James Gray’s Paper Tiger Follows Two Brothers in 1986 New York

Brothers blunder into violence in 1986 New York in James Gray’s punishing tragedy “Paper Tiger.”

The film opens with a sweeping view of New York in 1986, narrowing in on two brothers named Pearl in Queens. The eldest, Gary (Adam Driver), is a retired police officer turned security consultant with swagger, a Mercedes, and financial strain from an expensive divorce.

His younger brother, Irwin (Miles Teller), is an environmental engineer and ordinary dad making storm windows for the winter while facing the looming cost of college for his two kids.

James Gray, Adam Driver, and Miles Teller on Paper Tiger — Film at Lincoln Center

Set in 1986 Queens, “Paper Tiger” follows Irwin Pearl (Miles Teller), an environmental engineer and family man running a small business while raising two sons with his wife, Hester (Scarlett Johansson). As Irwin and his wife, Hester (Scarlett Johansson), bustle about helping with the meal, Gary chats up their sons, the teenage Scott (Gavin Goudey) and younger Benjamin (Roman Engel).

Irwin is married to Hester (Scarlett Johansson), a practical and spirited woman who fantasizes about suburban life. When Gary visits Irwin’s modest home, he drops by with a steak dinner from Luger’s and proposes a risky business opportunity involving the redevelopment of the Gowanus Canal (The New York Times, Yahoo News Canada).

James Gray and Jim Jarmusch on Paper Tiger, the Mafia, and Capturing New York City — Film at Lincoln Center

Russian immigrants are taking over businesses once controlled by the mafia around the canal, and Gary suggests he and Irwin consult for the outfit to help them follow regulations.

Although Irwin wonders if the scheme is shady, Gary dismisses his concerns.

James gray paper tiger
Photo: theplaylist.net

Tragedy in 1986 Queens

As the brothers blunder into violence, Hester quietly endures a secret health crisis of her own, acting as a physical manifestation of the polluted canal while bearing the weight of a death sentence in private. The film builds to a showdown near a local airport, embracing the omnipresent sound of planes taking off and landing.

Autobiographical Roots

Director James Gray developed the project as a continuation of his deeply personal film “Armageddon Time,” drawing on his own family history and his parents’ struggles with financial ambition, legal troubles, and terminal illness. Gray has previously explored similar territory in films such as “Little Odessa,” “The Yards,” and “We Own the Night”.

James Gray on Why Filming Paper Tiger Felt Like a Time Machine — ComingSoon.net

Discussing the emotional foundations of the movie, Gray pointed to the dangers of good intentions and how love gets tangled up with pride and money. He said that comparing abstract art to human suffering reveals deeper truths about modern life.

Release and Rating

Distributed by Neon, the 115-minute film arrives in select theaters on Friday before expanding nationwide on November 20, 2026. The Motion Picture Association rated the movie R for language and some violence.

Paper Tiger – Official Trailer – In Theaters November — NEON
Photo of author

Marina Collins - Entertainment Editor

Senior Editor, Entertainment Marina is a celebrated pop culture columnist and recipient of multiple media awards. She curates engaging stories about film, music, television, and celebrity news, always with a fresh and authoritative voice.

Childlight Reports 8,400% Rise in AI Child Abuse Material Cases

Darius Garland Scores 27, Clippers Defeat Hornets 113-105