Democratic lawmakers are preparing to challenge President Donald Trump’s immigration enforcement tactics as they take control of both chambers of Congress, following midterm election gains fueled by voter dissatisfaction with mass deportations.
Arizona Senator Ruben Gallego said on Wednesday that his party will have to cut deals with the administration, noting that members were already discussing how to move forward with a Dreamers bill by the end of 2026.
Democrats Plan to Scrutinize Department of Homeland Security Spending
When the new Congress convenes on January 3, 2027, Democrats plan to utilize committee investigations and subpoenas to scrutinize how the Department of Homeland Security manages its immigration agenda. House members are pushing for greater transparency into how the department is spending funding, including a roughly $70 billion cash infusion approved in June to bankroll the agency through the end of the president’s term.
Congressional staff have already compiled a list of investigative targets within the Department of Homeland Security, including the use of fatal force by federal agents, conditions inside detention centers, and the 2025 deportation of Venezuelans to a Salvadoran megaprison.

Moderate Democrats are focusing on the ICE Standards Act, which was introduced in March by New Jersey Representative Josh Gottheimer. The legislation seeks to place guardrails on the agency, which has become the highest federally-funded law enforcement body in the U.S. Agents need real training and body cameras, said Gottheimer.
They need to wear clear identification unless they are on an undercover operation. They must coordinate with state and local law enforcement.
Negotiating Immigration Reform
Texas Congressman Henry Cuellar, a moderate Democrat, has expressed confidence that the recent midterm results could open doors to reform. Following the election, Cuellar reached out to acting Immigration and Customs Enforcement director David Venturella and Customs and Border Protection commissioner Rodney Scott to identify areas of common ground.
Cuellar, who represents a border district in Laredo, has also reached out to DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin to express a willingness to work together.
“We're not going to be extreme,” Texas Congressman Henry Cuellar, a moderate Democrat, said.
“I'm not going to abolish ICE,” Texas Congressman Henry Cuellar, a moderate Democrat, said.

Houston Democratic Congresswoman Sylvia Garcia said that families are being separated daily, adding, I think we can get it done and get it done now. Why wait? San Antonio Congressman Joaquin Castro echoed this sentiment, asserting that the American public rebuked the administration’s mass deportation campaign at the ballot box.
However, experts like James Hollifield, a political science professor at Southern Methodist University, warn that the Republican Party remains closely aligned with the administration’s hardline agenda. It’s still a very hardcore Trump group, MAGA group, and I don’t think that they will be in a mood to reach across the aisle and pass a bipartisan immigration reform, Hollifield said.
Legislative Pathways Offer Permanent Status and Border Security Reform
Democrats intend to explore legislative pathways, such as the American Dream and Promise Act, which was reintroduced in 2025 to provide Dreamers under DACA the opportunity to apply for permanent legal status.
Another potential vehicle is the Dignity Act, a bipartisan bill that would create a path to legal residence for workers while simultaneously tightening border security and reforming visa programs. This bipartisan bill would create a path to legal residence for workers, and it would also tighten border security and reform visa programs.
According to Jose Parra, a former U.S. Senate aide, voters effectively moved the goalposts during the midterm elections, potentially creating space for these stalled bills to advance. However, success remains uncertain.
Administration Maintains Immigration Policy Despite Potential Strategy Changes
The administration maintains that its immigration policy has not changed, despite President Trump acknowledging in a 60 Minutes interview that his deportation strategy may have been “too tough.” When asked about potential deals with Democrats, the president suggested that a deal was doable, stating, Well, the deal would be we would work something out.

Eric Holguín, Texas state director for UnidosUS, warned that Latino voters are watching closely. They’re put on notice right now, Holguín said, noting that maintaining support will depend on Democrats delivering concrete results.
Texas Democrat Veronica Escobar, while identifying as a pragmatist, emphasized the long-term vision: If we can get this passed this upcoming Congress, we can do even more in 2028 to grow and expand what we can do for immigrants, immigrant families, and our economy and our communities.
Earlier coverage: Democrats Secure House Majority as Trump Loses Political Ground