Critics Divided on Tarantino and Fincher’s ‘Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth

Quentin Tarantino wrote it, David Fincher directed it, and Brad Pitt is back as Cliff Booth — the Oscar-winning stuntman from “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood” — in “The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth,” a sequel set in 1977 Los Angeles that opens in US and UK cinemas on Wednesday, November 25, hits Australian theaters on November 26, and lands on Netflix on December 23.

Here is the kicker: the film almost didn’t exist. Tarantino has never fully committed to writing a sequel to one of his own works, and this follow-up exists mainly because Pitt, with Tarantino’s permission, passed the screenplay to Fincher — one of his most famous longtime collaborators — when the project came close to being nothing more than a dream, as DiscussingFilm reported.

A script written by Tarantino and adapted by another filmmaker is something Hollywood hasn’t seen since the ’90s.

And the critics can’t agree on what to make of the result. The Guardian’s review calls it an “outrageous sugar-rush sequel” with “a huge amount of energy, fun, scabrous black comedy, provocative bad taste and film-making style,” while also flagging a truncated ending — a function, the review suggests, of the story being spread across film and a forthcoming Tarantino novel about Cliff.

Meanwhile, RogerEbert.com found the mash-up of two voices “shockingly leaden and even boring at times,” concluding that “Elmore Leonard would be bored.”

The Bottom Line

  • Pitt’s Cliff Booth is now a Hollywood fixer in 1977, eight years after the first film, working as a projectionist at the New Beverly Cinema and a bartender.
  • Elizabeth Debicki’s talent agent Karen Crosby is widely the standout, with chemistry with Pitt that The Hollywood Reporter calls “off the charts.”
  • Reviews split: IndieWire graded it B-, ScreenCrush gave it 8/10, DiscussingFilm three stars, and RogerEbert.com was the harshest.

Two Directors, One Cliff Booth

The setting is 1977 — the Los Angeles of “Boogie Nights” and Jimmy Carter’s presidency — with Cliff having grown a moustache, quit the stunt business after an injury that gives him a slight limp, and moved in with his cantankerous pawnshop-proprietor dad Gus, played by Peter Weller.

The Guardian reported that Cliff now presides over a portfolio of side-hustles: projectionist at the New Beverly (a coyly proprietorial touch, since Tarantino owns the real theater), bartender, demolition derby worker, and — most importantly — discreet fixer for influential people being extorted.

The plot kicks in when Karen Crosby, a willowy talent agent once mentored by Pauline Kael, contacts Cliff out of the blue and introduces him to her client Charlie Peters (Scott Caan), a TV actor whose wife Toni (Carla Gugino) once held a certain allure for Cliff.

Cliff agrees to a difficult job for Charlie, and the film slides into a world of violent crime. The Guardian said that Tarantino appears to have folded his idea for a movie-critic character — once planned as his “final” movie — into Karen.

Yahoo’s review, filed from Los Angeles on November 19, observed that Tarantino’s dialogue is about Cliff sizing people up and Karen sizing Cliff up: even off-topic chatter is Cliff getting information or letting people incriminate themselves.

Where the Critics Split

The disagreement comes down to whether the film is a hangout or a haul. RogerEbert.com argued it’s “at its best when it’s actually trying to be a hangout movie” — Cliff watching TV with his dad, flirting with Debicki — but called the whole “a mash-up of two voices that never find harmony,” comparing it to “watching someone dance who can’t hear the rhythm of the music being played behind them.”

The Hollywood Reporter took the opposite tack, calling the film “sexy, seductive and chaotic in mostly fun ways” and crediting Pitt’s “star wattage, shit-eating grin and cowboy gait” as the key ingredient binding together a movie that “seldom meets an abrupt tangent it declines to explore.”

IGN, for its part, called this Fincher’s “least emotionally grueling film to date” and his “most fun (and funniest) movie,” while warning that its leisurely pacing and abrupt conclusion may divide viewers.

IndieWire graded it B- and described a “muted but fascinating tug-of-war” between Tarantino’s past-tense romanticism and Fincher’s unsentimental technique — a tension, IndieWire noted, that the scratchy “vintage” Netflix logo at the start articulates better than anything else in the film.

The Numbers on the Marquee

One thing every outlet agrees on is the release strategy: a short theatrical window before streaming. RogerEbert.com and IGN both confirmed the film opens in IMAX theaters on Wednesday, November 25, before moving to Netflix on December 23 — a two-week theatrical run, as RogerEbert.com put it.

(L-R) Brad Pitt as Cliff Booth and Elizabeth Debicki as Karen Crosby in The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth
Photo: The Hollywood Reporter
Outlet Verdict Release framing
IndieWire Grade: B- IMAX theaters Nov. 25; Netflix Dec. 23
ScreenCrush 8/10 IMAX theaters Nov. 25; Netflix Dec. 23
DiscussingFilm ★★★☆☆ Theaters Nov. 25; Netflix Dec. 23
The Hollywood Reporter “Sexy, seductive and chaotic in mostly fun ways” In theaters Nov. 25; streaming Dec. 23
RogerEbert.com “Elmore Leonard would be bored” In theaters two weeks from Nov. 25; Netflix Dec. 23

Netflix releasing a Tarantino-scripted, Fincher-directed picture with a two-week IMAX window before it hits the streamer is an unusual play for a sequel — and the critics’ mixed grades suggest the film is charming but far from a surefire hit.

ScreenCrush noted the film carries both Tarantino’s nostalgic needle drops (Boz Scaggs’ “Lowdown” kicks off the end credits, per The Hollywood Reporter) and a moody jazz score from Fincher’s longtime composers Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross. DiscussingFilm confirmed the crew: cinematographer Erik Messerschmidt, editor Kirk Baxter, production company Plan B Entertainment.

Debicki Steals the Room

If there’s a consensus breakout, it’s Elizabeth Debicki. The Hollywood Reporter called her “in sublime command of her powers” — using her native Australian accent and her imposing height for once — and said her chemistry with Pitt is “off the charts.”

DiscussingFilm went further, writing that Debicki “almost runs away with the whole film” as a femme fatale of sorts for Booth, getting the best material from Tarantino’s script. The Guardian reported that Cliff falls passionately in love with Karen, and Yahoo noted the flirtations follow a pattern of mutual evasion until the pair find a mutual fetish that doesn’t require anyone to be unfaithful.

Weller, meanwhile, “steals the movie just sitting in Cliff’s living room,” per Yahoo’s review. And ScreenCrush flagged the Verdusco brothers — played by Matt Groove and JB Tadena — as a threat whose introduction is a clever callback to the first film.

What the Sequel Leaves Unsaid

The loudest silence in the film is the question that haunted the original: whether Cliff murdered his wife. The Guardian reported that throughout the film’s 140 minutes the subject is “tactfully passed over in silence,” the one point that damages Cliff’s amiable-cowpoke good nature, with the full picture possibly reserved for Tarantino’s forthcoming Cliff Booth novel — a multimedia narrative event the film is designed to join.

IndieWire observed that Cliff remains a man who “spontaneously killed his own wife in the span of a shrugged-off flashback” and beat up Bruce Lee in a backstory Tarantino can’t quite bring himself to disavow.

The Hollywood Reporter’s bottom line: Pitt’s “star wattage” is “dialed up to maximum magnetism.” IndieWire put it more succinctly — “It’s all a big goof, which is exactly why he’ll kill you for getting in the way of a good story.”

Fincher, born in 1962, made his feature debut with “Alien 3” in 1992 and broke through with “Seven” three years later, going on to direct “Fight Club,” “Zodiac” and “Gone Girl” — films that have collectively grossed over $2.1 billion worldwide. His three Oscar nominations for Best Director came for “The Curious Case of Benjamin Button,” “The Social Network” and “Mank.”

Before features, he co-founded Propaganda Films in 1986 and won two MTV Video Music Awards for directing Madonna’s “Express Yourself” and “Vogue,” plus two Grammys for Best Music Video. His Netflix ties run deep: he won a Primetime Emmy for directing the “House of Cards” pilot and co-created “Love, Death & Robots.”

You can judge for yourself starting Wednesday, November 25, in US and UK cinemas, Thursday, November 26, in Australia, or from December 23 on Netflix.

The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth Review — IGN

Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

Instagram Rolls Out Story Edit Feature for 15 Minutes, but Reshares May Be Lost

Nintendo Drops Switch 2 Mario Kart Bundle to $499.99 for Black Friday