Prime Minister Andy Burnham arrives in Brussels this Friday for his first major European summit, changing British strategy to mirror the complex, often precarious path of Swiss-EU relations.
While some within the Labour Party have floated the idea of a full return to the European Union, the political reality suggests a more incremental, sector-by-sector approach—a strategy increasingly described as “Thinking Swiss.”
The Limits of the Global Britain Narrative
Despite the promise of “Global Britain” and the pursuit of sovereignty, the economic costs of the 2021 departure from the EU single market have consistently outweighed the benefits. Data indicates that nearly 60 percent of Britons now express regret over the exit, while only 30 percent maintain that the decision remains correct.
Liz Truss’s 2023 attempt to aggressively deregulate and slash taxes to compete with Brussels faltered under pressure from financial markets. The global trade environment has shifted. Small businesses, farmers, and tech startups continue to struggle with the administrative burden of proving compliance with EU health and safety standards for exported goods.
After initial post-Brexit spikes in net migration, the government’s abrupt shift toward restrictive visa policies has created an environment that hinders economic growth. “Grossbritannien, so scheint es, dreht sich im Kreis,” said the Neue Zürcher Zeitung, highlighting the nation’s struggle to balance market access with political autonomy.
Burnham Pursues a Middle Path Through Sectoral Agreements
Burnham’s administration appears to be moving away from the rigid ideological lines of the past, eyeing a “middle path” that avoids the binary choice between a hard Brexit and full membership. This strategy aligns with the Swiss model of sectoral agreements. On Friday, the agenda includes the signing of deals covering youth exchange programs, the integration of emissions trading systems, and a food trade agreement.
Under the proposed food trade deal, British producers of items like sausages, margarine, and seafood would regain frictionless access to the EU market. The trade-off requires London to adopt EU regulations dynamically to ensure ongoing standard alignment.
Disputes would be handled by an arbitration court that draws upon the legal precedents of the European Court of Justice. This mechanism is nearly identical to the structure proposed in the latest Swiss-EU treaty package, a reality that has not escaped the notice of British policymakers.
The Swiss approach to the EU, characterized by the “autonomous adoption” of rules, provides a necessary balance in the tension between market access and political sovereignty. However, this balance is increasingly fragile as the EU insists on more binding legal commitments, as noted in the book Brexit, Bregret und die Lehren für die Schweiz by Niklaus Nuspliger.
Critics Warn of Surrendering Sovereignty for Market Access
The “Thinking Swiss” approach, as termed by the Labour Movement for Europe, is not without its domestic critics. Hardline Brexit supporters warn of a “salami tactic”—a slow, incremental process of surrendering sovereignty that they fear will lead to a de facto return to the EU without the benefits of being a member state.
Brussels, meanwhile, remains wary of granting special treatment. EU diplomats have signaled that the era of British rebates and unique exceptions is over. The European Commission prioritizes the integrity of the single market above all else, meaning it cannot offer third-party nations terms that would undermine the incentives for current EU members.
As Rolf Jeker observed in the Neue Zürcher Zeitung, the Swiss economy is so deeply integrated into European infrastructure that the country is effectively forced to align with EU regulations in its own self-interest, even without a formal deal, to remain competitive.
While Burnham has signaled a willingness to engage in an “honest debate” regarding migration, the political appetite for such a move remains untested.