2025 NFL Season: Evaluating Top Backup Quarterbacks Rankings

Okay, here’s a breakdown of the backup quarterback rankings discussed in the provided text, along with a summary of the reasoning for each player’s placement. I’ll present it in order, as the article seems to rank them:

1. Cousins (Minnesota Vikings) – Not much detail is given in this excerpt about why Cousins is ranked #1, but it’s stated he’s considered the best backup by ESPN’s Football Power Index.

2. Browning (Denver Broncos) – Also considered one of the top backups by ESPN’s FPI, trailing only Cousins. Again, little specific detail is provided on his strengths.

3. Mariota (Philadelphia Eagles) –
* Recent Performance: 66.2 QBR since 2020. 58.0 QBR in 2022 (when he was a primary starter with the Falcons).
* Fill-In ability: Described as “very solid” when stepping in for starters.
* FPI Ranking: 3rd best backup according to ESPN’s Football Power Index.

4. McKee (Philadelphia Eagles) –
* Limited Regular Season Experience: Sixth-round pick in 2023,lacking a large track record.
* Positive Signals: Strong performance in training camp and preseason.
* Key Team Action: The Eagles traded Kenny Pickett to acquire McKee, indicating a vote of confidence.
* Stats: 65.5 career QBR on 47 dropbacks (including one start) with a win against the Giants.
* Ranking Basis: The author admits this ranking is based more on “vibes” than hard data,but considers those vibes valuable.

5. Brissett (New England Patriots)

* Past Success: Played well as a starter for the Browns in 2022 while Deshaun Watson was suspended, finishing 8th in QBR (62.0).
* Market Value: Was a sought-after bridge/backup QB after 2022, signing deals with the Commanders and then the Patriots.
* Recent Struggles: Had a lower QBR (41.5) during his time with the Patriots, which is attributed, in part, to poor offensive support (especially pass protection).
* Age & Relevance: While a few seasons removed from his best performance, the author states his earlier success is still relevant.

Overall Theme:

The article focuses on identifying not just quarterbacks with starter experience, but those who can reliably step in and perform at a reasonable level when needed. It also gives weight to scouting reports and team decisions(like the Pickett trade) as indicators of potential. The use of ESPN’s FPI adds a data-driven element to the analysis.

What specific traits beyond arm strength and experience would be most crucial for a Tier 2 backup quarterback (like Sam Howell or Joe Flacco) to elevate their performance and potentially become a long-term starter?

The Increasing Importance of QB Depth in the NFL

The 2025 NFL season is shaping up to be another year where quarterback depth is paramount. Injuries are inevitable, and having a reliable backup can be the difference between a playoff run and a disappointing finish. This ranking focuses on the best NFL backup quarterbacks poised to make an impact should they be called upon, considering factors like experience, skillset, and team fit.We’ll be looking at potential NFL quarterback injuries and how teams are preparing for them. This isn’t just about arm talent; it’s about game management, leadership, and minimizing mistakes. Fantasy football backup QBs are also gaining attention as potential waiver wire gems.

Tier 1: Ready to Start Instantly

Thes quarterbacks aren’t just holding a clipboard; they’re legitimate starting-caliber players.

* Gardner Minshew,indianapolis Colts (Backup to Anthony Richardson): Minshew’s extensive experience and proven ability to win games make him arguably the most valuable backup in the league. He’s a capable passer with a strong understanding of NFL offenses. His performance filling in for Richardson last season demonstrated his readiness.

* Jacoby Brissett, New England Patriots (Backup to Drake Maye): Brissett’s familiarity with the Patriots system and his overall consistency make him a safe and reliable option. He’s a veteran who understands how to manage a game and avoid costly turnovers. He’s a prime example of a triumphant NFL backup.

* Jameis Winston, New Orleans Saints (Backup to Derek Carr): Winston, despite past turnover issues, possesses a powerful arm and the ability to make big plays. He’s shown flashes of brilliance and could thrive in the right situation if given an extended opportunity. His experience as a former starter is invaluable.

Tier 2: High-Potential Fill-Ins

These backups have the potential to be effective starters, but may need a bit more time to adjust or refine their skills.

* Sam Howell,Washington Commanders (Backup to Jayden Daniels): Howell gained valuable experience as a starter last season. While inconsistent, he demonstrated a willingness to learn and improve. He’s a mobile quarterback who can extend plays with his legs.

* joe Flacco, Minnesota Vikings (Backup to J.J. McCarthy): Flacco, a Super Bowl MVP, brings a wealth of experience and a strong arm to the Vikings. While past his prime, he’s a proven winner who can provide stability in a pinch. His veteran presence is a significant asset.

* Cooper Rush, Dallas Cowboys (Backup to Dak Prescott): Rush has proven he can win games for the Cowboys when called upon. He’s a steady and reliable player who understands the offense well. He’s a solid emergency quarterback option.

Tier 3: Developing prospects & Experienced Veterans

This group consists of quarterbacks with either significant potential but limited experience, or seasoned veterans who can provide a steady hand in a limited role.

* Bailey Zappe, New England Patriots (Backup to Drake Maye): Zappe showed promise in limited action during his rookie season. He’s a developing quarterback with a good arm and a willingness to learn.

* Tyler Huntley, Baltimore Ravens (Backup to Lamar Jackson): Huntley is a mobile quarterback who can make plays with his legs. He’s a capable backup who can run the Ravens’ offense effectively.

* Nathan Rourke, Jacksonville Jaguars (Backup to Trevor Lawrence): Rourke has generated buzz with his arm talent and athleticism. He’s a developing quarterback with the potential to become a valuable asset.

Key Factors in Backup QB Evaluation

Several factors contribute to a quarterback’s value as a backup:

* System Knowledge: How well does the backup understand the team’s offensive scheme?

* Experience: Has the backup started games in the NFL? What was their performance like?