ANIA Forum Survey: 88% of Italian Insurers Use ESG in Underwriting Policies

ESG criteria now sit in the underwriting policies of 88% of the Italian insurers surveyed by ANIA and the Forum for Sustainable Finance, up from 45% in 2022 — the sharpest shift recorded in the fifth edition of their joint survey, presented in Rome on November 12, assinews.it reported.

The survey covers companies holding 76% of the Italian insurance market by premiums collected. That weighting matters: these are not niche players talking about sustainability, but the bulk of the market that writes Italian households’ policies and manages their life savings. Assinews.it reported the findings, which were presented on the closing day of the Settimane SRI, a series of events on responsible investment running from October 29 to November 12.

Underwriting is the headline for these reasons. Investment portfolios went ESG years ago — 99.7% of the sample now applies environmental, social and governance factors there. Underwriting, the actual business of pricing and accepting risk, lagged. It no longer does. Another 11% of respondents is still evaluating the move, which leaves only a small residual with no plans at all.

What that means in practice, according to the survey: 94% of respondents offer dedicated ESG-themed products, 89% restrict coverage for activities exposed to high ESG risks, and 85% apply premium-based incentives — rewards or penalties tied to sustainability behavior. On the claims side, 64% already use sustainable solutions in claims handling and ancillary guarantees, with 14% more planning to introduce them.

ESG Underwriting and Investment Adoption Reaches New Heights

  • ESG underwriting adoption nearly doubled in four years — 88% versus 45% in 2022 — across firms representing 76% of Italian premiums.
  • Investment-side ESG saturation is effectively total: 99.7% of the sample, with 94% applying it to 75–100% of the portfolio.
  • Geopolitical tension has not reversed course — 72% of respondents left their investment stance unchanged, 28% strengthened it.

But the balance sheet tells its own story. Insurance companies are among Europe’s largest institutional investors, and the survey shows the ESG toolkit is now standard equipment: exclusions used by 100% of respondents, reference to international conventions by 91%, engagement with investee companies by 89%, thematic investments by 81%, best-in-class issuer selection by 79%, impact investing by 67% and voting rights exercised by 64%, according to Assinews.

ESG practice in underwriting Share of sample (2025 survey)
Dedicated ESG-themed products 94%
Restrictions on high-ESG-risk activities 89%
Premium incentives (bonus/malus) 85%
Sustainable claims and ancillary solutions 64%
Planning to introduce claims solutions 14%

Carbon accounting is nearly universal. Assinews.it reported that 98% of the sample measures the carbon footprint of its investment portfolio; in 80% of cases that footprint has declined since measurement began, and it is unchanged in 17%. Meanwhile, 69% of respondents have written climate-neutrality targets into investment policy, with a further 19% planning to.

The survey itself flags this catch. The release does not state the size of those carbon reductions, nor the time horizons behind the neutrality commitments. A target without a date is a statement of intent; the missing detail is where the market’s scrutiny will land next.

Governance is where the numbers approach unanimity. Every company in the sample includes ESG factors in strategic plans and maintains dedicated organizational structures — functions, committees, or both. Assinews.it reported that 99% embed ESG objectives in remuneration policy, 99.7% run training programs for all staff, 96% incorporate gender equality in personnel management, and 98.8% track the gender pay gap as an indicator.

The survey’s own caveats deserve plain language. The percentages describe the responding sample, not automatically the whole Italian market. The release does not specify how many companies answered or how responses were weighted — the 76% figure reflects participants’ weight in premiums, not the numerical share of Italian insurers. Smaller carriers, in other words, may look different from the giants that dominate the premium pool.

For market watchers, the commercial signal is straightforward. With 89% of major Italian insurers restricting cover for high-ESG-risk activities and 85% using premium incentives, sustainability criteria are moving from marketing language into pricing engines. That affects corporate clients’ cost of risk transfer — and, indirectly, the economics of carbon-intensive sectors seeking insurance in Italy.

The release, for now, does not say.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Senator Ted Cruz Pushes for US Recognition of Somaliland

Cambodia’s Online Scam Industry Remains Largely Intact Despite Crackdown