Florida to Break Annual Execution Record With Death of Thomas Overton

Florida plans to put Thomas M. Overton to death at 6 p.m. Thursday at Florida State Prison, and with him the state will break its own execution record — 20 in a single year, one more than the 19 carried out in 2025.

Overton, 71, has maintained his innocence since his 1999 sentencing for the 1991 murders of Michael and Susan “Missy” MacIvor, a Tavernier couple in the Florida Keys. Susan MacIvor was eight months pregnant; Overton was also convicted in the death of their unborn son. His attorneys say untested evidence and possible third-party guilt remain unresolved, Truthout reported.

The pace is the story. Before 2025, Florida’s modern annual record was eight executions. Gov. Ron DeSantis signed 19 death warrants in 2025, then matched that record on Nov. 5 with the execution of Jesse Guardado. Overton would be the 38th execution in the United States this year, and Florida alone will have carried out more than the rest of the country combined.

DPI
Photo: deathpenaltyinfo.org

“Executing Overton would violate his right to Due Process and be a manifest injustice because there remains a great deal of untested evidence and inconclusive evidence that must be retested,” his attorneys wrote in a motion to vacate filed Oct. 28 in Monroe County circuit court.

The motion also argues there is “information that was never disclosed to Overton regarding potential third-party guilt” that “would independently support Overton’s actual innocence claim,” Truthout reported. The Florida Supreme Court denied the motion on Nov. 13, writing there was “no need to stay Overton’s execution,” and declined to rehear additional motions. A stay application filed Nov. 14 is pending before the U.S. Supreme Court.

A veterinarian tested the evidence

The integrity questions center on the county’s original investigation. Monroe County’s chief serologist was a veterinarian with no formal forensic training who took crime scene evidence home, tested it in his spare bedroom, stored it in his refrigerator, and showed it to a psychic who handled it with bare hands.

Overton has also alleged misconduct involving jailhouse informants. Two men incarcerated with him said he confessed to breaking into the MacIvor home, court records show.

Even the sentence itself carries marks that would not survive in most of the country. Overton’s jury voted 9–3 and 8–4 for death — non-unanimous votes that would mean a life sentence in every other state today.

And he instructed his attorneys to present no mitigation evidence at all; the Florida Supreme Court noted in a 2001 opinion that he “unequivocally stated on several occasions that he did not want his attorneys to present any mitigating evidence.”

A Dozier survivor on death row

Overton’s biography traces two paths common on Florida’s death row. As a teenager he was sent to the Dozier School for Boys, the state reform school where officials are still investigating unmarked graves and for which Florida has formally apologized and authorized reparations.

At least 34 Dozier survivors later landed on death row, the Marshall Project found last year; Overton will be at least the 12th to be executed. He also served in the Army from 1973 to 1975, and Florida has sentenced more veterans to death — 119 — than any other state.

“Florida’s acknowledgement of the abuse at Dozier must extend to mercy for the men who survived it,” said Grace Hanna, executive director of Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty.

Hanna’s group says the new motion documents “extraordinary failures” in the original investigation. “Thomas Overton’s case sounds outrageous, but the reality is that Florida routinely sends people to death row based on unreliable evidence and deeply flawed investigation,” she told Truthout.

DeSantis says the pace serves victims

The governor has framed the accelerated schedule as justice delayed. He issued just eight death warrants between 2019 and 2024, then ramped up sharply after President Donald Trump’s 2025 executive order urging prosecutors to seek the death penalty more often.

Overton’s would be the 39th execution in Florida in two years. And it still would not approach the modern national record — Texas executed 40 people in 2000.

DeSantis, born in 1978 in Jacksonville, has been Florida’s 46th governor since 2019. A Yale graduate and Harvard Law School alumnus, he joined the U.S. Navy in 2004 and served in the Judge Advocate General’s Corps, including a 2007 deployment to Iraq, before being elected to Congress in 2012, where he became a founding member of the Freedom Caucus.

He won the governorship in 2018 by 0.4 percentage points, then won reelection in 2022 by 19.4 points — the largest margin in a gubernatorial race since 1982. He ran for the Republican presidential nomination in 2023 before withdrawing in January 2024 and endorsing Donald Trump.

Two more men follow within weeks. Ricardo Gonzalez, convicted of the 1992 murder of North Miami police officer Steven Bauer, is set for Dec. 1, and Willie Seth Crain Jr., convicted of the 1998 murder of 7-year-old Amanda Brown, is scheduled for Dec. 19. Overton’s lethal injection begins at 6 p.m. Thursday at Florida State Prison in Raiford, about 45 miles southwest of Jacksonville.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Satya Nadella Says Critical Infrastructure Is ‘Unpatchable’ as AI Makes Cyberattacks Easier

SF Health Plan Workers Allege Retaliation, Seek Executive Pay Transparency