carter Hart Defends Filming Partners in Sexual Assault Trial, Cites Athlete Norms
goalkeeper Carter Hart, during cross-examination at the sexual assault trial involving himself and four of his 2018 Team Canada teammates, stated that filming a partner to ostensibly confirm consent is not unusual for athletes.
Hart’s Testimony is central to the ongoing proceedings, where he, along with Michael Mcleod, Dillon Dubé, Alex Formenton, and Cal Foote, face accusations related to an incident following a Hockey Canada gala in London, Ontario.
The Prosecution’s Line of Questioning
Crown Prosecutor Meaghan Cunningham questioned Hart about videos taken by Michael McLeod after the alleged incident. These videos reportedly feature hockey players asking the woman if she consented and if she was “correct” with what was happening.
Cunningham pressed Hart, “Would You agree with me, logically speaking, that you would only think of recording a consent video if there was a possibility in your mind that the person could later say that he was not consenting?”
Hart responded, “No. There are lots of professional athletes who did this before.”
Memory Lapses and Inconsistencies
Since Friday, hart has faced intense questioning regarding alleged memory gaps and potential inconsistencies in his statements. He recalled one instance of oral sex with the complainant, while other teammates claimed it happened twice.
Despite the intense scrutiny, Hart appeared composed while addressing the Crown’s suggestions. The 26-year-old athlete testified in his defense, as well as for McLeod, Dubé, Formenton, and Foote.
Details of the Night in Question
Hart admitted consuming alcohol on the evening of the alleged assault in June 2018 but claimed he wasn’t heavily intoxicated. He also stated that he had no prior interaction with the alleged victim,only known as EM,whose identity is protected by a publication ban.
Cunningham questioned, “It Was your belief, when it comes into the room, that she wanted to engage in sexual acts but that had nothing to do with what she had saeid or done?” Hart confirmed this was accurate.
Hart also confirmed he did not recall asking the woman anything upon entering the room.
The “Three Plan” Text Message
The Court examined a text message sent by McLeod to a group chat, inviting teammates to his room for a “fast three plan” around 2 a.m. Hart replied, “I’m Ready,” approximately ten minutes later.
Despite the message not being directly addressed to him, Hart said he believed the offer was intended specifically for him because he was the only one to respond. He assumed an agreement existed between McLeod and the woman regarding the “three plan.”
Cunningham countered, “But This message does not say that a woman agrees with a three plan.” Hart acknowledged this point,admitting he proceeded despite knowing nothing about the woman involved.
| Player Name | Position | Role in trial |
|---|---|---|
| Carter Hart | Goalkeeper | Accused, Testifying in Defense |
| Michael McLeod | Forward | Accused, alleged Text Message Sender |
| Dillon Dubé | Forward | Accused |
| Alex Formenton | Forward | Accused |
| Cal Foote | Defenseman | Accused |
What are your thoughts on the defense’s argument regarding consent and the filming of partners? How do you perceive the role of social dynamics in such situations?
Understanding Consent: A Broader Perspective
The legal definition of consent is clear: it must be freely given, informed, and enthusiastic. Consent can be withdrawn at any time. any sexual activity without explicit consent is considered sexual assault. Resources like the Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network (RAINN) provide thorough information and support for survivors of sexual violence.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Carter Hart Case
- What Is the Current Status of Carter Hart’s Sexual Assault Trial?
- Carter Hart is currently on trial, along with four other members of the 2018 Team Canada junior team, facing sexual assault charges.The trial is ongoing, with testimonies and cross-examinations being conducted.
- What Did Carter Hart Say About Filming Partners?
- Carter Hart testified that filming partners to confirm consent is a normal practice among professional athletes, suggesting it’s not unusual to record such interactions.
- Who Else Is Involved in the Carter Hart Trial?
- Besides Carter Hart, Michael McLeod, Dillon Dubé, Alex Formenton, and Cal Foote are also facing charges related to the alleged sexual assault.
- What Is the Significance of the “Three Plan” Text Message in the Carter Hart Case?
- The “Three Plan” Text Message, sent by Michael Mcleod, is being used as evidence to understand the intentions and communications among the players involved in the alleged incident. It raises questions about consent and pre-arranged plans.
- Where Can I Find More Information About Sexual Assault and Consent?
- You can find more information about sexual assault and consent from organizations like the Rape, Abuse & Incest national Network (RAINN). They offer resources, support, and educational materials.
What are your thoughts on the complexities surrounding consent in high-profile cases? Share your perspective in the comments below.
