York County is taking legal action against the Dover Area School District after the school board rejected a request to use school buildings as polling places for the upcoming primary and general elections. The lawsuit, filed Monday, marks the latest escalation in a dispute that began in 2024, raising concerns about voter access and election security ahead of what is expected to be a high-turnout gubernatorial race.
The York County Board of Elections sought to utilize Dover Area school facilities to accommodate voters, but the school board voted 5-4 against the proposal on February 17th. School officials cited a range of concerns, including student safety, potential disruptions to state-mandated testing schedules, and dissatisfaction with the financial compensation offered by the county, according to reporting from the York Daily Record. The county argues that access to school buildings is crucial for ensuring adequate voter access and maintaining secure election operations.
School Board Cites Safety and Testing Conflicts
Dover Area School District spokesperson Bradly Perkins stated that “the safety of the students and staff remains the district’s highest priority,” and indicated the district would not comment further on the pending litigation. The school board’s decision centers on the belief that using school buildings as polling places could compromise student and staff security, particularly during critical testing periods. These testing periods include the administration of the Keystone Exams, which are end-of-course assessments in Algebra I, Literature, and Biology, and serve as a component of Pennsylvania’s high school graduation requirements, as outlined by the Pennsylvania Department of Education. Keystone Exams information.
County Argues for Voter Access
County officials, however, maintain that school buildings are essential for facilitating a smooth and secure election process, especially with anticipated high voter turnout. York County Commissioner Scott Burford, who also serves on the Board of Elections, noted that discussions regarding polling place access began in 2024 in anticipation of increased voter participation. The county previously hired Flagger Force to manage traffic flow during the 2024 elections, demonstrating a proactive approach to logistical challenges. The lawsuit seeks to compel the school district to allow the use of its buildings as polling places, arguing that doing so is necessary to uphold voter rights and ensure a fair election.
Keystone Exams and School Facility Use
The Keystone Exams, designed to replace the Grade 11 PSSA, are a key part of Pennsylvania’s assessment system, providing data on student proficiency and contributing to federal accountability measures under the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA). More information on Keystone Exams. The scheduling of these exams, alongside concerns about building security, appears to be central to the school board’s decision. The Pennsylvania Standards of School Assessments (PSSA) and Keystone Exams provide data on student performance in reading and math, broken down by school district, grade level, and student groups, including those historically underperforming. Pennsylvania School Performance Data.
The dispute highlights a broader tension between the need to provide accessible voting locations and the responsibilities of school districts to prioritize student safety and maintain educational operations. The outcome of this legal challenge could set a precedent for how school facilities are used as polling places in York County and potentially across Pennsylvania.
As the case progresses, the court will likely weigh the county’s arguments regarding voter access against the school district’s concerns about safety and operational disruptions. The next hearing date has not yet been announced, but the resolution of this lawsuit will be critical in preparing for the upcoming elections and ensuring a smooth voting process for York County residents. Stay tuned for further updates as this story develops.
Have your say: Do you think schools should be required to provide space for polling places? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
