Plant-based eating looks harder than it is: fewer than 5% of US and UK adults do it, and dietitians speaking this week said the difficulty is mostly perceived.
The stakes of closing that gap are large. A 2021 study found meat accounts for nearly 60% of all greenhouse gases from food production, and a 2025 report estimated animal agriculture is responsible for 12% to 19% of total human-caused greenhouse gases, The Guardian reported in laying out the United Nations’ position that shifting from a meat-heavy diet to a more plant-based one is one of the best things an individual can do for their carbon footprint.
Yet fewer than 5% of adults in the US and UK identify as vegetarian or vegan. The biggest obstacle, according to experts The Guardian interviewed, is a belief that the switch is too hard.
“Adopting a whole new lifestyle can feel daunting, especially when you’ve been eating a certain way your entire life,” said Alyssa Fontaine, a registered dietitian and nutritionist, a vegan, and founder of Plant-Based Dietitians USA & Canada.
In Fontaine’s experience, people worry a plant-based diet means missing essential nutrients and giving up dishes and traditions they enjoy. Neither has to be the case, she said.
Plant-Based Diet Focuses on Plants and Excludes Meat
- Plant-based means mostly plants — fruits, vegetables, nuts, legumes, whole grains, seeds — and typically excludes meat and dairy. You do not have to change everything at once.
- Protein is not the problem. Beans, soy, tofu, peas and nuts cover it when meals are planned.
- One nutrient genuinely needs attention: vitamin B12, which plants do not make. Fortified foods and, where needed, supplements close the gap.
Not Every Plant-Based Eater Is Vegan
A plant-based diet consists primarily of plants. Veganism is broader. The Vegan Society, the world’s oldest vegan charity, coined the term in 1944 and defines veganism as a way of living seeking to exclude — as far as possible and practicable — all forms of exploitation of animals for food, clothing or any other purpose.
“Veganism is not simply a diet devoid of animal foods, but a social justice movement, value and belief system that includes animals when considering how others ought to be treated,” said Taylor Wolfram, a registered dietitian and longtime vegan.
A person eating plant-based may not call themselves vegan and could still buy wool or leather, Wolfram’s position holds.
What the Health Record Shows
Plant-based diets are associated with a decreased risk of cardiovascular disease and a lower risk of type 2 diabetes, along with decreased likelihood of prostate, breast and colorectal cancers, according to the peer-reviewed reviews The Guardian’s reporting draws on.
Mechanistically — that is, in how the effect works — these diets tend to be lower in saturated fat and cholesterol and higher in fiber, antioxidants and phytochemicals, the plant compounds that act as antioxidants in the body.
Fontaine said the biggest change she sees in clients transitioning from an omnivorous diet is fiber intake.
“When we replace meat with plant-based protein sources, such as legumes, nuts and seeds, we’re also adding fiber to our diet,” said Fontaine. “Eating a fiber-rich diet can make a huge difference in improving digestion and bowel regularity.”
That matters at population scale: a survey by the American Gastroenterological Association found 40% to 50% of Americans struggle with digestive issues.
The Protein Question, Answered
The most common misconception, Fontaine said, is that plant-based eating shortchanges protein. Damien Watson, spokesperson for the Vegan Society, gets the question constantly.
“‘Where do you get your protein?’ If I had a pound for every time someone asked me that question …” said Watson, whose protein comes primarily from beans, soy, tofu, peas and nuts.
“Inadequate protein intake is not a concern on a vegan or plant-based diet when the diet is properly planned,” said Sue-Ellen Anderson-Hayes, spokesperson for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, who added that nutritional deficiencies occur “across dietary patterns without proper planning”.
Wolfram points to high-performing athletes on plant-based diets — soccer star Alex Morgan, Formula One driver Lewis Hamilton and NBA player Chris Paul — as further evidence.
The Environmental Ledger
Watson points to a 2023 study in Nature Food comparing vegan diets with high-meat diets. The coverage does not identify the funders of the 2021 study or the 2025 report on greenhouse gas emissions.
| Measure vs. high-meat diets | Reduction with vegan diets |
|---|---|
| Greenhouse gas emissions | 75% lower |
| Biodiversity loss | 66% lower |
| Water use | 54% lower |
Industrial farms also face criticism for keeping animals in inhumane conditions, the reporting notes.
Starting With Swaps, Not Overhauls
The practical advice converges on gradual substitution. “I recommend substituting some animal foods with plant foods,” Wolfram advised — black bean tacos instead of beef, soy milk instead of dairy milk, tofu stir-fries.
“It doesn’t have to be complicated,” said Wolfram.
Anderson-Hayes concurs: baby steps, progress over perfection, and no expectation that every day looks the same.
Fontaine’s structured tool is the “vegan go-to 10 method”: find 10 vegan meals you love and repeat them until preparation becomes second nature. Once those are in place, planning, shopping and cooking get much easier, she said. Spending extra time on meal prep and new cooking skills at the start makes a big difference.
Eating out is easier than it used to be. “It is rare now to find a restaurant that doesn’t offer a vegan option, and most supermarkets have whole sections devoted to plant-based food,” said Watson. Anderson-Hayes recommends checking menus beforehand and looking for black bean burgers, black bean and corn salad, hummus, or falafel.
Four Nutrients That Need a Plan
Vitamin B12 tops the list. It supports the nervous system and is not made by plants, Watson said, so vegans must be conscientious about fortified foods or supplements. Anderson-Hayes also suggests regularly consuming sea vegetables or seaweed for iodine, and fortified foods such as nutritional yeast and soy milk for vitamin D and calcium.
Consult a Dietitian for Personalized Nutrition Planning
A plant-based diet can be healthy, nutritious and sustainable, but it is not one-size-fits-all, Fontaine said. “Everyone is at a different stage of life and has different nutritional needs.” People at different life stages, or managing existing health conditions, should work with a registered dietitian rather than self-design the diet, the experts agree.
Anderson-Hayes’s warning cuts both ways: nutritional deficiencies occur in all dietary patterns without proper planning, so an unplanned plant-based diet carries the same class of risk as any other unplanned diet.
If a dietitian is outside the budget, Wolfram recommends reputable free resources such as VeganHealth.org. “It’s written by vegan, registered dietitians,” she said.
Where This Leaves the 5%
The contrast at the heart of this story remains unresolved: the environmental and health case is documented down to the percentage point, while adoption sits under 5% in two of the countries most exposed to the messaging.
“For me, personally, being vegan means that I live my life, as much as I can, doing no harm,” said Watson. “That’s good for my emotional wellbeing, as well as good for my physical health, and that of other living creatures and the world we inhabit.”
References
- A 2023 study — comparative study of vegan and high-meat diets’ environmental impacts.