Zug continued their dominant run in the Women’s League playoffs, securing a 4-0 victory against SC Bern following a resounding 7-1 win in the previous game. Yet, despite being on the cusp of a championship title, EVZ captain Lara Stalder voiced strong criticism regarding the officiating, citing concerns over player safety and the overall quality of the refereeing in the high-stakes final series.
The victory at the Postfinance Arena, witnessed by a crowd of 1562 fans, puts Zug within striking distance of claiming the title. But Stalder’s post-game comments overshadowed the team’s success, focusing on what she described as inconsistent and potentially dangerous officiating. The team is now poised to potentially secure the championship in their next home game, marking a significant achievement just two years after the team’s founding in 2023.
Stalder Alleges Inconsistent Officiating and Player Safety Concerns
Following the 4-0 win, Stalder expressed her frustration, stating, “Now we have another injured player.” Her criticism was directly aimed at the referees, Karin Williner and Fabienne Stucki, whom she believes did not meet the standard expected in a championship final. “The refereeing performance is not what it should be,” Stalder said, according to reporting from bote.ch.
A specific incident drawing Stalder’s ire involved a check by Bern’s Clara Rozier on Stalder in the 43rd minute, which appeared to target the head/neck area. No penalty was called on the play. Stalder described the impact, saying, “It took my breath away. I was glad Ivana (Wey) was there to facilitate me up. I was able to continue,” as reported by Blick.
Beyond the incident involving Stalder, two other players – Bern’s Cindy Joray and Zug’s Annic Büchi – sustained injuries during the game. Joray required assistance to leave the ice after an incident involving Noemi Neubauerova, while Büchi collided with Maija Otamo and ended up in the boards. In both cases, the referees opted not to issue penalties.
Balancing Women’s Hockey Development with Championship Standards
Stalder, a prominent figure in Swiss women’s hockey, acknowledged the importance of fostering growth within the sport but argued for a higher standard of officiating in the final. “I’m the last person to say anything against the promotion of women. I think that’s great,” she stated. “But you could likewise focus on a mix so that women are brought to the level. Because I believe that in the final, the refereeing performance should be flawless. Mistakes can happen. But there were too many mistakes now. The head referees need to take better control.”
The EVZ team has the opportunity to clinch the championship on Wednesday at 7:30 PM in the OYM Hall, in Zug. A win in the third game of the best-of-five series would secure the title for the Central Swiss team, marking a rapid ascent to success since the team’s establishment.
What’s Next for EV Zug and the Women’s League
All eyes will be on the EVZ as they aim to finish the series in their home arena. The outcome of Wednesday’s game will determine whether the championship is decided or if the series extends to a fourth and potentially fifth game. The league will also likely face scrutiny regarding the officiating, potentially leading to a review of referee assignments and performance evaluation protocols. Fans can follow the game and the entire Postfinance Women’s League through RED+, which offers a GAMEPASS for live coverage of various Swiss hockey leagues.
The situation highlights the ongoing discussion surrounding the development of women’s hockey and the need to balance support for emerging officials with the demand for consistent, high-quality officiating in championship-level competitions.
Share your thoughts on the game and the officiating controversy in the comments below.
