into a world that is both fascinating and frightening. What does this mean for the future of storytelling? It means that authenticity, complexity, and a willingness to confront uncomfortable truths will be more valuable than ever. What are your predictions for the future of narratives exploring these themes? Share your thoughts in the comments below!