All 212 Plant-Based Foods Tested in UK Study Contain Fungal Toxins, But Levels Below EU Limits

A new study reveals that 212 plant-based foods and beverages tested in the UK market contained at least one of 19 naturally occurring fungal toxins, known as mycotoxins.

Researchers from the University of Parma and Cranfield University, collaborating on the Horizon Europe FunShield4Med project, found these substances in products ranging from vegan sausages to oat milk, raising public health questions about cumulative dietary exposure.

The discovery serves as a significant warning for consumers relying heavily on meat alternatives and dairy substitutes. While the concentrations detected were all below the established European Union guidelines, the study highlights a critical gap in current food safety regulations: the lack of specific, established monitoring for mycotoxins in the rapidly expanding category of novel food products.

This meticulous testing of complex, multi-ingredient foods provides crucial data for public health bodies to better understand how widespread environmental contaminants are within modern diets.

Mycotoxins Come from Mold in Crops

  • Mycotoxins are chemical compounds produced by molds in crops (like grains and seeds), not necessarily living mold itself.
  • While the levels found in the tested products are currently compliant with EU safety limits, repeated exposure across multiple different foods is the primary concern.
  • Regulatory frameworks need to evolve to keep pace with the complexity and volume of new plant-based food ingredients entering the market.

Identifying Fungal Contaminants in Plant-Based Ingredients

The investigation, which analyzed 212 products sold across UK supermarkets, confirmed that every single item contained at least one mycotoxin. These toxins are produced when agricultural crops—such as grains, legumes, and seeds—are contaminated by fungi during cultivation, harvesting, or storage. The scientific team said that many of the tested products contained multiple different toxins, with at least one of the 19 monitored substances found in each sample.

This contamination generally occurs at the raw material stage, before the ingredients are processed into final products. For instance, the raw materials utilized in vegan burgers or soy milk are susceptible to mold growth in storage facilities or fields. Because mycotoxins are chemical metabolites, their presence does not indicate the food contains live mold, nor does it automatically classify the food as unsafe based on a single measurement.

Scientists tested 212 plant-based foods. Every single one contained fungal toxins
Photo: ncijnetwork.com

Researchers from the University of Parma reported that the toxins were detected across a wide range of categories, including plant-based meat alternatives (PMBAs) and plant-based beverages (PBBs). This broad detection pattern suggests that the contamination is not isolated to one specific ingredient but is a widespread environmental issue affecting common agricultural supplies used in modern food production.

Evaluating the Risk of Cumulative Dietary Exposure

The primary finding of the study is not that the products are immediately dangerous, but that they are ubiquitous with naturally occurring toxins. The concentration of toxins in all 212 sampled products remained below the recommended European Union guideline levels. This is a key reassurance for the UK food safety industry, which the team stated maintains high quality standards.

However, the researchers caution against evaluating these findings in isolation. The potential health risk is intrinsically linked to the cumulative exposure an individual receives over time. While eating one of these products occasionally is unlikely to pose a health risk based on the levels reported, a diet heavily reliant on numerous plant-based products could lead to repeated, low-level exposure.

The severity of potential mycotoxin exposure varies depending on the specific chemical compound involved and the dose. Clinically, at sufficiently high or sustained exposure levels, certain mycotoxins have the potential to damage critical organs like the liver and kidneys, interfere with normal immune system function, and increase cancer risk.

It is important to note that the new data does not establish a causal link between these products and these conditions; rather, it provides data for risk assessment.

Regulatory Frameworks Must Address New Plant-Based Foods

  • Mycotoxins are chemical compounds produced by molds in crops (like grains and seeds), not necessarily living mold itself.
  • While the levels found in the tested products are currently compliant with EU safety limits, repeated exposure across multiple different foods is the primary concern.
  • Regulatory frameworks need to evolve to keep pace with the complexity and volume of new plant-based food ingredients entering the market.

Bridging the Gap in Food Safety Regulation

The study highlights a critical regulatory vulnerability: there are currently no established regulations to monitor mycotoxins when new foods enter the market, a concern raised by Cranfield University's Senior Lecturer in Mycology, Andrea Patriarca. She explained that “Mycotoxins occur naturally in foods and cannot be completely avoided.”

Patriarca added that the challenge lies in the complexity of multi-ingredient food systems. When a product is made from numerous components—such as a plant-based sausage containing grains, legumes, and seeds—each component may introduce different, unpredictable contaminants, making overall dietary exposure assessment extremely difficult. The research aims to inform policymakers and help food safety organizations understand these complex risk profiles.

This study was part of the European Union-funded Horizon Europe FunShield4Med project (HORIZON-WIDERA-2021-ACCESS-03), Grant Agreement No 101079173, demonstrating the collaborative, European focus on food safety research.

Metric Finding Regulatory Status
Total Products Tested 212 Widespread Contamination
Source of Contaminant Raw ingredients (Grains/Legumes) No specific regulation for new foods

Dietary Diversity Manages Mycotoxin Exposure

Mycotoxin exposure is generally managed through dietary diversity and adherence to established food safety guidelines.

Future Monitoring of Complex Food Matrices

The collaboration between the University of Parma and Cranfield University is focused on building solid data to guide future risk assessments for the UK population. By understanding how different dietary patterns influence exposure, researchers hope to provide evidence that can inform future food safety policies.

The University of Parma, one of the oldest universities in the world, traces its origins to a studium in the city during the 13th and 14th centuries. It was reopened in 1412 by Niccolò III d’Este and, after several closures and revivals, was formally reestablished in 1601 under Ranuccio I Farnese with a papal bull, operating jointly with the Society of Jesus.

Today a public university organized into nine departments, it counts around 26,000 students. Its long scientific tradition includes Bernardino Ramazzini, the professor of medicine regarded as the father of Occupational Medicine, and the neuroscientist Giacomo Rizzolatti, and the institution continues to play an active role in European research collaborations such as the FunShield4Med project.

The findings suggest that for consumers, the critical action is not to avoid the entire category of plant-based foods, but to prioritize variety and to be aware of the possibility of cumulative exposure. The research continues to monitor how food safety monitoring can keep pace with the rapid expansion of the plant-based food industry.

References

  • ScienceDaily, “Mycotoxin contamination in plant-based beverages and meat alternatives: A survey of the UK market.”
  • European Union Horizon Europe FunShield4Med project (HORIZON-WIDERA-2021-ACCESS-03).
Photo of author

Health Desk

Health Desk at Archyde.

Marseille, the Tapie Révolution: How Bernard Tapie Transformed OM (1986-1989)

Pauline Hits 35,000€ on ‘N’oubliez Pas Les Paroles’ to Fund Dream Kitchen