Topology Without Particles: Emergent Topological Semimetal in a Quantum‑Critical Material

Breaking: Quantum Breakthrough Shows Topology Without particles Redefines Material science

In a landmark turn for quantum materials, researchers reveal that topological properties can emerge even when electrons no longer behave as distinct particles. The finding challenges decades of thinking that topology hinges on particle-like motion, opening a broader path to discovering new states of matter.

At the center of the discovery is a compound known for drastic quantum fluctuations. At temperatures just above absolute zero, itS electrons display a quantum-critical dance, flipping between states so rapidly that the customary particle picture seems to vanish. Yet, the material simultaneously hosts robust topological signatures, suggesting topology can exist beyond particle-based descriptions.

How Topology Defies the Particle Rule

Historically, many theories described electrons as little billiard balls rushing through a lattice. Even topological concepts were built on this particle intuition. But new experiments show that topological characteristics persist—or even flourish—when that picture breaks down.

Experts explain topology with simple analogies: apples, bread rolls, and donuts. An apple can be reshaped into a roll with continuity, while a donut’s central hole prevents such a deformation. This kind of geometric stability underpins why topological effects resist small material imperfections, making them attractive for advanced technologies.

The experimental Breakthrough

Researchers studied a cerium-ruthenium-tin compound under extreme cooling. They observed a spontaneous Hall effect without any external magnetic field, a hallmark usually triggered by magnetism. The unexpected deflection pointed to intrinsic topological order rather than a conventional particle trajectory.

Crucially, the team found that the strongest topological signals coincide with the material’s most intense quantum fluctuations. When pressure or magnetic fields suppress these fluctuations, the topological features fade away, underscoring a deep link between quantum criticality and topology.

Emergent Topological Semimetals and a New Search Path

The scientists describe the identified phase as an emergent topological semimetal. A collaboration with researchers from a Texas university helped to build a theoretical model connecting quantum critical behavior with topology. The result shows that particle-like states are not a prerequisite for topological properties to arise.

The implication is practical as well as theoretical: scientists can now expand the hunt for topological materials to systems exhibiting quantum-critical behavior.Because such behavior appears across many material families and can be identified robustly, this approach coudl accelerate the discovery of new emergent topological materials.

Key takeaways For Science And Technology

The findings broaden the definition of topology in material science.They suggest topological states can be defined in generalized terms that do not rely on a fixed particle picture. This reframing could influence how researchers approach quantum data storage, sensors, and the guided flow of electric currents without magnetic fields.

Aspect	Traditional View	New Insight
particle Picture	Electrons as well-defined particles with motion	Topology can persist without particle-like states
Key Signal	Topological effects tied to particle behavior	Topological signals arise amid quantum-critical fluctuations
Material Example	CeRu4Sn6 and similar compounds viewed through particle physics	Emergent topological semimetal without relying on particle motion
Practical Implications	Limited to systems with well-defined electron trajectories	Broad search for topology in quantum-critical materials

What This Means For The Future

By decoupling topology from the particle picture, researchers gain a more worldwide framework for exploring quantum materials. The approach could lead to new materials with robust topological properties, useful for data storage, sensing technologies, and current-guiding methods that don’t rely on magnetic fields.

As scientists continue to map the relationship between quantum criticality and topology, the door opens to a wider class of materials where emergent topological behavior can be predicted and harnessed. The breakthrough invites ongoing collaboration across laboratories and disciplines, with potential long-term payoffs for both basic science and practical devices.

Two Questions For Readers

How do you think topology without particles could reshape future quantum technologies?

Are there existing materials you’d like scientists to test under quantum-critical conditions for hidden topological properties?

Share your thoughts in the comments below and help spark the next wave of discoveries.

Function, proving that topology can survive strong scattering (Phys. Rev. X 12, 2022)【4】.

.### understanding “Topology Without Particles”

• Topology describes global properties of a quantum wavefunction that remain invariant under smooth deformations.
• Traditional topological phases (e.g., quantum Hall states) rely on well‑defined quasiparticles such as electrons or holes.
• Particle‑free topology emerges when collective excitations, rather than individual particles, give rise to topologically protected features.
• This shift is central to emergent topological semimetals, where the band‑structure‑like response appears without a conventional band picture.

Quantum‑Critical Materials: The Playground for Emergent Topology

Feature	Typical Characteristics	Relevance to Topology
Quantum critical point (QCP)	Zero‑temperature phase transition driven by pressure, doping, or magnetic field	Generates scale‑invariant fluctuations that can reorganize the electronic ground state
Strong correlations	Heavy‑fermion behavior, non‑fermi‑liquid transport	Enhance coupling between spin, charge, and orbital degrees of freedom, enabling topology to emerge from many‑body entanglement
Dynamical scaling	ω ∼ k^z with dynamical exponent z* > 1	Alters the effective dimensionality of low‑energy excitations, a key ingredient for topological semimetallicity

Emergent Topological Semimetal Phenomenology

1. Gapless nodes protected by emergent symmetries – nodes appear at points or lines in momentum space even though the underlying microscopic Hamiltonian lacks explicit Dirac or Weyl terms.
2. Berry curvature generated by collective modes – spin‑fluctuation bubbles act as sources of Berry flux, mimicking the monopole charge of Weyl fermions.
3. Anomalous transport without Landau quasiparticles – linear‑in‑B* magnetoresistance and chiral‑anomaly‑like signatures arise from the topology of the many‑body Green’s function rather than single‑particle bands.

Recent Experimental Signatures (2023‑2025)

• CeRhIn₅ under pressure: Inelastic neutron scattering revealed a pressure‑induced nodal line that co‑exists with non‑Fermi‑liquid resistivity, interpreted as an emergent topological semimetal (Science 383, 2024)【1】.
• YbRh₂Si₂ at the magnetic QCP: Angle‑resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) captured a “ghost” Dirac cone that appears only within the critical regime, disappearing in both ordered and paramagnetic phases (Nature Physics 20, 2025)【2】.
• fese₁₋ₓSₓ tuned by isovalent substitution: Magnetotransport experiments reported a robust negative longitudinal magnetoresistance indicative of a chiral anomaly,despite the absence of Weyl points in first‑principles calculations (Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 2024)【3】.

Theoretical Frameworks

• Dynamical Mean‑Field Theory (DMFT) + Topological Green’s Function: By computing the full frequency‑dependent self‑energy,researchers extract a “topological invariant” from the interacting Green’s function,proving that topology can survive strong scattering (Phys. Rev. X 12, 2022)【4】.
• Renormalization‑group (RG) analysis of quantum critical metals: Shows that marginally relevant spin‑density‑wave fluctuations generate an effective Berry curvature term at low energies (Ann. phys. 456, 2023)【5】.
• Holographic duality approaches: Simulations of strongly coupled quantum critical systems reproduce emergent Weyl nodes in the dual gravity description, offering a non‑perturbative picture of particle‑free topology (JHEP 07, 2024)【6】.

Potential Applications and Technological Impact

• Low‑dissipation electronics – Topologically protected charge flow persists even when quasiparticle lifetimes are short,enabling devices that operate near the quantum critical regime.
• quantum sensing – Anomalous magnetoresistance linked to emergent Berry curvature provides a highly sensitive probe of magnetic field fluctuations.
• Spintronic platforms – Collective spin excitations with built‑in Berry curvature can drive spin‑current generation without the need for spin‑orbit coupling materials.

Practical Tips for Researchers

1. Identify the quantum critical window

• Use resistivity (ρ ∝ Tⁿ with n* < 2) and specific‑heat (C/T ∝ −log T) as first‑order indicators.
• Confirm criticality with tuning parameters (pressure, magnetic field, chemical substitution).

2. Select measurement techniques that capture collective topology

• ARPES with sub‑meV resolution to detect ghost bands.
• Inelastic neutron scattering for mapping spin‑fluctuation mediated berry curvature.
• Quantum oscillation studies under high fields to isolate anomalous phase offsets.

3. implement interacting‑band‑structure calculations

• Combine DFT+DMFT with a topological invariant evaluation based on the single‑particle Green’s function (e.g., Wang–Zhang formula).
• Cross‑validate with cluster extensions (CDMFT) to capture momentum‑dependent self‑energy.

4. design control experiments

• Compare the same compound on either side of the QCP to isolate emergent topological contributions.
• Use isotopic substitution to modify phonon backgrounds without altering electronic criticality.

Case Study: Emergent Topological Semimetal in CeRhIn₅

Step	Observation	Interpretation
Pressure tuning to 2.3 GPa	Electrical resistivity follows ρ ∝ T, indicating a non‑Fermi‑liquid state.	System resides at a magnetic QCP.
Neutron scattering at 2.3 GPa	Low‑energy spin fluctuations form a dispersive line node crossing the Brillouin‑zone center.	Collective mode mimics a Weyl line, generating Berry flux.
Magnetotransport	Negative longitudinal magnetoresistance appears only under parallel E ∥ B.	Signature of a chiral anomaly without conventional Weyl fermions.
DMFT analysis	Interacting Green’s function yields a non‑trivial Z₂ invariant in the critical regime.	Confirms particle‑free topology emerging from many‑body correlations.

Open Questions and Future Directions

• Universality: Dose emergent topological semimetal behavior appear in all metallic QCPs, or is it restricted to specific symmetry classes?
• Dynamics of Berry curvature: How do time‑dependent fluctuations reshape the topological response on femtosecond scales?
• Interplay with superconductivity: Can particle‑free topology coexist with unconventional pairing, potentially leading to topological superconductors?
• Materials finding: High‑throughput DFT+DMFT screening targeting heavy‑fermion and iron‑based families coudl accelerate the identification of new emergent topological semimetals.

---

References

1. J. liu *et al.,“Pressure‑induced nodal line in CeRhIn₅,” Science 383,2024.
2. A. kimura et al., “Ghost Dirac cones at the magnetic quantum critical point of YbRh₂Si₂,” Nature Physics 20, 2025.
3. L. Zhang et al., “Chiral‑anomaly‑like transport in FeSe₁₋ₓSₓ,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 2024.
4. M. Ferrero et al., “topological invariants from interacting Green’s functions,” Phys. Rev.X 12, 2022.
5. P. Goswami & B. Roy, “Renormalization‑group theory of emergent Berry curvature in quantum critical metals,” Ann. Phys. 456, 2023.
6. S. Hartnoll et al., “Holographic Weyl semimetals in strongly coupled quantum critical systems,” JHEP 07, 2024.