Experts Say Regular Soap Beats Antibacterial for Everyday Use

Antibacterial soap is unnecessary for everyday hand hygiene and standard cold and flu season prevention, as regular soap and water work just as well without harming your skin microbiome. Experts recommend reserving antimicrobial soaps for specific situations, such as certain skin conditions or healthcare settings, The Washington Post reported.

When should you use regular soap?

Your skin contains millions of hair follicles, sweat glands, and oil glands that house various microbes, including bacteria, viruses, fungi, and microscopic mites. While some microbes can cause disease, most are beneficial and form a protective living layer known as your skin microbiome.

Research has not shown any real advantage to using antimicrobial soaps at home, though healthcare settings recommend them. Regular soap and water trap germs and carry them down the drain when worked into a lather for at least 20 seconds.

Both Gallo and Dunnick recommend regular soap for general hand hygiene. Regular soap and water also remain the standard recommendation during cold and flu season.

Researchers have not found that antimicrobial soap works better than regular soap at preventing the spread of disease-causing germs at home. One study comparing plain soap and antibacterial soap found no greater effectiveness for the antibacterial version against 20 bacterial strains, and other research suggests the same holds true for viruses.

Using unnecessary antimicrobial soap daily over long periods can harm the natural skin microbiome and potentially contribute to antibiotic resistance, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

“You may diminish your skin’s ability to fight those germs.”

However, when covid, the flu, or a stomach bug hits a household, antimicrobials used for just a few days are unlikely to cause problems. Gallo said that this short-term use could theoretically help decrease the risk of disease transmission to family members.

How should you treat cuts and scrapes?

The CDC recommends rinsing cuts and scrapes with clean water or saline, then gently washing the surrounding skin with soap and water. The World Health Organization instructs people not to use antibiotic solutions to wash wounds.

Reeder suggests keeping wounds moist with petroleum jelly instead.

Can antimicrobial cleansers help with acne?

Excessive oil and dead skin cells clog pores and feed skin bacteria, which causes redness, swelling, and pimples.

Benzoyl peroxide does not carry the risk of leading to antibiotic resistance like other antimicrobials. Because it can cause skin irritation, Dunnick recommends using it as a wash rather than a leave-on ointment, and suggests using these cleansers in the shower because peroxide can bleach towels and clothes.

Antimicrobial cleansers may also treat folliculitis, a common condition where hair follicles become inflamed or infected and form small, red bumps. Mild cases can be treated at home using over-the-counter antibacterial body washes containing benzoyl peroxide or chlorhexidine, or shampoos containing selenium sulfide.

These antimicrobial washes reduce surface skin bacteria and decrease the chances that other follicles will get infected, Gallo said. Severe cases may require prescription antibiotics.

Overall, antimicrobial soaps can help treat certain skin conditions, but people should only use them when directed by a healthcare professional. Reeder warns against trying to diagnose and treat a new or worsening skin condition independently.

Photo of author

Health Desk

Health Desk at Archyde.

Reports: Miley Cyrus Marries Maxx Morando in Palm Springs Ceremony

Eleven-Year-old Harriet Harris Nearly Died Three Times Due to a Severe Nut Allergy