The European country where trains are even less punctual than Britain’s railways

German Train Punctuality: Reality vs. Perception

German intercity train travel has a reputation for reliability, often contrasted wiht the perceived struggles of UK rail services. However, recent analyses have shed light on the reality of punctuality across the continent, revealing that Germany’s state-owned operator, deutsche Bahn, faces significant challenges.

Last week, during a snap election debate, German chancellor Olaf Scholz dismissed the suggestion of privatizing the country’s rail system, stating that it would “end as badly as in England, where nothing works any more.” This statement, while highlighting a contentious issue, has been met with skepticism in light of new data.

A punch below expectations

A detailed analysis by the financial Times, using over 1.9bn train arrival records from February 2024 to January 2025,revealed that only 72% of Deutsche Bahn‘s intercity trains arrived within 10 minutes of their scheduled time. This figure pales in comparison to the 78% punctuality rate recorded for British long-distance trains.

“Around 39% of german long-distance trains arrived with a delay of less than 60 seconds, while Britain’s worst-performing operator, Avanti West Coast, met this service level 41% of the time.

adding to the concern, a significant 20% of German intercity trains experienced delays exceeding 15 minutes, almost double the rate of Avanti West Coast and ten times the average for all UK services.

Infrastructure as a Roadblock

Deutsche Bahn attributed these delays primarily to infrastructure issues, stating that 80% of disruptions stem from an overburdened, aging, and vulnerable network. They described the infrastructure as “too crowded, too old and too prone to disruptions”.

However, the company also pointed to some successes, particularly with the new high-speed track between Berlin and Munich, which achieved an impressive 82.5% punctuality rate in 2024.

The European Landscape

While German rail services lag behind some of its European counterparts, particularly in Austria, Switzerland, and the Netherlands, where punctuality consistently exceeds 90%, the situation is not unique. The pressure to maintain reliable and timely services across different national rail networks presents a complex challenge for all involved.

Recent Events and Future Outlook

The ongoing Euro 2024 football tournament brought German train services back into the spotlight, with fans reporting significant disruptions and delays, further highlighting the need for improvement.

As Germany works to modernize its infrastructure and address the underlying causes of punctuality issues,the nation’s reputation for reliable rail travel remains under scrutiny.

For more travel news and advice, listen to Simon calder’s podcast. Here

How notable a role do you think infrastructure plays in overall punctuality?

German Train Punctuality: A Conversation with Rail Expert Heidi Musik

German intercity train travel has long been synonymous with reliability, but recent analyses suggest that the reality isn’t quite as punctual as the reputation. Archyde sat down with Heidi Musik, a seasoned railway analyst and author of the upcoming book “Rails of Progress,” to discuss the current state of German train punctuality and its future prospects.

Debunking the Myth of German Punctuality

Archyde: Heidi, a Financial Times analysis recently revealed that only 72% of Deutsche Bahn’s intercity trains arrived on time. How do you interpret this figure?

Heidi Musik: while 72% might seem respectable, it’s important to consider that the definition of ‘on time’ used by Deutsche Bahn is arriving within 10 minutes of the scheduled time. When you compare this to the 78% punctuality rate recorded for British long-distance trains, using the same definition, the situation seems less notable.

Infrastructure Woes and Success Stories

Archyde: Deutsche Bahn attributes most delays to infrastructure issues.How significant a role do you think infrastructure plays in overall punctuality?

Heidi Musik: Infrastructure is undoubtedly theprimary culprit. With 80% of disruptions stemming from the network, it’s clear that Germany’s rail infrastructure is simply not coping with the demands placed upon it. However, it’s also crucial to note that Deutsche Bahn’s new high-speed tracks, like the route between Berlin and Munich, are achieving impressive punctuality rates, which suggests that with the right investment, significant improvements are possible.

Germany vs. Europe: Where Does the Nation Stand?

Archyde: How does Germany’s rail punctuality compare to other European countries?

Heidi Musik: While Germany may not be the gold standard it once was, it’s not alone in its challenges. Tho Austria, Switzerland, and the Netherlands consistently achieve punctuality rates above 90%, many other countries face similar pressures in maintaining reliable services. It’s a continent-wide challenge that requires collective effort and innovation.

Euro 2024: A Spotlight on rail Infrastructure

Archyde: The Euro 2024 football tournament brought German train services back into the spotlight. How have these events highlighted the need for enhancement?

Heidi Musik: The tournament brought thousands of football fans onto Germany’s rails, putting the network under immense pressure. The resulting disruptions and delays were a stark reminder that while progress is being made, there’s still much work to do. These high-profile events can be challenging,but they also offer opportunities to identify weaknesses and drive improvements.

The Way Forward: Modernization and Hope

Archyde: What steps do you beleive Germany should take to improve its rail punctuality and reputation?

Heidi Musik: Germany needs a sustained, long-term investment strategy to modernize its infrastructure.This includes upgrading track, signaling systems, and stations, as well as deploying new, reliable fleets of trains.It’s a significant undertaking,but one that’s crucial for the future of Germany’s rail network and the country’s standing in Europe.

Archyde: Heidi, thank you for sharing your insights. Before we wrap up,could you leave our readers with one thought-provoking question to consider?

Heidi Musik: Given the importance of rail travel in mitigating climate change,should we be prioritizing punctuality over other metrics of success,such as capacity and sustainability?

Let us know your thoughts in the comments below,and don’t forget to tune in to Simon Calder’s podcast for more travel news and advice. Listen here.

Heidi Musik is a railway analyst and author of the upcoming book “Rails of Progress.”