A resident with dementia was sexually assaulted at a care home in Greenock, Scotland

A resident with dementia was sexually assaulted at a care home in Greenock, Scotland, after three staff members had formally raised safeguarding concerns about the man who attacked her.

The operator, HC-One, later admitted liability and paid damages, BBC News reported.

The attack happened on a Saturday night in late 2023 at Merino Court Care Home.

Documents seen by BBC News show that in the months before it, staff reported the fellow resident, Allistair McAuley, for sexualised remarks, inappropriate conduct, slapping the woman — whom BBC News is calling Mary to protect her identity — on the bottom, touching her thighs, and giving her food she was not allowed to eat. One staff member told management that McAuley was “grooming” Mary.

The numbers that should have stopped it: three separate staff warnings, documented, in the months before the assault. The attack proceeded anyway.

That gap between what staff reported and what management did is now the central accountability question in the case, and it is why HC-One admitted primary liability for its failure to safeguard Mary in a civil action in March 2025 and paid damages to the family, according to BBC News.

HC-One Admitted Liability and Paid Damages

  • HC-One, one of the UK’s largest care home operators, admitted primary liability in March 2025 and paid damages — an admission of safeguarding failure, not a disputed claim.
  • The criminal case collapsed: 86-year-old McAuley was deemed unfit to stand trial and died in June, weeks before the evidence was due to be examined at Greenock Sheriff Court.
  • Abuse-related calls to the charity Hour Glass’s helpline rose 125% in Scotland over the past year, which its chief executive calls “the tip of the iceberg.”

Three Warnings, One Attack

McAuley’s behaviour was not hidden. According to the documents reported by BBC News, he had also acted inappropriately toward two female staff members at the home. The concerns were raised by three staff members in the months before the assault.

Then John — the name BBC News is using for Mary’s son — received a call from the home. “When I got to the home it was full of police cars,” he told BBC News. “They called the rape team in and that’s when the penny was starting to drop and I was told exactly what happened, and I was shocked.”

Merino Court Care Home - Exterior view of a modern two-storey care home or residential building with cream-rendered walls
Photo: bbc.co.uk

A carer walked into the bedroom and intervened, which John said meant the attack could have been worse. His mother, who has limited speech because of her dementia, was subdued and able to say only “bad man, bad man” — words he says still haunt him. “I was angered that I put my mum in that home to be safe,” he told BBC News.

Two Days of Assessments, Three Years of Delay

After the attack, McAuley remained at the home under staff supervision for two days while undergoing mental capacity assessments. During that time, Mary was confined to her room until police could remove him. Once found to have full capacity, he was charged with four counts of sexual assault — two relating to Mary and two relating to carers.

But the timeline tells a different story. The case took several years to call and was due at Greenock Sheriff Court earlier this year. By then, McAuley had been deemed unfit to stand trial. He died in June, weeks before the court was due to examine the evidence against him.

“There was no justice,” John told BBC News. “Nobody’s got justice. That man did what he did. In those three years nothing happened to him. Where’s the justice? There’s none.”

A spokesman for the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service said the indictment was served within the relevant statutory timescale, but that he “understood” John’s concern. The spokesman added that assessments of McAuley’s fitness to stand trial affected the case’s progress.

Liability Admitted, Apology Contested

With the criminal route closed, John pursued HC-One through the civil courts. In March 2025, the operator admitted primary liability for its failure to safeguard Mary and paid damages to the family. Michael McKitrick, of PBW Law, who represented John, said his client had expected his mother to be cared for, not exposed to the risk of sexual assault. “The second assault was certainly avoidable,” he said.

John says he has never received a formal apology and, three years on, “just wants answers.” HC-One declined an interview request from the BBC and did not answer questions about whether it had changed its protocols.

A spokesperson for the company said it took “immediate and appropriate steps,” alerted social services, the Care Inspectorate and police, and informed the family. “We apologised at the time for the distress caused to the victim and do so again now,” the spokesperson said.

The Care Inspectorate said it was satisfied the provider had notified it appropriately. Merino Court has been rated good or very good in its most recent inspections.

The Inverclyde Health and Social Care Partnership, which oversees care locally for the council and NHS board, told John three years ago that an inquiry would take place; he says he has heard nothing since. A spokesperson said any concerns are “dealt with through the appropriate safeguarding and professional processes” and that the partnership remains willing to meet family members.

A 125% Rise in Calls

The scale of the wider problem is measurable. Hour Glass, a charity running a 24-hour helpline on the abuse of older people, said calls about care home abuse in Scotland rose 125% in the past year. Its chief executive, Richard Robinson, told BBC News that sexual abuse in care homes is a “hidden issue” and that “there were a number of missed opportunities here.”

“It’s not just the victim survivor here. It’s not just the son. It’s also the staff themselves that have been let down,” Robinson said.

HC-One has been a familiar name in British care for over a decade. The company was formed in the wreckage of Southern Cross Healthcare — the UK’s then-largest care home operator — and became operational on 1 November 2011, founded by the entrepreneur and doctor Chai Patel, a former Chief Executive of Priory Group.

It grew by acquisition, most notably in August 2017, when it bought 122 care homes with 9,000 beds from Bupa for £300 million, making it the biggest care home company in the UK with 22,000 beds in total. Today it runs more than 275 homes across England, Scotland and Wales specialising in dementia, nursing and residential care, and in November 2018 it was named Care Home Group of the Year at the National Care Awards in London.

For operators in the sector, the financial mechanics of this case are worth reading closely: a documented internal warning trail, followed by an admission of primary liability and a damages payment. The paper trail staff created became the evidence against the operator.

Mary’s dementia has advanced rapidly since the attack; her son says “I don’t think it helped.” He still visits, trying to make her smile. “It was never about the money,” he told BBC News. “I wanted justice.”

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Microsoft’s Official Python Agent Framework Hijacked to Steal Cloud Credentials via PyPI

Zverev Beats Fils 6-4, 7-6 as Frenchman Exits ATP Finals Group Stage