Israel’s Systematic Deprivation of Gaza: A Historical Pattern with Unique Characteristics

Gaza Famine: Israel Holds the Key, Despite Aid Efforts, Experts Warn

Gaza City – A looming famine in Gaza is not a result of logistical failures, but a direct result of Israel’s control over aid access and sustained obstruction of humanitarian efforts, experts are warning. Despite international concern and aid deliveries through Egypt, Israel maintains effective veto power over what reaches Palestinians, turning the Gaza Strip into a “vacuum-sealed” territory, according to recent analysis.

While Egypt facilitates aid passage through its Rafah border crossing, all shipments are subject to Israeli inspection, creating a critical bottleneck. This control allows Israel to “hamper or entirely reject” life-saving assistance, a practice that violates international law, sources say.”What is unique about the Israeli one is just how rigorous and how sustained it is, and how it is in defiance of an international humanitarian capacity that can respond just like that,” stated Alex de Waal, a leading expert on famine. he emphasized that preventing widespread starvation is entirely within Israel’s power: “If Netanyahu wanted every [child in Gaza] to have breakfast tomorrow, it can be organized.”

The situation highlights a stark contrast with demonstrated capabilities for rapid humanitarian response when political will exists. Last year,a polio outbreak – the first in Gaza in 25 years,triggered by the deteriorating conditions of the war – prompted international pressure on Israel to agree to a humanitarian pause for a vaccination campaign. This resulted in a remarkably accomplished effort, reaching 95% of the target population.

“This demonstrates the capacity to efficiently address critical health needs even amidst conflict,” a WHO representative commented, suggesting a similar approach could avert widespread malnutrition.

However, experts caution that even with an immediate ceasefire and full aid access, the damage is already extensive. “Even if there was divine intervention… I think we’d still have hundreds [or] thousands of deaths,” warned Dr. Sarah Gordon, a humanitarian aid worker. “But we’re not going to have that divine intervention.”

Evergreen Insights:

The Weaponization of Aid: The Gaza crisis underscores a disturbing trend in modern conflict: the intentional obstruction of humanitarian aid as a tactic of war. This practice, while not unique to Israel, is being executed with unprecedented rigor in Gaza.
The Role of Border Control: The case highlights the critical importance of border access and control in humanitarian crises. When one party maintains absolute control over entry points, it effectively dictates who receives assistance and when. Humanitarian Pauses as a Model: The successful polio vaccination campaign offers a blueprint for future interventions. Targeted humanitarian pauses, even during active conflict, can be highly effective in delivering essential aid and preventing outbreaks.
International Law and Accountability: The deliberate hindering of aid delivery raises serious questions about adherence to international humanitarian law and the potential for accountability for violations.

How has the past context of the Nakba shaped the ongoing deprivation experienced by Palestinians in Gaza?

The Roots of Deprivation: Post-1948 Displacement & Initial Restrictions

The establishment of Israel in May 1948, while fulfilling a long-held Zionist dream, concurrently resulted in the displacement of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians – an event known as the Nakba (catastrophe). (Deutschlandfunk, 2024). This initial displacement laid the groundwork for decades of restrictions on Palestinian movement and economic progress, particularly impacting the Gaza Strip. Early restrictions focused on land ownership and access to resources, effectively marginalizing the Palestinian population. The 1956 Suez Crisis saw Israel briefly occupy Gaza, further solidifying control and initiating a pattern of military intervention impacting civilian life. These early actions, while often framed within a security context, established a precedent for limiting palestinian self-determination and economic prosperity.

The Oslo Accords & the Illusion of Progress (1993-2000)

The Oslo Accords offered a brief period of optimism, envisioning a two-state solution and increased Palestinian autonomy. However, the agreements ultimately failed to deliver lasting improvements in Gaza’s economic situation. While some limited industrial zones were established, the fundamental restrictions on movement of people and goods remained.

Limited Sovereignty: The Palestinian Authority (PA) lacked full control over borders,trade,and security,hindering economic development.

Dependence on Israel: Gaza’s economy remained heavily reliant on Israel for imports, exports, and employment opportunities for Gazan workers in israel. This created a vulnerable economic structure susceptible to Israeli policy changes.

Settlement Expansion: Continued Israeli settlement expansion in the West Bank diverted resources and further complicated the prospects for a viable Palestinian state.

The Blockade & its Escalating Impact (2007 – Present)

Following Hamas’s victory in the 2006 Palestinian elections and subsequent takeover of Gaza in 2007, Israel, with Egyptian cooperation, imposed a comprehensive blockade on the Gaza Strip. This blockade, justified by Israel as a security measure to prevent weapons from reaching hamas, has had a devastating impact on Gaza’s economy and humanitarian situation.

Key Aspects of the Gaza Blockade:

1. Restrictions on Movement: Severe limitations on the movement of people in and out of Gaza, effectively creating an open-air prison.Permits for medical treatment,education,and family visits are often denied or delayed.
2. control of Goods: Strict control over the entry of goods, including essential supplies like food, medicine, and construction materials. dual-use items (those with potential military applications) are heavily restricted, hindering reconstruction efforts and industrial development.
3. Fishing Zone Restrictions: Repeatedly reduced fishing zones limit the ability of Gazan fishermen to earn a livelihood and access vital food sources.
4. Economic Collapse: The blockade has led to a dramatic decline in Gaza’s GDP, soaring unemployment rates (over 50%), and widespread poverty.

Unique Characteristics of the Deprivation in Gaza:

Demographic Pressure: Gaza is one of the most densely populated areas in the world, exacerbating the impact of the blockade and limited resources.

Repeated Military Offensives: Multiple large-scale military operations (e.g., 2008-2009, 2012, 2014, 2021, 2023) have caused widespread destruction of infrastructure, loss of life, and psychological trauma.

infrastructure Collapse: Years of blockade and conflict have severely damaged Gaza’s infrastructure, including its power grid, water supply, and sewage systems. This has led to chronic shortages of electricity, clean water, and sanitation.

Humanitarian Crisis: The combination of these factors has created a severe humanitarian crisis, with a large proportion of the population dependent on international aid.

The Role of International Law & Human Rights

Numerous international organizations,including the United Nations and human rights groups,have condemned the blockade of Gaza as a violation of international law.

Collective Punishment: Critics argue that the blockade constitutes collective punishment of the civilian population, which is prohibited under international humanitarian law.

Right to Development: The restrictions on economic activity and movement impede the Palestinians’ right to development.

Access to Essential Services: The denial of access to essential services like healthcare and education violates fundamental human rights.

Case Study: The Impact on Gaza’s Healthcare System

Gaza’s healthcare system has been brought to the brink of collapse by the blockade. Shortages of essential medicines, medical equipment, and electricity severely limit the ability of hospitals to provide adequate care. The restrictions on movement prevent patients from accessing specialized treatment outside of Gaza, and medical personnel from receiving training and professional development. The 2023 conflict further decimated the healthcare infrastructure, leaving it barely functional.

Keywords & Related search Terms:

Gaza Blockade

Israel-Palestine Conflict

Palestinian Displacement (Nakba)

Humanitarian Crisis in Gaza

International Law & Gaza

gaza Economy

*