Crew Coach Courtois Says ‘Everyone Knows’ Messi Deserved Red Card After 3-0 Win’

Columbus Crew routed Inter Miami 3-0 in Game 1 of their best-of-three MLS Cup playoff series at Nu Stadium on Saturday night.

The match turned on a flashpoint in first-half stoppage time. With Miami already down to 10 men after Gonzalo Luján’s earlier ejection and trailing 1-0 on a Gonzalo Tapia penalty, Lionel Messi whipped a quick throw-in directly into Tapia’s face from a few feet away. Referee Allen Chapman booked both players — Tapia for failing to retreat the required two yards, Messi for the throw.

“Everybody knows that he deserved more than a yellow card,” Crew coach Laurent Courtois said after the game. “It’s just sad, really sad,” he told ESPN.

Chapman defended the decision to a pool reporter. “The force used was negligible and the offense did not reach the level of violent conduct,” the referee said, according to SI.com.

Had Messi been shown a red card, he would have been suspended for at least Friday’s Game 2 in Columbus, where the Crew can eliminate the defending MLS Cup champions.

Instead, the 39-year-old — who claimed his second consecutive Golden Boot with 26 goals and 17 assists in the regular season — remains available.

Tapia, who added a second goal after halftime alongside a Taha Habroune strike, declined to judge the call. “It’s a play in the match. I don’t know if it’s a red card, but I am not the referee to say,” he said. “It stays there.”

Miami coach Cristian “Kily” González echoed the restraint.

“The referee saw a yellow and that is it, we can’t blame the referee. Sometimes they make mistakes, sometimes they don’t like each one of us and we have to accept it,” he said.

“Pressure? Of course there is pressure,” Miami midfielder Casemiro said. “Inter Miami always plays to win and we know if we lose the next game we are out. So, that’s the pressure. The most important thing now is to be calm. We know we have to do better, because we can do better.”

Referee Allen Chapman told a pool reporter that the force Messi used was negligible and did not reach the threshold for violent conduct, according to SI.com.

The referee wasted little time showing the yellow card and insisted the incident did not warrant a dismissal, leaving Messi available for Friday’s Game 2 in Columbus.

Laurent Courtois arrived at Columbus Crew Academy in 2019 and was named inaugural head coach of Columbus Crew 2 ahead of the 2022 MLS Next Pro season, guiding the reserve side to the championship and earning MLS Next Pro Coach of the Year honors.

He departed to become head coach of CF Montréal in January 2024, leading the club to an eighth-place Eastern Conference finish and a playoff berth before a penalty-shootout loss to Atlanta United, then was dismissed on 24 March 2025 after a five-game winless start.

Columbus reappointed Courtois as interim head coach in 2025, and he has steered the Crew to the top of the MLS Cup playoffs with a 3-0 Game 1 rout of defending champion Inter Miami at Nu Stadium.

Asked whether Major League Soccer should review the incident, Crew coach Laurent Courtois described the entire situation as “sad,” according to ESPN. The Columbus manager had already told reporters that everyone knew the offense deserved more than a yellow card and later called it “just sad, really sad.”

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Julia Minkin Turns Columbus Night Into Singalong at The Spacebar

Reporter: Rodriguez Confronted Alley After WVU Loss to Houston