Oliver Hermanus’s “The History of Sound,” originally titled “Le Son des souvenirs,” is proving to be a surprisingly divisive film, sparking debate among critics and audiences alike. The drama, starring Paul Mescal and Josh O’Connor, premiered at the Cannes Film Festival and is set to release in France on February 25, 2026, according to AlloCiné. While lauded for its evocative imagery and poignant exploration of love and memory, the film’s artistic choices have also drawn criticism.
The story centers on Lionel, a young singer from Kentucky, and David, a composition student, who forge a connection at the Boston Conservatory in 1917. Their burgeoning relationship is interrupted by the outbreak of World War I, but they reunite in 1920 to embark on a journey through Maine, documenting the region’s fading folk music traditions. “The History of Sound” isn’t simply a love story; it’s a tribute to the often-overlooked work of early music collectors like John Lomax and his son Alan Lomax, who dedicated their lives to preserving America’s musical heritage.
The film’s aesthetic, described as “highly polished” by Critique Express, is a key point of contention. Some viewers find the meticulous cinematography to be academic and overly refined, while others appreciate its beauty and artistry. Similarly, the film’s melancholic tone and focus on a same-sex romance have elicited varied reactions, with some finding it sincere and emotionally resonant, and others dismissing it as overly sentimental.
A Focus on the Art of Musical Preservation
Beyond the central love story, “The History of Sound” shines a light on the crucial, yet often unacknowledged, practice of musical collecting. The film depicts Lionel and David recording songs on wax cylinders, a method used by pioneering ethnomusicologists to capture the voices and melodies of a disappearing culture. This aspect of the film has particularly resonated with those passionate about music and its preservation. The film features the work of Sam Amidon, a specialist in American traditional music, who coached Mescal and O’Connor in their vocal performances, ensuring authenticity in their interpretations of the collected songs.
The soundtrack itself is a rich tapestry of musical influences, extending beyond American folk traditions to include compositions by Pergolese and Gabriel Fauré, as scenes unfold in Rome and London. This blending of musical styles underscores the film’s broader themes of memory, loss, and the enduring power of music to connect us across time and place.
Mescal and O’Connor Deliver Compelling Performances
Critical praise has also been directed towards the performances of Paul Mescal and Josh O’Connor. Mescal, recently seen in “Hamnet,” is slated to portray Paul McCartney in an upcoming biopic series directed by Sam Mendes, according to multiple sources. O’Connor, known for his role in “The Mastermind,” delivers a nuanced and captivating performance alongside him. The chemistry between the two actors is central to the film’s emotional impact, bringing depth and authenticity to their characters’ complex relationship.
The film’s narrative extends beyond the initial romance, following Lionel’s journey through life, success, and subsequent relationships, all while haunted by the memory of David. The rediscovery of their collaborative work years later serves as a catalyst for Lionel to confront the enduring significance of their connection.
A Divisive Reception and Upcoming Release
Despite its artistic merits and strong performances, “The History of Sound” did not receive any awards at the Cannes Film Festival, a fact noted by Critique Express. However, the film’s divisive reception among critics and audiences suggests We see a work that will continue to generate discussion and debate. Mubi has acquired the North American distribution rights, while Focus Features and Universal Pictures International will handle international distribution, as reported by IMDb.
“The History of Sound” promises to be a thought-provoking and emotionally resonant cinematic experience, offering a unique blend of historical drama, romance, and musical exploration. As the film prepares for its wider release, audiences can anticipate a visually stunning and emotionally complex story that lingers long after the credits roll.
What are your thoughts on films that explore the intersection of music and memory? Share your comments below and let us know what you think!
