Deadly heat waves and catastrophic floods mark 2026 as the hottest year on record, yet the 31st annual UN climate summit (COP31) opens in Antalya, Turkey, with no global consensus on phasing out fossil fuel emissions.
Negotiations at COP31, which concludes on Friday, November 20, face low expectations from observers as global leadership largely bypasses the event. British Prime Minister Andy Burnham told the summit that any international consensus on fighting climate change has vanished, “talking more about weapons and tariffs than the survival of future generations,” Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva said of fellow leaders at the UN climate summit in Turkey.
Reflecting on fifty years of environmental policy, James K. Boyce, professor emeritus of economics at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, said that when he began doctoral studies at Oxford in 1980, the university offered no courses in environmental economics. As pollution put environmental issues on the political map, the academic field eventually developed around the concept of externalities—impacts of production and consumption excluded from market prices.
Initial models focused on cost-benefit efficiency using shadow prices, largely ignoring economic inequality and political power structures. Boyce’s research highlights that standard cost-benefit analyses operate on a principle of one dollar, one vote, giving wealthier populations disproportionate influence over acceptable environmental degradation thresholds.
“Economic inequality and the accompanying inequalities of power make it easier for those on top of the economic ladder to impose environmental costs on everyone else, and especially on those at or near the bottom,” Boyce told Truthout.
Early environmental movements often framed nature protection as a conflict against people, echoing Malthusian views that population growth among the poor drove ecological degradation. That narrative shifted in the 1980s with the rise of the environmental justice movement, which focused initially on the disproportionate placement of hazardous waste facilities in Black communities.
This activism broadened to address disparities across class, ethnicity, and gender. A significant institutional milestone occurred in 1994 when President Bill Clinton signed an executive order directing federal agencies to address disproportionate environmental impacts on minority and low-income populations.
Despite historical achievements such as the 1989 Montreal Protocol protecting the stratospheric ozone layer, systemic challenges persist. Studies analyzing predictors of exposure to environmental hazards indicate that race and ethnicity often serve as stronger predictors of environmental hazard exposure than income levels alone.
COP31 follows decades of climate summits marked by short-term political maneuvering, ongoing disputes over adaptation funding, and deep divisions between developed and developing nations. The official summit agenda also omits the relationship between militarism and climate action, ignoring the greenhouse gas emissions generated by military conflicts and occupations, including the destruction in Gaza.
Boyce argues that national and local action need not wait for stalled international treaties.
“The fact that we are now on the 31st summit and have yet to phase out emissions of greenhouse gases shows that their impact has been limited,” Boyce told Truthout.