Breaking stories and in‑depth analysis: up‑to‑the‑minute global news on politics, business, technology, culture, and more—24/7, all in one place.
The question of how Abraham Lincoln would approach the deeply divided political landscape of today is gaining traction, prompting historians and political analysts to re-examine his leadership strategies. At a time when polarization seems to be the norm, understanding Lincoln’s methods – particularly his ability to navigate intense conflict – feels increasingly relevant. The exploration of how Lincoln would navigate today’s politics isn’t simply an academic exercise, but a search for potential lessons applicable to contemporary challenges.
Historian Matthew Pinsker, author of the recently released “Boss Lincoln,” is at the forefront of this inquiry. Pinsker’s work, and his weekly substack centered around the question “What would Lincoln do?”, frames modern political issues through the lens of Lincoln’s pragmatism and political acumen. He argues that while Lincoln is often remembered for his moral stance against slavery, his success as a leader stemmed from a more complex understanding of power and compromise. This nuanced view challenges the often-simplified image of Lincoln as solely the “Great Emancipator,” and instead presents him as a shrewd politician who understood the art of the possible.
Lincoln’s Political Skillset: Beyond Emancipation
Pinsker’s research reveals a Lincoln who was comfortable with maneuvering within the existing political system, even if it meant making tough choices or engaging in what might be considered “boss” politics today. As Pinsker explained in a recent discussion with Geoff Bennett, Lincoln’s ability to build coalitions and manage competing interests was crucial to preserving the Union during the Civil War. This involved a willingness to negotiate, to understand the motivations of his opponents, and to apply patronage strategically. The idea that Lincoln was a master of political maneuvering, not just a moral beacon, is central to Pinsker’s analysis.
The historian points out that new evidence continues to emerge, offering fresh insights into Lincoln’s life and presidency. “We find new evidence almost every year,” Pinsker stated, “There’s always some document stashed away, somebody’s attic. It just brings him to life in a fresh way.” This ongoing discovery underscores the enduring relevance of Lincoln and the potential for continued learning from his example.
Applying Lincoln’s Lessons to Modern Division
So, how might Lincoln approach the political divisions of 2026? Pinsker suggests that Lincoln would likely focus on finding common ground and building bridges, even with those he strongly disagreed with. He would recognize the importance of understanding the concerns of all sides and seeking solutions that, while not perfect, could move the country forward. This approach contrasts sharply with the current tendency towards entrenched positions and demonization of opponents.
The question of whether Lincoln would be successful using these tactics today is a complex one. Pinsker acknowledges that the political landscape has changed dramatically since Lincoln’s time, with the rise of social media, 24-hour news cycles, and increased polarization. However, he believes that the fundamental principles of Lincoln’s leadership – empathy, pragmatism, and a commitment to preserving the Union – remain relevant.
A recent discussion on PBS News Hour explored these themes further, with Pinsker analyzing modern politics through the lens of Lincoln’s actions. The YouTube video provides a visual companion to the conversation, offering additional insights into Pinsker’s research and analysis. Another video, “What would surprise Lincoln most about today’s politics”, delves into specific aspects of the modern political environment that might shock the 16th president.
What Comes Next?
As President’s Day approaches, the renewed focus on Lincoln’s leadership offers a valuable opportunity for reflection. The lessons from his presidency, as illuminated by historians like Matthew Pinsker, suggest that navigating today’s political challenges requires a willingness to compromise, a commitment to understanding opposing viewpoints, and a focus on the long-term health of the nation. The ongoing exploration of Lincoln’s legacy, fueled by new discoveries and insightful analysis, promises to continue shaping our understanding of American politics for years to reach.
What aspects of Lincoln’s leadership do you think are most relevant to today’s political climate? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and please share this article with others who might find it insightful.
