Bull Ray Doubts Star’s Reign at AEW All In 2025

AEW All In: Texas Main Event – Bully Ray Argues for “Hangman” Page too Win, Cites Lack of Incentive for Moxley Retention

TEXAS – with AEW All In: Texas just 24 hours away, the wrestling world is buzzing with predictions for the highly anticipated card.At the forefront is the AEW World Championship clash between champion Jon Moxley and challenger Adam “Hangman” Page. While Moxley’s recent championship reign has faced criticism from segments of the fanbase, Bully Ray, speaking on “Busted Open Radio,” has weighed in on the potential outcome, suggesting that a victory for Moxley offers little benefit.

Ray articulated his reasoning, stating, “I don’t think any good can possibly come out of Jon Moxley retaining. I don’t care about who is on the horizon. We’ve talked about Darby [Allin], we’ve talked about Bryan Danielson, there’s nobody on the horizon where I’m like, you know what, I’d like to see Mox win ’cause they have this guy waiting, and this guy vs this guy would be amazing. There’s onyl two people out there that I could come up with who I’d rather see [other than Page] …. Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns.Chances of that happening – zero.”

The sentiment highlights a potential creative crossroads for Moxley’s championship. As Ray points out, the immediate future challengers, while credible, might not present a compelling enough narrative hook for a Moxley victory that would elevate the championship considerably.

Conversely, Bully Ray emphasized Adam Page’s organic connection with the audience, arguing that this momentum makes him the clear choice to win. “More people are behind him than ever, whatever it is. All of this emotion is now in ‘Hangman’ Page. You have to pull the trigger,” Ray asserted. This outlook suggests that Page’s current popularity and the narrative built around him create a critical opportunity for AEW to capitalize on fan investment.

Adding another layer of intrigue to the main event, a stipulation known for its brutality has been added to the AEW World Championship match. Given the intense history between Moxley and Page in AEW, this bloody stipulation is hardly a surprise and promises a hard-hitting contest that will undoubtedly leave a lasting mark on the event.

Evergreen Insight: The debate surrounding championship reigns and potential challengers is a perennial topic in professional wrestling. Examining when to “pull the trigger” on a rising star or a popular challenger is a crucial booking decision. A accomplished championship reign frequently enough hinges not just on the champion’s performance but also on the quality of opponents and the narratives developed. When a champion’s reign begins to feel stagnant, or when a challenger has garnered significant organic support, making a change at the top can reignite interest and provide a fresh direction for the company. The emotional investment of the fanbase is a powerful currency, and recognizing opportunities to reward that investment through meaningful championship changes can be key to long-term success.

How might Bull Buchanan’s comments influence fan perception of AEW’s booking leading up to All In 2025?

Dudley Boyz’s Perspective on AEW Championship Picture

Veteran wrestling personality and former tag team champion, Bull Buchanan (formerly Bull Ray Dudley), has publicly expressed skepticism regarding a potential extended championship reign for a top AEW star heading into All In 2025. While not naming the specific competitor, buchanan’s comments, made during a recent appearance on the 83 Weeks podcast with Eric Bischoff, centered around concerns about booking patterns and the long-term viability of certain storylines within All Elite Wrestling. The speculation focuses heavily on the AEW World Championship and the potential challengers emerging before and during the All In event in London.

Key Concerns Voiced by Buchanan

Buchanan’s doubts stem from several key observations regarding AEW’s current booking strategies. He highlighted:

Predictability: A perceived tendency towards predictable outcomes in major feuds, perhaps diminishing the impact of championship victories. this impacts fan engagement and the perceived stakes of AEW All In 2025.

Over-Reliance on Established Names: Concerns that AEW sometimes prioritizes elevating established stars over organically building new ones, potentially stifling the growth of homegrown talent.

Short-Term Storytelling: A critique of storylines that lack long-term depth and rely heavily on immediate gratification, hindering the development of compelling narratives leading into events like all In.

Championship Transition Timing: Buchanan questioned the timing of potential championship changes, suggesting that some transitions feel forced or lack logical progression. He specifically mentioned the importance of building momentum towards a title change, not simply executing it.

Potential Targets of Buchanan’s Criticism: Analyzing the AEW Roster

While Buchanan remained intentionally vague, several AEW stars are frequently discussed as potential subjects of his critique. These include:

Samoa Joe: Currently holding the AEW World Championship, Joe’s reign has been marked by strong performances but also questions about its longevity. His history of injuries is a recurring concern among fans.

Swerve Strickland: A recent challenger and former champion, Strickland’s momentum has been significant, but some analysts question his ability to maintain a dominant position long-term.

adam Cole: A popular and skilled performer, Cole’s championship aspirations are consistently discussed, but his past booking in WWE raises questions about AEW’s plans for him.

Jon Moxley: A cornerstone of AEW, Moxley’s unpredictable nature and history of taking time off for personal reasons contribute to uncertainty about his championship prospects.

Impact on AEW all in 2025

The implications of buchanan’s doubts for AEW All In 2025 are significant. The event, already positioned as a major showcase for the company, relies heavily on compelling championship matches and storylines.If fans perceive the outcomes as predetermined or the narratives as lacking substance, it could negatively impact attendance, viewership, and overall event success.

Increased Scrutiny: Buchanan’s comments will undoubtedly lead to increased scrutiny of AEW’s booking decisions in the weeks leading up to All In.

Fan Expectations: Fans will be more critical of championship matches, demanding more logical and satisfying outcomes.

Pressure on AEW Creative: The AEW creative team will face increased pressure to deliver compelling storylines and avoid predictable booking patterns.

Ancient Precedent: Championship Reign Doubts

Throughout wrestling history, veteran personalities have often voiced skepticism about championship reigns. For example, in 2015, Jim Ross publicly questioned Roman Reigns’ push as the face of WWE, citing a lack of organic fan support. Similarly, in 2019, Ric Flair expressed concerns about Becky Lynch’s ability to sustain her momentum as a top star. These instances demonstrate that such critiques are common and often spark debate within the wrestling community.

AEW’s Response and Future Outlook

As of July 11, 2025, AEW has not officially responded to buchanan’s comments. Though, the company’s booking decisions in the coming weeks will be closely monitored by fans and analysts alike. The success of AEW All In 2025 hinges on AEW’s ability to address these concerns and deliver a compelling and unpredictable championship picture. Key factors to watch include:

Championship Match Announcements: The caliber and build-up of championship matches announced for All In.

Storyline Development: the depth and complexity of the storylines leading into the event.

Surprise Appearances: The potential for unexpected appearances or twists that could shake up the championship landscape.