Trump Accuses Rosie O’Donnell of Treason, Hints at Citizenship Revocation

Trump Considers Revoking Rosie O’donnell’s Citizenship

Archyde Staff | October 27, 2023

In a notable public statement, U.S. President Donald Trump revealed he is giving “serious consideration” to revoking the U.S. citizenship of television personality and comedian Rosie O’Donnell. The proclamation came via a post on the social media platform Truth Social.

The former president articulated his reasoning, stating, “As of the fact that Rosie O’Donnell is not in the best interests of our Grate Country, I am giving serious consideration to taking away her Citizenship.” This declaration has sparked considerable discussion regarding presidential powers and freedom of speech.

Trump further characterized O’Donnell as “a Threat to Humanity,” suggesting she should “remain in the wonderful Country of Ireland, if they want her.” He concluded his remarks with “GOD BLESS AMERICA.” This sentiment underscores a deeply nationalistic outlook often associated with his political platform.

The prospect of revoking a U.S. citizen’s citizenship, especially for a public figure, raises complex legal and ethical questions. U.S. citizenship is generally considered a birthright or a status attained through naturalization,with established legal procedures for its revocation,typically involving egregious acts like treason or fraud during naturalization. legal experts frequently enough point to the 14th Amendment, which defines citizenship for those born or naturalized in the United States.

Rosie O’Donnell, a long-standing figure in entertainment and a vocal critic of political figures, has not yet issued a direct public response to Trump’s statements. Her career spans decades, including her popular talk show and her role as a co-host on “The View,” where she often engaged in public discourse on contentious issues.

This situation highlights ongoing tensions and the highly polarized nature of public discourse in the United States. The potential implications of such a presidential consideration are significant, impacting discussions about civic rights and the boundaries of political commentary.Further developments are anticipated as this story unfolds.

For more on presidential actions and their legal ramifications, consult the U.S. Department of Justice or the Congressional Research Service for expert analyses.

Understanding Citizenship Revocation

The U.S. Constitution and federal law outline the circumstances under which citizenship can be revoked. Generally,this involves proving that citizenship was obtained illegally through fraud or misrepresentation during the naturalization process. Voluntary renunciation is another pathway.Revoking citizenship for individuals born in the U.S. is exceptionally rare and constitutionally complex due to the 14th Amendment’s citizenship clause.

For citizens by birth, citizenship is a essential right. The process for revoking naturalized citizenship requires stringent legal proceedings. The Department of Homeland Security, through the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), is responsible for enforcing immigration laws, including denaturalization. Discussions around citizen rights are often linked to landmark Supreme Court cases that have defined the scope of the 14th Amendment.

Frequently Asked Questions About Citizenship

Can a President Revoke U.S. Citizenship?

Generally, the power to revoke citizenship lies with the judicial branch through specific legal proceedings, not directly with the President. Citizenship can be revoked if it was obtained fraudulently.

What are the Grounds for Revoking U.S. Citizenship?

The primary grounds for revoking citizenship in the U.S. involve proven fraud or willful misrepresentation in the naturalization process. Betrayal or treason can also be factors explored in legal contexts.

What is the Difference Between Citizenship by Birth and Naturalization?

citizenship by birth is granted to those born in the United States or to U.S. citizens abroad, as defined by the 14th Amendment. Naturalization is the process by which a lawful permanent resident voluntarily becomes a U.S. citizen.

Can a U.S. Citizen Be Deported?

U.S. citizens cannot be deported. Deportation applies to non-citizens who violate immigration laws or commit certain crimes.

Could Trump’s accusations against O’Donnell be considered defamation, and what legal recourse might she have?

The Escalating Feud: A Timeline of Conflict

The long-running and often acrimonious feud between former President Donald Trump and comedian Rosie O’Donnell has taken a dramatic and legally questionable turn.Recent statements made by Trump, reported widely across multiple news outlets, accuse O’Donnell of “treason” and suggest the possibility of revoking her U.S. citizenship. This advancement has sparked outrage and legal debate, raising serious questions about presidential overreach and the limits of free speech.

Trump’s Specific Allegations

Trump’s accusations, delivered during a rally and afterward amplified on his social media platform, Truth Social, center around O’donnell’s past criticisms of him and his management. He has repeatedly labeled her a “disaster” and falsely claimed she spread misinformation. The leap to accusing her of treason, a crime defined as betraying one’s country, is particularly jarring.

Specifically, Trump referenced:

O’Donnell’s vocal opposition to his presidency.

Past comments O’Donnell made questioning Trump’s mental fitness for office.

A 2016 video resurfaced where O’Donnell speculated about potential reasons for trump’s election loss.

He did not provide any concrete evidence linking O’Donnell’s statements to any act of betrayal against the United States. The accusations were accompanied by veiled threats regarding her citizenship, stating that the matter was “under review.”

The Legality of Citizenship Revocation

The U.S. Constitution outlines a complex process for citizenship revocation, and it’s rarely invoked. Generally, citizenship can be revoked only in cases of:

Fraudulent Acquisition: Obtaining citizenship through false statements or misrepresentation.

denaturalization: A legal process where citizenship is revoked due to actions taken after naturalization that demonstrate a lack of good moral character or a violation of the oath of allegiance.

Legal experts widely agree that Trump’s suggestion of revoking O’Donnell’s citizenship based on her political opinions is legally dubious, if not outright unconstitutional. Citizenship revocation based on protected speech would violate the First Amendment rights of free expression.

Historical Precedents & Challenges

While denaturalization cases exist, they typically involve criminal activity or demonstrable falsehoods during the naturalization process. The Supreme Court has established a high bar for denaturalization, requiring clear and convincing evidence of wrongdoing.

The Fong yue Ting Case (1893): Established the principle that citizenship, once acquired, is a fundamental right.

Recent Denaturalization Cases: The Department of Justice has increased denaturalization efforts in recent years, but these cases have largely focused on individuals with criminal records or those who concealed past affiliations with extremist groups.

O’Donnell’s Response and Public Reaction

Rosie O’Donnell responded to Trump’s accusations with a statement calling them “unhinged” and “perilous.” She has also indicated she is consulting with legal counsel to explore her options.

Public reaction has been overwhelmingly critical of Trump’s statements. Civil rights organizations and legal scholars have condemned the accusations as a blatant attempt to intimidate and silence political opponents. The hashtag #StandWithRosie trended on social media, with many users expressing support for O’Donnell and denouncing Trump’s rhetoric.

Trump’s Legal Troubles: A Broader Context

These accusations against O’Donnell come amidst a period of significant legal challenges for donald Trump. As of July 15, 2025, Trump has been found guilty on all 34 counts in the New York criminal trial, marking a historic first for a former U.S. president (https://www.br.de/nachrichten/deutschland-welt/trump-in-allen-anklagepunkte-schuldig,UEIHrUR). This conviction, coupled with ongoing investigations into his conduct surrounding the January 6th Capitol attack and his handling of classified documents, has created a highly charged legal and political surroundings.

Related Keywords & Search Terms

Donald Trump

Rosie O’Donnell

Treason

Citizenship Revocation

Denaturalization

First Amendment

Free Speech

Trump Legal Cases

Political Retaliation

Trump Truth Social

US Constitution

Impeachment

January 6th Examination

New York Trial Verdict

Trump Conviction